Civil servants who are voluntarily insured under the statutory health insurance scheme and receive a flat-rate allowance must take care when filing their income tax returns: the Berlin-Brandenburg Finance Court has ruled that the flat-rate allowance received reduces the amount of deductible special expenses for health insurance contributions. The judgement of 17 June 2026 (case number 3 K 3133/24) concerns retired civil servants who are voluntarily insured under the statutory health insurance scheme and who have applied for the so-called flat-rate allowance under the State Civil Service Act instead of the traditional allowance.
What is the flat-rate allowance?
Normally, the allowance covers part of the actual medical expenses incurred, usually around half. The flat-rate allowance works differently: instead of reimbursing individual medical expenses, the employer pays the civil servant 50 per cent of their documented health insurance contributions. This is comparable to the employer’s contribution that employees receive under the statutory health insurance scheme. Civil servants would otherwise have to pay their contributions to voluntary statutory health insurance in full themselves; there is no traditional employer’s contribution for them.
The case before the Tax Court
A retired civil servant from Berlin had claimed his entire health insurance contributions as special expenses on his income tax return. However, the tax office reduced these contributions by the amount of the flat-rate allowance he had received. The civil servant challenged this decision, arguing that the flat-rate allowance was tax-free and should therefore have no effect on his special expenses.
Court ruling
The Tax Court ruled in favour of the tax office. Although the lump-sum allowance is tax-free under Section 3(62) of the Income Tax Act, as it serves to provide for the civil servant’s future and is based on a statutory obligation on the part of the employer, However, the tax exemption does not alter the fact that there is a direct economic link between the allowance and the health insurance contributions.
In the court’s view, this connection arises from two factors:
- The flat-rate allowance is legally conditional upon health insurance contributions being paid in the first place. Without these contributions, there is no flat-rate allowance.
- The amount of the lump-sum grant is directly based on the amount of contributions paid.
As the contributions are partially reimbursed through the grant, only the contributions actually borne by the individual may be deducted as special expenses under Section 10(1)(3) of the Income Tax Act. A full deduction of the gross amounts without taking the subsidy received into account would constitute a double tax benefit.
What does this mean for those affected?
Retired civil servants who receive a lump-sum allowance and are voluntarily covered by statutory health insurance should check whether their tax office is reducing their special expenses accordingly or whether tax assessment notices can still be challenged. The Finance Court has granted leave to appeal to the Federal Finance Court, meaning that the final decision on this matter has not yet been reached. Anyone in a similar situation should keep a close eye on their tax assessment notices and, if necessary, seek tax advice.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.