Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

The Federal Court of Justice strengthens the rights of the contractual heir in cases of gifts made by the testator during their lifetime

Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH): A reser­va­ti­on of the right of with­dra­wal in a con­tract of inhe­ri­tance which has not been exer­cis­ed does not pre­vent the con­trac­tu­al heir from reclai­ming gifts made during the testator’s lifetime. 
The Federal Court of Justice strengthens the rights of the contractual heir in cases of gifts made by the testator during their lifetime

The Federal Court of Justice strengthens the rights of the contractual heir in cases of gifts made by the testator during their lifetime

Anyo­ne appoin­ted as an heir in a con­tract of inhe­ri­tance may, fol­lo­wing the testator’s death and sub­ject to cer­tain con­di­ti­ons, recla­im gifts that the test­a­tor made to third par­ties during his or her life­time. The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce has now cla­ri­fied that this right also appli­es even if the test­a­tor had reser­ved the right to with­draw from the inhe­ri­tance con­tract but never exer­cis­ed it. The jud­ge­ment was han­ded down on 8 July 2026 (case num­ber: IV ZR 256/25).

What was the dispute about?

A test­a­tor had alre­a­dy ente­red into a con­tract of inhe­ri­tance with his wife in 1969. In it, the cou­ple appoin­ted each other as preli­mi­na­ry heirs and their two joint child­ren as sub­se­quent heirs. In an adden­dum dated 2015, the cou­ple also agreed that the sur­vi­ving spou­se might divi­de the joint estate among­st the child­ren in a man­ner dif­fe­ring from that set out in the inhe­ri­tance con­tract. Fur­ther­mo­re, both reser­ved the right to with­draw from the inhe­ri­tance con­tract at any time.

During his life­time, the test­a­tor trans­fer­red two plots of land to his daugh­ter and made cash pay­ments to her; she acted on his behalf by vir­tue of a power of att­or­ney gran­ted to her. Fol­lo­wing the testator’s death, his wife renoun­ced her inhe­ri­tance. Both child­ren accept­ed their inhe­ri­tance. The son sub­se­quent­ly brought an action see­king the trans­fer of a 50 per cent co-owner­ship share in the plots of land and reim­bur­se­ment of half the pay­ments, as he felt he had been dis­ad­van­ta­ged by the gifts.

The key legal issue

The Nurem­berg Hig­her Regio­nal Court had dis­missed the cla­im. Its reaso­ning was that, becau­se the test­a­tor had reser­ved the right to with­draw from the inhe­ri­tance con­tract, the son could not rely on actual­ly beco­ming an heir. Howe­ver, such pro­tec­tion of legi­ti­ma­te expec­ta­ti­ons is a pre­re­qui­si­te for reclai­ming gifted items after death.

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce took a dif­fe­rent view. As long as a test­a­tor does not actual­ly exer­cise his right of with­dra­wal, he remains bound by the inhe­ri­tance con­tract. The con­trac­tu­al heir desi­gna­ted as such may the­r­e­fo­re con­ti­nue to expect to recei­ve the inhe­ri­tance. If this were not the case, a test­a­tor could give away their enti­re estate during their life­time, ther­eby ren­de­ring the con­trac­tu­al obli­ga­ti­on eco­no­mic­al­ly meanin­g­less, wit­hout ever for­mal­ly with­dra­wing from the con­tract. The heir appoin­ted under the con­tract would thus be signi­fi­cant­ly dis­ad­van­ta­ged wit­hout ever having been awa­re of the gifts.

What does that mean in practice?

At the heart of the ruling is the so-cal­led cla­im for resti­tu­ti­on by the con­trac­tu­al heir under Sec­tion 2287(1) of the Civil Code. This cla­im appli­es whe­re the test­a­tor has made gifts with the inten­ti­on of dis­ad­van­ta­ging the con­trac­tu­al heir. The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce has cla­ri­fied that a right of with­dra­wal which was mere­ly reser­ved but never exer­cis­ed does not pre­clude this claim.

This is an important cla­ri­fi­ca­ti­on for pri­va­te indi­vi­du­als who have ente­red into a con­tract of inhe­ri­tance. This cla­im can be of con­sidera­ble signi­fi­can­ce, par­ti­cu­lar­ly in blen­ded fami­lies or situa­tions whe­re one parent favours cer­tain child­ren during their life­time. The case has been refer­red back to the Nurem­berg Hig­her Regio­nal Court, which must now exami­ne whe­ther the other con­di­ti­ons for the cla­im for resti­tu­ti­on are met in this spe­ci­fic case.

  • A con­tract of inhe­ri­tance remains bin­ding on the test­a­tor for as long as he has not resc­in­ded it
  • Gifts made during one’s life­time may, under cer­tain cir­cum­s­tances, be reclai­med after death
  • A reser­va­ti­on of the right to with­draw that has not been exer­cis­ed does not alter this
  • The con­di­ti­on remains that the gift must have been made with the inten­ti­on of pre­ju­di­cing the con­trac­tu­al heir

Anyo­ne fin­ding them­sel­ves in a simi­lar situa­ti­on – that is, who, as a con­trac­tu­al heir, may have been dis­ad­van­ta­ged by gifts made by the test­a­tor – should seek legal advice. The claims and the con­di­ti­ons for them must be exami­ned on a case-by-case basis.

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this