Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Dismissal over Pride Month flag in the staff room: court rules that a written warning must be issued first

Dismissal over Pride Month flag in the staff room: court rules that a written warning must be issued first

In June 2025, an asyl­um case offi­cer at the Fede­ral Office for Migra­ti­on and Refu­gees (BAMF) hung a so-cal­led ‘Pri­de Month’ flag in his office. The ‘Pri­de Month’ flag is a sty­li­sed ver­si­on of the Ger­man flag, used as a coun­ter-sym­bol to the rain­bow flag of Pri­de Month. Accor­ding to the 2024 Report on the Pro­tec­tion of the Con­sti­tu­ti­on, the cam­paign behind it is lar­ge­ly dri­ven by right-wing and far-right groups. The sta­te of Hes­se sub­se­quent­ly dis­missed the employee in accordance with stan­dard pro­ce­du­re. Howe­ver, the Gies­sen Labour Court declared the dis­mis­sal invalid.

Why hanging it up constituted a breach of duty

The office ser­ved not only as a work­place but also as a hea­ring room for asyl­um pro­cee­dings. Asyl­um see­kers, inter­pre­ters and legal advi­sers were regu­lar­ly pre­sent the­re. The court ruled that dis­play­ing the flag con­sti­tu­ted a serious breach of ancil­la­ry obli­ga­ti­ons under the employ­ment con­tract. Public sec­tor employees, par­ti­cu­lar­ly tho­se in a sove­reign capa­ci­ty such as asyl­um decis­i­on-making, are sub­ject to the state’s requi­re­ment of neu­tra­li­ty. A par­ti­cu­lar­ly sen­si­ti­ve issue is that some asyl­um see­kers are per­se­cu­ted on the grounds of their sexu­al iden­ti­ty and might inter­pret the flag as a sign that they will not recei­ve a fair hearing.

Why the dismissal failed all the same

The key fac­tor was the prin­ci­ple of pro­por­tio­na­li­ty. Accor­ding to the estab­lished case law of the Fede­ral Labour Court, dis­mis­sal on grounds of con­duct requi­res that the­re be a nega­ti­ve pro­gno­sis for the future – in other words, that the employee is likely to repeat their mis­con­duct. This is pre­cis­e­ly what the Gies­sen Labour Court ruled against.

The employee had remo­ved the flag imme­dia­te­ly upon being express­ly asked to do so, wit­hout objec­tion. He express­ly distanced hims­elf from far-right and anti-LGBTQ+ views and, on his own initia­ti­ve, signed up for anti-dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on trai­ning, which his employ­er, howe­ver, refu­sed to allow him to attend. The court regard­ed this as a clear sign of remor­se and a wil­ling­ness to cooperate.

The behaviour of the line managers had an impact

The court also did not fail to assess the con­duct of the aut­ho­ri­ty its­elf. Alt­hough the team lea­der noti­ced the flag, she did not express­ly demand that it be taken down. The head of depart­ment was awa­re of this and initi­al­ly took no action eit­her. It was only a seni­or civil ser­vant who arran­ged for it to be remo­ved. Around six and a half weeks elap­sed bet­ween the inci­dent and the sus­pen­si­on. The court found that anyo­ne who, in the face of an alle­gedly so serious breach of duty, stands by idly for weeks on end and allows the employee to con­ti­nue pro­ces­sing asyl­um appli­ca­ti­ons can­not sub­se­quent­ly cre­di­bly cla­im that the rela­ti­onship of trust has been irrepa­ra­b­ly destroyed.

No evidence of anti-constitutional views

The court was also not con­vin­ced by the state’s argu­ment that the employee did not adhe­re to the free and demo­cra­tic basic order. The Pri­de Month flag is not a pro­hi­bi­ted sym­bol. The employee had not pre­vious­ly attrac­ted atten­ti­on for making anti-con­sti­tu­tio­nal remarks, and his reports had pas­sed inter­nal qua­li­ty assu­rance checks wit­hout any objections.

What the ruling means for employers

The jud­ge­ment high­lights a point that is often unde­re­sti­ma­ted in prac­ti­ce: even in the case of serious brea­ches of duty, a writ­ten war­ning must, as a gene­ral rule, be issued befo­re dis­mis­sal can take place. Excep­ti­ons app­ly only if a repeat offence is to be expec­ted despi­te the writ­ten war­ning, or if the breach of duty is so serious that con­ti­nuing the employ­ment rela­ti­onship is cle­ar­ly unre­asonable. In the court’s view, neither of the­se cir­cum­s­tances appli­ed in this case.

Employ­ers should also bear in mind that their own hesi­ta­ti­on fol­lo­wing an inci­dent may be inter­pre­ted as a coun­ter-argu­ment if they later wish to base a dis­mis­sal on the serious­ness of that same breach of duty. Anyo­ne wis­hing to act in a legal­ly sound man­ner in com­pa­ra­ble situa­tions should seek advice on employ­ment law at an ear­ly stage.

Gies­sen Labour Court, jud­ge­ment of 22 April 2026, Case No. 6 Ca 220/25

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this