Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Termination by notice: When termination at the request of the workforce is permissible

Termination by notice: When termination at the request of the workforce is permissible

Ima­gi­ne that a lar­ge pro­por­ti­on of your work­force is threa­tening to lea­ve the com­pa­ny unless a par­ti­cu­lar employee is dis­missed. What at first glan­ce sounds like a clear need to take action is, from a legal per­spec­ti­ve, one of the most deli­ca­te situa­tions in employ­ment law. Accor­ding to the case law of the Ger­man labour courts, so-cal­led ‘dis­mis­sal under pres­su­re’ is sub­ject to very strict conditions.

What is a termination by notice?

A dis­mis­sal under duress occurs when an employ­er dis­mis­ses an employee not of their own accord, but becau­se third par­ties demand it and threa­ten adver­se con­se­quen­ces. The­se third par­ties may be col­le­agues who threa­ten to resign them­sel­ves, the enti­re work­force announ­cing a work stop­pa­ge, or even key cus­to­mers who intend to ter­mi­na­te the busi­ness rela­ti­onship if the employee is not dismissed.

In this regard, case law distin­gu­is­hes bet­ween two vari­ants. In the case of the genui­ne dis­mis­sal under duressthe­re is no inde­pen­dent ground for dis­mis­sal against the employee con­cer­ned. Nevert­hel­ess, the employ­er feels com­pel­led to take action. In the case of the unju­s­ti­fied dis­mis­sal under duressAlt­hough the­re may be grounds for dis­mis­sal rela­ting to con­duct or the employee’s per­so­nal cir­cum­s­tances, the employ­er only deci­des to actual­ly invo­ke the­se grounds as a result of exter­nal pressure.

Significant obstacles in practice

Seve­ral regio­nal labour courts have recent­ly made it clear that employ­ers often unde­re­sti­ma­te the requi­re­ments for a valid dis­mis­sal under duress.

The Lower Sax­o­ny Regio­nal Labour Coun­cil(Judgment of 13 May 2025, Case No. 10 SLa 687/24) ruled that an employ­er who had initia­ted media­ti­on pro­cee­dings should have seen them through to a pro­per con­clu­si­on befo­re resort­ing to dis­mis­sal. Fur­ther­mo­re, no spe­ci­fic writ­ten war­ning had been issued to the employee concerned.

The Nurem­berg Regio­nal Labour Court(Judgment of 12 Decem­ber 2023, Case No. 7 Sa 61/23) held, in a simi­lar case, that the employ­er had not made suf­fi­ci­ent efforts to resol­ve con­flicts in the work­place befo­re giving noti­ce of dis­mis­sal. Mere­ly con­sul­ting the work­force was not sufficient.

And that LAG Hes­se(Jud­ge­ment of 13 July 2016, ref. 18 Sa 1498/15) dealt with a case invol­ving Com­merz­bank, in which a US finan­cial super­vi­so­ry aut­ho­ri­ty deman­ded the dis­mis­sal of employees. The jud­ges ruled that even regu­la­to­ry pres­su­re from abroad does not jus­ti­fy dis­mis­sal if the con­di­ti­ons requi­red under Ger­man law are not met.

Step by step: What the FOPH requires

The Fede­ral Labour Court has set out clear requi­re­ments. Employ­ers must com­ply with the fol­lo­wing steps:

  • First, make a con­cer­ted effort to con­vin­ce the third par­ties exer­ting pres­su­re that their demand is unreasonable.
  • Next, check whe­ther the­re are other employ­ment opti­ons available, such as a trans­fer or phy­si­cal sepa­ra­ti­on from the staff invol­ved in the conflict.
  • To pro­tect the employee con­cer­ned and stand up for them, pro­vi­ded the­re are no inde­pen­dent grounds for dismissal.
  • Only when all the­se mea­su­res have fai­led and the thre­ats are of a serious natu­re may ter­mi­na­ti­on under duress be jus­ti­fied in indi­vi­du­al cases.

What does this mean for employers?

Employ­ers who find them­sel­ves under pres­su­re should not act rash­ly. A dis­mis­sal issued wit­hout fol­lo­wing the afo­re­men­tio­ned inter­me­dia­te steps is unli­kely to stand up in an employ­ment tri­bu­nal. The cos­ts of losing a case con­cer­ning unfair dis­mis­sal, inclu­ding poten­ti­al con­tin­ued employ­ment or a sever­ance pay­ment, can be sub­stan­ti­al. In the event of a spe­ci­fic dis­pu­te, it is advi­sa­ble to seek advice on employ­ment law at an ear­ly stage.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this