Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Freedom of expression in the workplace: What employees are allowed to say and where the boundaries lie

What are employees allo­wed to say publicly about their employ­er? A recent court ruling high­lights the limits of free­dom of expres­si­on in the workplace. 
Freedom of expression in the workplace: What employees are allowed to say and where the boundaries lie

Freedom of expression in the workplace: What employees are allowed to say and where the boundaries lie

A DHL employee publicly cri­ti­cis­ed his employ­er for trans­port­ing arms on behalf of Rhein­me­tall. The company’s respon­se was to dis­miss him wit­hout noti­ce for an alle­ged breach of trade secrets. Howe­ver, the Leip­zig Labour Court ruled that the dis­mis­sal was unlawful. The cli­ent rela­ti­onship had long been public know­ledge; the employee had not made any fal­se claims and was the­r­e­fo­re rightful­ly entit­led to keep his job.

This case illus­tra­tes just how com­plex the issue of free­dom of expres­si­on is in the con­text of employ­ment, for both parties.

Fundamental protection under the Basic Law

Artic­le 5 of the Basic Law pro­tects free­dom of expres­si­on. This pro­tec­tion also appli­es in the con­text of employ­ment. The Fede­ral Labour Court cla­ri­fied as ear­ly as 2005 that employees are, in prin­ci­ple, free to express their opi­ni­ons, regard­less of whe­ther the state­ment is ratio­nal or emo­tio­nal (BAG, jud­ge­ment of 24 Novem­ber 2005, ref. 2 AZR 584/04). Inci­den­tal­ly, employ­ers also bene­fit from this pro­tec­tion: not every cri­ti­cal remark made by a mana­ger to staff auto­ma­ti­cal­ly con­sti­tu­tes an inf­rin­ge­ment of per­so­nal rights or work­place bullying.

Where do employees’ rights end?

Free­dom of expres­si­on is not a free pass for every kind of state­ment. The­re are clear limits:

  • Fal­se state­ments of factare excluded from the scope of free­dom of expres­si­on from the outset.
  • Insults, abu­si­ve cri­ti­cism and for­mal insultstowards supe­ri­ors or col­le­agues are not pro­tec­ted under Artic­le 5 of the Basic Law.
  • Public cri­ti­cism, which dama­ges the company’s repu­ta­ti­on or spreads rumours about the employer’s sol­ven­cy, may have con­se­quen­ces under employ­ment law.
  • Comm­ents on social mediaare con­side­red public, even if only a limi­t­ed group of peo­p­le can see the posts. The­re is always a risk of uncon­trol­led dissemination.

Internal criticism versus public statements

Whe­ther an expres­si­on of opi­ni­on is per­mis­si­ble depends, among­st other things, on whe­ther it is made intern­al­ly or publicly. Objec­ti­ve cri­ti­cism within the work­place is gene­ral­ly per­mit­ted. Anyo­ne who expo­ses mal­prac­ti­ce of public inte­rest may, under cer­tain cir­cum­s­tances, also invo­ke the Whist­le­b­lo­wing Pro­tec­tion Act. Com­pa­nies with 50 or more employees are obli­ged to set up an inter­nal report­ing chan­nel for such reports.

Specific features in certain areas

Public sec­tor employees are sub­ject to spe­ci­fic duties of loyal­ty, depen­ding on their role and respon­si­bi­li­ties. Howe­ver, in 2009, the Fede­ral Labour Court (BAG) ruled that public-sec­tor employees who do not per­form sove­reign func­tions are, in prin­ci­ple, sub­ject to the same stan­dards as employees in the pri­va­te sec­tor (BAG, jud­ge­ment of 10 Sep­tem­ber 2009, ref. 2 AZR 257/08).

In so-cal­led ‘ideo­lo­gi­cal­ly ori­en­ted orga­ni­sa­ti­ons’ – such as trade uni­ons, churches or poli­ti­cal insti­tu­ti­ons – stric­ter requi­re­ments app­ly. Anyo­ne working in such orga­ni­sa­ti­ons must also take care, even out­side working hours, not to act in a man­ner that con­tra­ve­nes the organisation’s fun­da­men­tal prin­ci­ples (Fede­ral Labour Court, jud­ge­ment of 23 Octo­ber 2008, ref. 2 AZR 483/07).

In addi­ti­on, works coun­cil mem­bers are sub­ject to a sta­tu­to­ry pro­hi­bi­ti­on on par­ty poli­ti­cal acti­vi­ty under Sec­tion 75(2), third sen­tence, of the Works Con­sti­tu­ti­on Act (BetrVG) whe­re the­re is a spe­ci­fic link to a poli­ti­cal party.

What does this mean in practice?

Employ­ers may respond to inap­pro­pria­te comm­ents by issuing a writ­ten war­ning or, in serious cases, by dis­miss­ing the employee. Howe­ver, it is always essen­ti­al to careful­ly weigh up the cir­cum­s­tances of each indi­vi­du­al case. Any employee who is unsu­re whe­ther a plan­ned state­ment might have con­se­quen­ces under employ­ment law, or any employ­er wis­hing to respond to an expres­si­on of opi­ni­on, should seek legal advice befo­re taking any hasty action.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this