People who work at night rarely think straight away of the Maternity Protection Act. Yet the issue of night work is particularly important for pregnant and breastfeeding employees. German law contains clear protective provisions which, in practice, are underestimated by many of those affected.
What counts as night work during maternity leave?
The Maternity Protection Act (MuSchG) defines night work as any work carried out between 8.00 pm and 6.00 am. Pregnant and breastfeeding employees are generally prohibited from working during this period. This explicitly applies not only to traditional night shifts, but to any work carried out during these night-time hours – including, for example, late shifts that do not finish until after 8.00 pm.
The ECJ had already strengthened the rights of shift workers back in 2018
In a judgement of 19 September 2018 (Case C‑41/17), the European Court of Justice clarified that protection against night work also applies to shift workers who are only occasionally scheduled to work during the night. The case was brought by a Spanish security worker whose shifts only partially extended into the night. The ECJ ruled that it is sufficient for even part of the working time to fall during the night for a worker to be regarded as a night worker and to enjoy the corresponding protection. The German maternity protection regulations are compatible with these European requirements and even go beyond them.
Are there any exceptions to the ban on night work?
Until the reform of the Maternity Protection Act in May 2017, the ban was absolute. Since the amendment to the Act, it has been possible, under certain conditions, to work between 10.00 pm and 6.00 am. However, for this to apply, three conditions must be met simultaneously:
- The employer and the employee concerned are in agreement.
- A doctor confirms that there are no health concerns.
- The relevant supervisory authority grants the authorisation.
This exception is therefore not automatic and, in all cases, requires the employee’s voluntary consent.
What does that mean in practice?
Employers who operate shift patterns must take particular care. As soon as an employee becomes pregnant or is breastfeeding and informs her employer of this, her working hours must be adjusted. This applies regardless of whether it is a traditional night shift or simply the end of a late shift that extends beyond 8.00 pm.
For female employees, this means they have a clearly defined right to be exempted from night work. A doctor’s certificate can further support this entitlement.
Night work under the Working Hours Act: a different term
Important to note: The Working Hours Act (ArbZG) uses a different definition of ‘night’. Under this Act, night-time is defined as the period from 11 pm to 6 am. A night worker within the meaning of the ArbZG is defined as someone who normally works night shifts as part of a rotating shift pattern or who carries out night work on at least 48 days a year. This definition is relevant to issues such as night work allowances or special health checks, but does not replace the protection provided by the Maternity Protection Act.
If you have specific questions about the ban on employment or about entitlements relating to pregnancy and maternity leave, it is advisable to seek advice on employment law on a case-by-case basis.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.