A window box on a balcony railing sounds harmless enough. Yet in blocks of flats, this can quickly turn into a serious legal dispute. In recent years, several courts have ruled on when window boxes may be hung outside, when they may be prohibited, and who is liable for any damage.
WEG resolution: The owners’ association may require the use of interior curtains
In November 2024, the Munich Local Court ruled that a flat owners’ association (WEG) may, by resolution, stipulate that all window boxes must be hung facing inwards (Case No. 1293 C 12154/24 WEG). In this specific case, a homeowner had attached six heavy ceramic planters to the outside of the building; these were neither adequately secured nor fixed in a storm-proof manner. Furthermore, water running down them had already discoloured the façade.
The court made it clear that the external areas of balconies form part of the common property. The Owners’ Association is therefore solely responsible for decisions regarding their design. Such a resolution is deemed to fall within the scope of proper administration, even if no specific instance of damage has occurred to date. This does not disproportionately restrict the affected owner’s freedom of personal expression.
However, the provision stipulating that the party responsible is automatically liable for all damages was declared partially invalid. This clause deviates from the legal principle that liability requires fault.
Watering is not allowed when neighbours are sitting on the terrace
The Munich I Regional Court has ruled that watering balcony plants may be prohibited if the water drips onto the terrace below whilst people are present there (Case No. 1 S 1836/13 WEG). In such cases, this constitutes an unreasonable nuisance within the meaning of the Condominium Act. The affected owner may demand that watering be suspended at such times.
Tenancy: Outdoor hanging may constitute a breach of contract
Flower boxes on the balcony are generally considered part of normal tenancy use. However, the situation may be different if the boxes are hung on the outside of the railing and this creates a specific hazard. The Berlin Regional Court has ruled that a landlord may prohibit hanging planters on the outside if cars are parked beneath the balcony and falling planters could endanger people or vehicles (Case No. 65 S 40/12). In this case, the tenant was required to remove the planters.
In contrast, the Hamburg Regional Court emphasised that external letterboxes are not generally prohibited. A specific risk must be proven. In the absence of such proof, hanging boxes outside remains permitted, provided that they are secured in such a way as to withstand strong winds (Case No. 316 S 79/04).
Overgrown vegetation and litter on the neighbouring terrace
Anyone who plants their balcony in such a way that plant debris and bird droppings fall onto their neighbour’s terrace must expect that the landlord will be obliged to take action. The Berlin Regional Court has ruled that a landlord may require their tenant to trim back the plants to a reasonable extent if the neighbour can no longer make proper use of their terrace due to the contamination (Case No. 67 S 127/02).
The owners’ association may not take legal action directly against tenants
Important for owners’ associations: The owners’ association itself cannot directly prohibit a tenant from installing window boxes. Only the respective owner has this right under the terms of the tenancy agreement. This was clarified by the Munich I Regional Court (Case No. 13 S 2348/01).
What does that mean in practice?
Whether flower boxes may be hung outside depends on several factors: the specific circumstances of the building, any resolutions passed by the owners’ association, the tenancy agreement and the actual risk involved. Anyone who is unsure whether their planting is permitted, or who, as a landlord or owner, wishes to enforce clear rules, should seek legal advice.
Source: Haufe: Property
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.