Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

The ‘nest’ model and tax relief for single parents: No tax benefit where the family home is shared

Munich Regio­nal Tax Court: Par­ents in the ‘nest model’ are not entit­led to the tax reli­ef for sin­gle par­ents. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court is now exami­ning the matter. 
The ‘nest’ model and tax relief for single parents: No tax benefit where the family home is shared

The ‘nest’ model and tax relief for single parents: No tax benefit where the family home is shared

Par­ents living apart who opt for the so-cal­led ‘nest model’ face a tax-rela­ted pro­blem. The Munich Finan­ce Court has ruled that the tax reli­ef for sin­gle par­ents can­not be gran­ted in this case. The reason: the shared fami­ly home con­sti­tu­tes a joint house­hold, which pre­cludes the tax benefit.

What is the ‘Nest’ model?

Under the ‘nest’ arran­ge­ment, the child­ren remain in the home they pre­vious­ly shared with both par­ents fol­lo­wing their sepa­ra­ti­on. The par­ents take turns moving into the fami­ly home for a week at a time, whilst the other parent lives in a sepa­ra­te second home. The aim is to main­tain a sta­ble envi­ron­ment for the children.

What was the specific case about?

A mother had been living apart from her hus­band sin­ce 2022. Their three child­ren remain­ed in the fami­ly home. Both par­ents took turns loo­king after the child­ren on a weekly basis and each main­tai­ned their own second home. The fami­ly home was still lis­ted in both their names on the ten­an­cy agree­ment, and they shared the costs.

The mother appli­ed for tax class II and the tax reli­ef for sin­gle par­ents under Sec­tion 24b of the Inco­me Tax Act for the years 2023 and 2024. She argued that the­re was no genui­ne shared house­hold, as both par­ents only used the flat in turn and never lived the­re at the same time.

The decision of the Munich Finance Court

The Munich Finan­ce Court dis­missed the cla­im. Accor­ding to the jud­ge­ment of 14 March 2025 (case num­ber 8 K 1717/24), the par­ents con­sti­tu­ted a joint house­hold within the mea­ning of the law even under the ‘nest model’. The decisi­ve fac­tor was not whe­ther they were pre­sent in the flat at the same time, but that they ran the house­hold for the child­ren joint­ly. Both finan­ced the flat, shared child­ca­re respon­si­bi­li­ties and bene­fi­ted from the eco­no­mic advan­ta­ges of a joint­ly run house­hold. The­se so-cal­led syn­er­gy effects were suf­fi­ci­ent to con­sti­tu­te a joint household.

The court also found no breach of the prin­ci­ple of equa­li­ty under Artic­le 3 of the Basic Law. It held that the ‘nest’ model was not com­pa­ra­ble to the alter­na­ting cus­t­ody model. Under the alter­na­ting cus­t­ody model, each parent runs a com­ple­te­ly sepa­ra­te house­hold for the child­ren. Under the ‘nest’ model, on the other hand, a shared house­hold for the child­ren is maintained.

What does this mean for the parents concerned?

The tax reli­ef amount for sin­gle par­ents curr­ent­ly stands at 4,260 euros per year, plus 240 euros for each addi­tio­nal child. It is inten­ded to off­set the typi­cal addi­tio­nal finan­cial bur­dens that ari­se when a parent runs the house­hold wit­hout the sup­port of ano­ther adult. The court con­side­red that this con­di­ti­on was not met in the case of the ‘nest model’.

Important to note: The appeal to the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has been allo­wed becau­se the­re has not yet been a ruling by the hig­hest court on this mat­ter. The case is pen­ding befo­re the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court under refe­rence num­ber III R 14/25. Par­ents who are part of the ‘nest model’ and have appli­ed for, or wish to app­ly for, the tax reli­ef can lodge an appeal against any nega­ti­ve decis­i­ons and refer to the­se ongo­ing appeal pro­cee­dings in order to keep the decis­i­on open.

Anyo­ne affec­ted by this situa­ti­on should keep an eye on future deve­lo­p­ments in case law and seek tax advice to ensu­re they do not miss any deadlines.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this