Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Flower boxes on balconies: What tenants, homeowners and owners’ associations need to know

Flower boxes on balconies: What tenants, homeowners and owners’ associations need to know

A win­dow box on the bal­c­o­ny sounds like a harm­less pas­ti­me. In prac­ti­ce, howe­ver, it has been the sub­ject of seve­ral court cases. Whe­ther a win­dow box may be hung on the out­side or insi­de, who is lia­ble for any dama­ge, and what rights a flat owners’ asso­cia­ti­on has are, from a legal per­spec­ti­ve, any­thing but clear-cut.

WEG resolution: Interior decorations to be displayed in accordance with the owners’ resolution

The Munich Local Court has ruled that a owners’ mee­ting may pass a reso­lu­ti­on requi­ring all bal­c­o­ny plan­ters to be hung on the insi­de in future. In this spe­ci­fic case, hea­vy cera­mic plan­ters had been hung on the out­side wit­hout being ade­qua­te­ly secu­red against fal­ling. Fur­ther­mo­re, over­flowing plan­ters had alre­a­dy dis­co­lou­red the faça­de. The court regard­ed the reso­lu­ti­on as a per­mis­si­ble mea­su­re of pre­ven­ta­ti­ve main­ten­an­ce. Whe­ther any­thing had actual­ly hap­pen­ed to date was irrele­vant. The faça­de and the exter­nal are­as of the bal­co­nies form part of the com­mon pro­per­ty, mea­ning that the owners’ asso­cia­ti­on alo­ne can deci­de on their design. Howe­ver, the reso­lu­ti­on was rest­ric­ted in one respect: an auto­ma­tic obli­ga­ti­on to bear the cos­ts in the event of brea­ches of the rules wit­hout pro­of of fault is void, as it devia­tes from the legal prin­ci­ple of fault-based lia­bi­li­ty. (Munich Local Court, jud­ge­ment of 12 Novem­ber 2024, ref. 1293 C 12154/24 WEG)

Watering plants whilst the terrace below is occupied: a claim for an injunction may be possible

The Munich I Regio­nal Court has cla­ri­fied that a flat owner must not water their bal­c­o­ny plants if the­re are peo­p­le on the ter­race direct­ly below. The water run­ning off the bal­c­o­ny con­sti­tu­tes an unre­asonable nui­sance under the Con­do­mi­ni­um Act. Affec­ted owners may, in such cases, assert a cla­im for an injunc­tion. (Munich Regio­nal Court I, jud­ge­ment of 15 Sep­tem­ber 2014, Case No. 1 S 1836/13 WEG)

Tenancy law: External storage boxes are not always permitted

In prin­ci­ple, pla­cing and han­ging plants is con­side­red nor­mal use of the ten­an­ted pro­per­ty. Howe­ver, a land­lord may pro­hi­bit the attach­ment of plan­ters to the out­side of the bal­c­o­ny para­pet if the­re are reasonable grounds for doing so. The Ber­lin Regio­nal Court has reco­g­nis­ed such a ground whe­re the­re is a car park beneath the bal­c­o­ny: Plan­ters fal­ling from the bal­c­o­ny pose a dan­ger to vehic­les and peo­p­le in that area. As the pro­per­ty owner, the land­lord is obli­ged to pre­vent such dan­gers. (Ber­lin Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 3 July 2012, ref. 65 S 40/12)

On the other hand, the Ham­burg Regio­nal Court has ruled that exter­nal plan­ters can­not be ban­ned across the board. Pro­vi­ded that no spe­ci­fic dan­ger has been pro­ven and the plan­ters are secu­re­ly fixed to with­stand the wind, their use con­sti­tu­tes a lawful exer­cise of the tenant’s rights under the ten­an­cy agree­ment. The bur­den of pro­of regar­ding a spe­ci­fic dan­ger lies with the land­lord. (Ham­burg Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 7 Decem­ber 2004, ref. 316 S 79/04)

Overhanging vegetation beyond the parapet: consideration is required

If the plants grow well bey­ond the bal­c­o­ny para­pet and, as a result, cau­se a nui­sance to the neighbour’s ter­race by fal­ling plant debris or bird drop­pings, the land­lord must take action. The Ber­lin Regio­nal Court has orde­red a land­lord to requi­re his ten­ant to trim the plants back. Anyo­ne who plants their bal­c­o­ny in such a way that neigh­bours are per­ma­nent­ly incon­ve­ni­en­ced is using the let pro­per­ty in breach of the ten­an­cy agree­ment. (Ber­lin Regio­nal Court, jud­ge­ment of 28 Octo­ber 2002, ref. 67 S 127/02)

The owners’ association cannot take legal action against tenants directly

A flat owners’ asso­cia­ti­on can­not its­elf pro­hi­bit a ten­ant from instal­ling bal­c­o­ny plan­ters. This has been cla­ri­fied by the Munich I Regio­nal Court. The right to requi­re the ten­ant to remo­ve them lies sole­ly with the land­lord and is based on the ten­an­cy agree­ment. The owners’ asso­cia­ti­on has no con­trac­tu­al cla­im of its own against the ten­ant. (Munich Regio­nal Court I, jud­ge­ment of 8 May 2001, ref. 13 S 2348/01)

What this means for tenants and homeowners

The legal situa­ti­on regar­ding win­dow boxes varies from case to case. The key fac­tors are how the plan­ters are actual­ly secu­red, the loca­ti­on of the bal­c­o­ny, the ten­an­cy agree­ment and any reso­lu­ti­ons pas­sed by the owners’ asso­cia­ti­on. Anyo­ne who is unsu­re whe­ther their plan­ting is per­mit­ted, or who, as a pro­per­ty owner, wis­hes to enforce regu­la­ti­ons, should seek legal advice if in doubt.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this