Anyone applying for child benefit in Germany who has a connection to the United Kingdom has had to deal with a complicated legal situation since Brexit. The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) has now clarified in a recent ruling the conditions under which European coordination law may still be applied following the end of the transition period on 31 December 2020.
What is EU coordination law all about?
EU coordination legislation determines which country is responsible for certain social benefits in cross-border situations. This includes family benefits such as child benefit. The relevant regulations specify which country is primarily responsible for payment and prevent families from receiving double benefits or receiving nothing at all. Following Brexit, these rules will, in principle, no longer apply to the United Kingdom, unless the Withdrawal Agreement provides for exceptions.
The specific case
In October 2019, a German mother moved to Germany with her child, who is also German. The child had been born in the United Kingdom. The father continued to live and work there in the catering industry. The mother applied for full child benefit in Germany for the period from March to August 2022.
The Family Benefits Office rejected this and paid only what is known as ‘differential child benefit’. This means that it recognised the United Kingdom as having primary responsibility and granted only the amount by which the German child benefit exceeded the British benefits. Enquiries in the UK as to why there was no entitlement there yielded no clear result.
The Finance Court of First Instance ruled in the mother’s favour and awarded her the full child benefit. However, the Federal Finance Court overturned this ruling.
The Federal Fiscal Court’s ruling
The court made it clear that, following the end of the transition period, the new EU coordination legislation will only apply in certain categories of cases. A decisive factor, for example, is whether the person in question was still in a cross-border situation with the United Kingdom on the cut-off date of 31 December 2020. The Tax Court had failed to examine this in relation to the mother.
There is also another aspect to consider: if the child’s father is not an EU citizen but a national of a third country, even older EU coordination legislation dating from the 1970s might apply. This, too, had not been clarified.
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) therefore referred the case back to the Finance Court so that the missing facts could be established. Case number: BFH, judgement of 18 March 2026, III R 10/25, published on 9 July 2026.
What does this mean for those affected?
Families with cross-border links to the United Kingdom should have their specific circumstances carefully assessed to determine which rules apply to them. Whether they are entitled to full or only a proportion of child benefit depends on several factors: the parents’ place of residence and nationality, and whether a cross-border connection still existed at the end of the transition period.
Anyone in a similar situation who has questions about their entitlement to child benefit should seek tax or legal advice. Following Brexit, the legal situation is extremely complex and can be difficult to navigate on a case-by-case basis.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.