Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Flower boxes on the balcony: What tenants, owners and the owners’ association need to know

When is it per­mis­si­ble to hang win­dow boxes out­side? An over­view of court rulings on reso­lu­ti­ons under the Ger­man Con­do­mi­ni­um Act (WEG), ten­an­cy law and pro­tec­tion of neighbours. 
Flower boxes on the balcony: What tenants, owners and the owners’ association need to know

Flower boxes on the balcony: What tenants, owners and the owners’ association need to know

A win­dow box on a bal­c­o­ny rai­ling sounds harm­less enough. Yet in blocks of flats, this can quick­ly turn into a serious legal dis­pu­te. In recent years, seve­ral courts have ruled on when win­dow boxes may be hung out­side, when they may be pro­hi­bi­ted, and who is lia­ble for any damage.

WEG resolution: The owners’ association may require the use of interior curtains

In Novem­ber 2024, the Munich Local Court ruled that a flat owners’ asso­cia­ti­on (WEG) may, by reso­lu­ti­on, sti­pu­la­te that all win­dow boxes must be hung facing inwards (Case No. 1293 C 12154/24 WEG). In this spe­ci­fic case, a homeow­ner had atta­ched six hea­vy cera­mic plan­ters to the out­side of the buil­ding; the­se were neither ade­qua­te­ly secu­red nor fixed in a storm-pro­of man­ner. Fur­ther­mo­re, water run­ning down them had alre­a­dy dis­co­lou­red the façade.

The court made it clear that the exter­nal are­as of bal­co­nies form part of the com­mon pro­per­ty. The Owners’ Asso­cia­ti­on is the­r­e­fo­re sole­ly respon­si­ble for decis­i­ons regar­ding their design. Such a reso­lu­ti­on is dee­med to fall within the scope of pro­per admi­nis­tra­ti­on, even if no spe­ci­fic ins­tance of dama­ge has occur­red to date. This does not dis­pro­por­tio­na­te­ly rest­rict the affec­ted owner’s free­dom of per­so­nal expression.

Howe­ver, the pro­vi­si­on sti­pu­la­ting that the par­ty respon­si­ble is auto­ma­ti­cal­ly lia­ble for all dama­ges was declared par­ti­al­ly inva­lid. This clau­se devia­tes from the legal prin­ci­ple that lia­bi­li­ty requi­res fault.

Watering is not allowed when neighbours are sitting on the terrace

The Munich I Regio­nal Court has ruled that wate­ring bal­c­o­ny plants may be pro­hi­bi­ted if the water drips onto the ter­race below whilst peo­p­le are pre­sent the­re (Case No. 1 S 1836/13 WEG). In such cases, this con­sti­tu­tes an unre­asonable nui­sance within the mea­ning of the Con­do­mi­ni­um Act. The affec­ted owner may demand that wate­ring be sus­pen­ded at such times.

Tenancy: Outdoor hanging may constitute a breach of contract

Flower boxes on the bal­c­o­ny are gene­ral­ly con­side­red part of nor­mal ten­an­cy use. Howe­ver, the situa­ti­on may be dif­fe­rent if the boxes are hung on the out­side of the rai­ling and this crea­tes a spe­ci­fic hazard. The Ber­lin Regio­nal Court has ruled that a land­lord may pro­hi­bit han­ging plan­ters on the out­side if cars are park­ed beneath the bal­c­o­ny and fal­ling plan­ters could end­an­ger peo­p­le or vehic­les (Case No. 65 S 40/12). In this case, the ten­ant was requi­red to remo­ve the planters.

In con­trast, the Ham­burg Regio­nal Court empha­sis­ed that exter­nal let­ter­bo­xes are not gene­ral­ly pro­hi­bi­ted. A spe­ci­fic risk must be pro­ven. In the absence of such pro­of, han­ging boxes out­side remains per­mit­ted, pro­vi­ded that they are secu­red in such a way as to with­stand strong winds (Case No. 316 S 79/04).

Overgrown vegetation and litter on the neighbouring terrace

Anyo­ne who plants their bal­c­o­ny in such a way that plant debris and bird drop­pings fall onto their neighbour’s ter­race must expect that the land­lord will be obli­ged to take action. The Ber­lin Regio­nal Court has ruled that a land­lord may requi­re their ten­ant to trim back the plants to a reasonable ext­ent if the neigh­bour can no lon­ger make pro­per use of their ter­race due to the con­ta­mi­na­ti­on (Case No. 67 S 127/02).

The owners’ association may not take legal action directly against tenants

Important for owners’ asso­cia­ti­ons: The owners’ asso­cia­ti­on its­elf can­not direct­ly pro­hi­bit a ten­ant from instal­ling win­dow boxes. Only the respec­ti­ve owner has this right under the terms of the ten­an­cy agree­ment. This was cla­ri­fied by the Munich I Regio­nal Court (Case No. 13 S 2348/01).

What does that mean in practice?

Whe­ther flower boxes may be hung out­side depends on seve­ral fac­tors: the spe­ci­fic cir­cum­s­tances of the buil­ding, any reso­lu­ti­ons pas­sed by the owners’ asso­cia­ti­on, the ten­an­cy agree­ment and the actu­al risk invol­ved. Anyo­ne who is unsu­re whe­ther their plan­ting is per­mit­ted, or who, as a land­lord or owner, wis­hes to enforce clear rules, should seek legal advice.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this