Imagine that a large proportion of your workforce is threatening to leave the company unless a particular employee is dismissed. What at first glance sounds like a clear need to take action is, from a legal perspective, one of the most delicate situations in employment law. According to the case law of the German labour courts, so-called ‘dismissal under pressure’ is subject to very strict conditions.
What is a termination by notice?
A dismissal under duress occurs when an employer dismisses an employee not of their own accord, but because third parties demand it and threaten adverse consequences. These third parties may be colleagues who threaten to resign themselves, the entire workforce announcing a work stoppage, or even key customers who intend to terminate the business relationship if the employee is not dismissed.
In this regard, case law distinguishes between two variants. In the case of the genuine dismissal under duressthere is no independent ground for dismissal against the employee concerned. Nevertheless, the employer feels compelled to take action. In the case of the unjustified dismissal under duressAlthough there may be grounds for dismissal relating to conduct or the employee’s personal circumstances, the employer only decides to actually invoke these grounds as a result of external pressure.
Significant obstacles in practice
Several regional labour courts have recently made it clear that employers often underestimate the requirements for a valid dismissal under duress.
The Lower Saxony Regional Labour Council(Judgment of 13 May 2025, Case No. 10 SLa 687/24) ruled that an employer who had initiated mediation proceedings should have seen them through to a proper conclusion before resorting to dismissal. Furthermore, no specific written warning had been issued to the employee concerned.
The Nuremberg Regional Labour Court(Judgment of 12 December 2023, Case No. 7 Sa 61/23) held, in a similar case, that the employer had not made sufficient efforts to resolve conflicts in the workplace before giving notice of dismissal. Merely consulting the workforce was not sufficient.
And that LAG Hesse(Judgement of 13 July 2016, ref. 18 Sa 1498/15) dealt with a case involving Commerzbank, in which a US financial supervisory authority demanded the dismissal of employees. The judges ruled that even regulatory pressure from abroad does not justify dismissal if the conditions required under German law are not met.
Step by step: What the FOPH requires
The Federal Labour Court has set out clear requirements. Employers must comply with the following steps:
- First, make a concerted effort to convince the third parties exerting pressure that their demand is unreasonable.
- Next, check whether there are other employment options available, such as a transfer or physical separation from the staff involved in the conflict.
- To protect the employee concerned and stand up for them, provided there are no independent grounds for dismissal.
- Only when all these measures have failed and the threats are of a serious nature may termination under duress be justified in individual cases.
What does this mean for employers?
Employers who find themselves under pressure should not act rashly. A dismissal issued without following the aforementioned intermediate steps is unlikely to stand up in an employment tribunal. The costs of losing a case concerning unfair dismissal, including potential continued employment or a severance payment, can be substantial. In the event of a specific dispute, it is advisable to seek advice on employment law at an early stage.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.