Parents living apart who opt for the so-called ‘nest model’ face a tax-related problem. The Munich Finance Court has ruled that the tax relief for single parents cannot be granted in this case. The reason: the shared family home constitutes a joint household, which precludes the tax benefit.
What is the ‘Nest’ model?
Under the ‘nest’ arrangement, the children remain in the home they previously shared with both parents following their separation. The parents take turns moving into the family home for a week at a time, whilst the other parent lives in a separate second home. The aim is to maintain a stable environment for the children.
What was the specific case about?
A mother had been living apart from her husband since 2022. Their three children remained in the family home. Both parents took turns looking after the children on a weekly basis and each maintained their own second home. The family home was still listed in both their names on the tenancy agreement, and they shared the costs.
The mother applied for tax class II and the tax relief for single parents under Section 24b of the Income Tax Act for the years 2023 and 2024. She argued that there was no genuine shared household, as both parents only used the flat in turn and never lived there at the same time.
The decision of the Munich Finance Court
The Munich Finance Court dismissed the claim. According to the judgement of 14 March 2025 (case number 8 K 1717/24), the parents constituted a joint household within the meaning of the law even under the ‘nest model’. The decisive factor was not whether they were present in the flat at the same time, but that they ran the household for the children jointly. Both financed the flat, shared childcare responsibilities and benefited from the economic advantages of a jointly run household. These so-called synergy effects were sufficient to constitute a joint household.
The court also found no breach of the principle of equality under Article 3 of the Basic Law. It held that the ‘nest’ model was not comparable to the alternating custody model. Under the alternating custody model, each parent runs a completely separate household for the children. Under the ‘nest’ model, on the other hand, a shared household for the children is maintained.
What does this mean for the parents concerned?
The tax relief amount for single parents currently stands at 4,260 euros per year, plus 240 euros for each additional child. It is intended to offset the typical additional financial burdens that arise when a parent runs the household without the support of another adult. The court considered that this condition was not met in the case of the ‘nest model’.
Important to note: The appeal to the Federal Fiscal Court has been allowed because there has not yet been a ruling by the highest court on this matter. The case is pending before the Federal Fiscal Court under reference number III R 14/25. Parents who are part of the ‘nest model’ and have applied for, or wish to apply for, the tax relief can lodge an appeal against any negative decisions and refer to these ongoing appeal proceedings in order to keep the decision open.
Anyone affected by this situation should keep an eye on future developments in case law and seek tax advice to ensure they do not miss any deadlines.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.