Anyone appointed as an heir in a contract of inheritance may, following the testator’s death and subject to certain conditions, reclaim gifts that the testator made to third parties during his or her lifetime. The Federal Court of Justice has now clarified that this right also applies even if the testator had reserved the right to withdraw from the inheritance contract but never exercised it. The judgement was handed down on 8 July 2026 (case number: IV ZR 256/25).
What was the dispute about?
A testator had already entered into a contract of inheritance with his wife in 1969. In it, the couple appointed each other as preliminary heirs and their two joint children as subsequent heirs. In an addendum dated 2015, the couple also agreed that the surviving spouse might divide the joint estate amongst the children in a manner differing from that set out in the inheritance contract. Furthermore, both reserved the right to withdraw from the inheritance contract at any time.
During his lifetime, the testator transferred two plots of land to his daughter and made cash payments to her; she acted on his behalf by virtue of a power of attorney granted to her. Following the testator’s death, his wife renounced her inheritance. Both children accepted their inheritance. The son subsequently brought an action seeking the transfer of a 50 per cent co-ownership share in the plots of land and reimbursement of half the payments, as he felt he had been disadvantaged by the gifts.
The key legal issue
The Nuremberg Higher Regional Court had dismissed the claim. Its reasoning was that, because the testator had reserved the right to withdraw from the inheritance contract, the son could not rely on actually becoming an heir. However, such protection of legitimate expectations is a prerequisite for reclaiming gifted items after death.
The Federal Court of Justice took a different view. As long as a testator does not actually exercise his right of withdrawal, he remains bound by the inheritance contract. The contractual heir designated as such may therefore continue to expect to receive the inheritance. If this were not the case, a testator could give away their entire estate during their lifetime, thereby rendering the contractual obligation economically meaningless, without ever formally withdrawing from the contract. The heir appointed under the contract would thus be significantly disadvantaged without ever having been aware of the gifts.
What does that mean in practice?
At the heart of the ruling is the so-called claim for restitution by the contractual heir under Section 2287(1) of the Civil Code. This claim applies where the testator has made gifts with the intention of disadvantaging the contractual heir. The Federal Court of Justice has clarified that a right of withdrawal which was merely reserved but never exercised does not preclude this claim.
This is an important clarification for private individuals who have entered into a contract of inheritance. This claim can be of considerable significance, particularly in blended families or situations where one parent favours certain children during their lifetime. The case has been referred back to the Nuremberg Higher Regional Court, which must now examine whether the other conditions for the claim for restitution are met in this specific case.
- A contract of inheritance remains binding on the testator for as long as he has not rescinded it
- Gifts made during one’s lifetime may, under certain circumstances, be reclaimed after death
- A reservation of the right to withdraw that has not been exercised does not alter this
- The condition remains that the gift must have been made with the intention of prejudicing the contractual heir
Anyone finding themselves in a similar situation – that is, who, as a contractual heir, may have been disadvantaged by gifts made by the testator – should seek legal advice. The claims and the conditions for them must be examined on a case-by-case basis.
Source: BGH press releases
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.