In a judgement dated 18 March 2026, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) addressed a question of practical importance: What rules apply to child benefit where a case has a connection to the United Kingdom and the post-Brexit transition period has already expired? The court clarified that EU coordination law does not automatically continue to apply (case number III R 10/25).
What is EU coordination law all about?
Within the EU, a specific set of rules ensures that family benefits, such as child benefit, are allocated in an orderly manner in cross-border cases. The so-called EU Coordination Regulations determine which country has primary responsibility for payment and how duplicate payments are avoided. Following Brexit and the end of the transition period on 31 December 2020, this no longer automatically applies to cases involving the United Kingdom.
The specific case
A German national moved from the United Kingdom to Germany in October 2019 with her child, who is also a German national. She applied for full child benefit in Germany for the period from March to August 2022. The child’s father continued to live in the United Kingdom, where he had been working in the catering industry since around the year 2000.
The relevant family benefits office paid only a reduced amount. It regarded the United Kingdom as having primary responsibility because the child’s father was employed there, and deducted the benefits theoretically available there from the German child benefit. The Finance Court initially upheld the claim for the full amount of child benefit.
The Federal Fiscal Court’s ruling
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) set aside this decision and referred the case back to the Finance Court. The court clarified that, following the end of the transitional period, the more recent EU coordination legislation will continue to apply only in certain categories of cases.
- Grandfathering applies to claims that already existed at the end of the transition period. This presupposes that the person concerned was still in a cross-border situation between the EU and the United Kingdom at that time.
- The Tax Court had not sufficiently examined whether this was the case with regard to the mother.
- As regards the father, there was a possibility that he was solely a third-country national. In that case, older coordination legislation dating from before the United Kingdom’s accession to the EU might apply, which governed the protection of migrant workers in cross-border employment.
The Tax Court must now investigate the facts of the case in greater detail, in particular the father’s nationality and the mother’s place of residence at the end of the transition period.
What does this mean for those affected?
Families in which one parent has been living or working in the United Kingdom since Brexit should check their child benefit notices carefully. Whether EU law still applies depends on very specific circumstances: the timing of the cross-border situation, the nationality of those involved and their place of residence at the end of the transition period. Anyone who is unsure whether the family benefits office has calculated the payments correctly should seek legal or tax advice.
Source: BFH press releases
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.