Anyone who fails to submit a tax return, despite being obliged to do so, risks more than just having to pay back tax. In a recent judgement dated 13 March 2026 (Ref. 4 K 135/19 E), the Münster Finance Court has clarified why the precise classification of the conduct as tax evasion or reckless tax avoidance has significant implications for the question of how long the tax office is still permitted to assess taxes.
What had happened?
A married couple had regularly filed income tax returns up until 2008. From 2009 onwards, the wife also took up employment as an employee. Both their wages were taxed under tax classes III and V. This meant that the couple were legally obliged to submit an annual income tax return, as stipulated in Section 46 of the Income Tax Act (EStG). This obligation applies whenever both spouses receive wages and the less favourable tax class V has been chosen.
The couple did not submit any tax returns for 2009 and 2010. The tax office did not notice this until 2018 and subsequently issued tax assessment notices. The couple invoked the statute of limitations.
The issue of limitation periods
Under tax law, there are different time limits within which the tax office is still permitted to assess taxes. The standard assessment period is four years. In cases of reckless tax evasion, this is extended to five years; in cases of tax evasion, it is extended to as many as ten years.
The court therefore had to determine which of these time limits applied in this case. Tax evasion requires intent; in other words, the taxpayer must at least have accepted, with approval, that they were paying too little tax. The Münster Fiscal Court was not convinced that the couple had acted with such intent. It considered it possible that the couple simply assumed that the income tax deducted at source would cover their tax liability in full, as had been the case in previous years.
Carelessness is sufficient to extend the limitation period
Reckless tax evasion, on the other hand, does not require intent. It is broadly equivalent to gross negligence, but is assessed in the light of the individual’s personal capabilities. Anyone who, given their circumstances and knowledge, would have been in a position to find out about their tax obligations is acting recklessly if they fail to do so.
The court emphasised that, when the wife took up employment and was thereby obliged to inform her employer of her income tax bracket, it should have been obvious to the couple that this might entail further tax implications. They should have sought advice from a qualified adviser. They failed to do so. This constituted reckless tax evasion, and the five-year limitation period applied. The tax office was therefore still able to assess taxes retrospectively for 2010. The limitation period had only expired for 2009.
What does this mean for taxpayers?
The ruling shows that ignorance does not automatically protect against an extended limitation period. Anyone whose income situation changes – for example, by taking on a second job within the household – should check whether this gives rise to an obligation to declare it. If in doubt, it is advisable to consult a tax adviser at an early stage.
- Standard limitation period: 4 years
- For reckless tax evasion: 5 years
- For tax evasion: 10 years
In specific individual cases, tax advice should be sought in order to assess one’s own risk.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.