Anyone wishing to get a divorce in Germany must, as a general rule, have lived apart for one year before the family court can dissolve the marriage. This is set out in Section 1565(2) of the German Civil Code (BGB). In very limited exceptional cases, however, this one-year separation period may be waived if it would be unreasonable to expect one spouse to remain in the marriage. The Federal Court of Justice has now clarified, in a default judgement dated 8 July 2026 (Case No. XII ZB 576/25), under what conditions this may be the case.
The case: violence, sexual abuse and a contested divorce petition
The couple had married in 2009. Shortly after the wedding, the husband had broken his wife’s nose and was convicted of a criminal offence as a result. Despite this, the two kept getting back together. In January 2025, the husband sexually assaulted their daughter, who was six years old at the time. He admitted to the incident, apologised and subsequently moved out of the marital home. The wife subsequently filed for divorce before the end of the one-year separation period. She argued that, in light of these events, it was simply unreasonable to expect her to wait for the one-year separation period to elapse.
The Family Court rejected the application. The Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe upheld this decision. Whilst it regarded the incidents as serious, it considered that waiting a few more months was reasonable, as the man had moved out and was no longer in contact with his daughter. The court largely disregarded the earlier acts of violence, as the couple had reconciled at that time.
The Federal Court of Justice overturns the ruling and sets out the criteria for the assessment in more detail
The Federal Court of Justice took a different view and quashed the ruling of the Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe. It referred the case back for a fresh hearing. The Federal Court of Justice’s criticism was directed primarily at the isolated consideration of the individual incidents. Instead, the Higher Regional Court should have assessed all the circumstances of the case collectively and in their entirety.
Furthermore, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) criticised the fact that previous acts of violence had been deemed irrelevant solely because the woman had reconciled with her partner at the time. Reconciliation does not necessarily preclude previous assaults from being taken into account when assessing whether a case constitutes a hardship situation.
What the Federal Court of Justice has clarified for the future
The decision sets out three key guidelines for practice:
- Continuity despite physical separation:Serious misconduct, such as physical violence against a spouse or the sexual abuse of a minor child, may still be deemed unacceptable to the other spouse even if the couple have already separated and are no longer in contact.
- A holistic approach is essential:The court must assess all the relevant circumstances as a whole. An examination in which individual incidents are assessed in isolation and then dismissed on their own merits is not sufficient.
- Reconciliation is not a ground for exclusion:If spouses have reconciled following an assault, this does not mean that the incident may be disregarded in a subsequent assessment of hardship.
What does this mean for those affected?
Anyone affected by domestic violence in a marriage who is wondering whether a divorce is possible before the end of the one-year separation period should be aware of the recent Federal Court of Justice (BGH) ruling. It makes it clear that the courts are obliged to consider the full picture and not simply tick off individual incidents in isolation. However, whether the conditions set out in Section 1565(2) of the German Civil Code (BGB) are actually met always depends on the specific circumstances of each individual case. Legal advice is strongly recommended in such cases.
Source: Haufe: Law
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.