Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

A flat-rate allowance reduces the tax deduction for special expenses relating to health insurance contributions

Ber­lin-Bran­den­burg Finan­ce Court: A flat-rate allo­wan­ce redu­ces the spe­cial expen­ses deduc­tion for sta­tu­to­ry health insu­rance con­tri­bu­ti­ons paid by reti­red civil servants. 
A flat-rate allowance reduces the tax deduction for special expenses relating to health insurance contributions

A flat-rate allowance reduces the tax deduction for special expenses relating to health insurance contributions

Civil ser­vants who are vol­un­t­a­ri­ly insu­red under the sta­tu­to­ry health insu­rance sche­me and recei­ve a flat-rate allo­wan­ce must take care when fil­ing their inco­me tax returns: the Ber­lin-Bran­den­burg Finan­ce Court has ruled that the flat-rate allo­wan­ce recei­ved redu­ces the amount of deduc­ti­ble spe­cial expen­ses for health insu­rance con­tri­bu­ti­ons. The jud­ge­ment of 17 June 2026 (case num­ber 3 K 3133/24) con­cerns reti­red civil ser­vants who are vol­un­t­a­ri­ly insu­red under the sta­tu­to­ry health insu­rance sche­me and who have appli­ed for the so-cal­led flat-rate allo­wan­ce under the Sta­te Civil Ser­vice Act ins­tead of the tra­di­tio­nal allowance.

What is the flat-rate allowance?

Nor­mal­ly, the allo­wan­ce covers part of the actu­al medi­cal expen­ses incur­red, usual­ly around half. The flat-rate allo­wan­ce works dif­fer­ent­ly: ins­tead of reim­bur­sing indi­vi­du­al medi­cal expen­ses, the employ­er pays the civil ser­vant 50 per cent of their docu­men­ted health insu­rance con­tri­bu­ti­ons. This is com­pa­ra­ble to the employer’s con­tri­bu­ti­on that employees recei­ve under the sta­tu­to­ry health insu­rance sche­me. Civil ser­vants would other­wi­se have to pay their con­tri­bu­ti­ons to vol­un­t­a­ry sta­tu­to­ry health insu­rance in full them­sel­ves; the­re is no tra­di­tio­nal employer’s con­tri­bu­ti­on for them.

The case before the Tax Court

A reti­red civil ser­vant from Ber­lin had clai­med his enti­re health insu­rance con­tri­bu­ti­ons as spe­cial expen­ses on his inco­me tax return. Howe­ver, the tax office redu­ced the­se con­tri­bu­ti­ons by the amount of the flat-rate allo­wan­ce he had recei­ved. The civil ser­vant chal­len­ged this decis­i­on, arguing that the flat-rate allo­wan­ce was tax-free and should the­r­e­fo­re have no effect on his spe­cial expenses.

Court ruling

The Tax Court ruled in favour of the tax office. Alt­hough the lump-sum allo­wan­ce is tax-free under Sec­tion 3(62) of the Inco­me Tax Act, as it ser­ves to pro­vi­de for the civil servant’s future and is based on a sta­tu­to­ry obli­ga­ti­on on the part of the employ­er, Howe­ver, the tax exemp­ti­on does not alter the fact that the­re is a direct eco­no­mic link bet­ween the allo­wan­ce and the health insu­rance contributions.

In the court’s view, this con­nec­tion ari­ses from two factors:

  • The flat-rate allo­wan­ce is legal­ly con­di­tio­nal upon health insu­rance con­tri­bu­ti­ons being paid in the first place. Wit­hout the­se con­tri­bu­ti­ons, the­re is no flat-rate allowance.
  • The amount of the lump-sum grant is direct­ly based on the amount of con­tri­bu­ti­ons paid.

As the con­tri­bu­ti­ons are par­ti­al­ly reim­bur­sed through the grant, only the con­tri­bu­ti­ons actual­ly bor­ne by the indi­vi­du­al may be deduc­ted as spe­cial expen­ses under Sec­tion 10(1)(3) of the Inco­me Tax Act. A full deduc­tion of the gross amounts wit­hout taking the sub­s­idy recei­ved into account would con­sti­tu­te a dou­ble tax benefit.

What does this mean for those affected?

Reti­red civil ser­vants who recei­ve a lump-sum allo­wan­ce and are vol­un­t­a­ri­ly cover­ed by sta­tu­to­ry health insu­rance should check whe­ther their tax office is redu­cing their spe­cial expen­ses accor­din­gly or whe­ther tax assess­ment noti­ces can still be chal­len­ged. The Finan­ce Court has gran­ted lea­ve to appeal to the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court, mea­ning that the final decis­i­on on this mat­ter has not yet been rea­ched. Anyo­ne in a simi­lar situa­ti­on should keep a clo­se eye on their tax assess­ment noti­ces and, if neces­sa­ry, seek tax advice.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this