Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

BFH: Business owners and taxpayers should be aware of these new procedures

BFH: Business owners and taxpayers should be aware of these new procedures

In August 2026, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) accept­ed a num­ber of new cases for adju­di­ca­ti­on, which may have signi­fi­cant prac­ti­cal impli­ca­ti­ons for busi­ness owners, employees and pri­va­te indi­vi­du­als. We out­line the most important cases and explain why they are relevant.

Directors’ liability following departure

One par­ti­cu­lar­ly rele­vant case con­cerns the tax lia­bi­li­ty of for­mer mana­ging direc­tors (Ref. VII R 16/26). The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) is to cla­ri­fy whe­ther a for­mer mana­ging direc­tor can still be requi­red to sub­mit tax returns or tax decla­ra­ti­ons after lea­ving a com­pa­ny limi­t­ed by shares. Spe­ci­fi­cal­ly, the issue is whe­ther lia­bi­li­ty is limi­t­ed to obli­ga­ti­ons that alre­a­dy exis­ted at the time of lea­ving the com­pa­ny. For indi­vi­du­als who are step­ping down from, or have alre­a­dy step­ped down from, a mana­ging direc­tor role, this decis­i­on could have far-rea­ching consequences.

Hidden profit distributions in family employment relationships

Two cases deal with hid­den pro­fit dis­tri­bu­ti­ons, that is, bene­fits which a limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH) grants to its share­hol­der or rela­ted par­ties wit­hout ade­qua­te con­side­ra­ti­on. Case I R 9/26 con­cerns expen­ses ari­sing from an employ­ment rela­ti­onship bet­ween the GmbH and the daugh­ter of the share­hol­der-mana­ging direc­tor, as well as the pri­va­te use of a com­pa­ny car by that daugh­ter. Case VIII R 23/25 addres­ses the ques­ti­on of how con­tri­bu­ti­ons to a working time account held by a con­trol­ling share­hol­der-mana­ging direc­tor should be trea­ted for tax pur­po­ses, and when exact­ly a pay­ment is dee­med to have been received.

Gift tax and property values

The­re are two pro­ce­du­res of par­ti­cu­lar signi­fi­can­ce for pro­per­ty owners and indi­vi­du­als who trans­fer or recei­ve pro­per­ty as part of a gift. Case II R 11/26 cla­ri­fies whe­ther, in the case of a co-owner­ship share, it can be demons­tra­ted that this share is worth less than the cal­cu­la­ted pro­por­ti­on of the total value of the pro­per­ty, and whe­ther, in the case of pro­per­ties encum­be­red by a usu­fruct, an addi­tio­nal dis­count should be reco­g­nis­ed due to redu­ced mar­ke­ta­bi­li­ty. A usu­fruct is a right in rem to use the pro­per­ty, which can signi­fi­cant­ly redu­ce the mar­ket value of a pro­per­ty. Case II R 20/26 con­cerns whe­ther a buil­ding plot is to be clas­si­fied as tax-pri­vi­le­ged busi­ness assets under the Inhe­ri­tance and Gift Tax Act.

Property tax: constitutional issues and flat ownership

Two cases con­cer­ning pro­per­ty tax are also pen­ding. Case II R 21/26 con­cerns the con­sti­tu­tio­na­li­ty of the Lower Sax­o­ny Pro­per­ty Tax Act. As seve­ral fede­ral sta­tes have intro­du­ced their own pro­per­ty tax models, rulings on this mat­ter could set a pre­ce­dent nati­on­wi­de. Case II R 14/26 is deter­mi­ning whe­ther, in the case of a sin­gle block of flats com­pri­sing seve­ral flats under civil law, a sin­gle pro­per­ty tax value should be deter­mi­ned or whe­ther a sepa­ra­te value should be estab­lished for each indi­vi­du­al flat.

Equalisation of accrued gains and private sales transactions

Case IX R 10/26 is of par­ti­cu­lar inte­rest to tho­se invol­ved in divorce pro­cee­dings. It con­cerns the ques­ti­on of whe­ther the trans­fer of pro­per­ty as part of a divorce sett­le­ment can be regard­ed as a taxa­ble pri­va­te sale if, at the same time, claims for main­ten­an­ce and equa­li­sa­ti­on of accrued gains are waived.

What does this mean for you?

Pen­ding Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) pro­cee­dings do not yet con­sti­tu­te final jud­ge­ments, but they do high­light which tax issues remain unre­sol­ved in prin­ci­ple at pre­sent. In ongo­ing pro­cee­dings invol­ving com­pa­ra­ble facts, it may be pos­si­ble to app­ly for the pro­cee­dings to be stay­ed until the BFH has rea­ched a decis­i­on. Anyo­ne affec­ted by any of the issues men­tio­ned should dis­cuss this with a tax or legal adviser.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this