Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

20 years of the AGG: What the Equal Treatment Act means for employers

20 years of the AGG: What the Equal Treatment Act means for employers

The Gene­ral Equal Tre­at­ment Act, or AGG for short, is cele­bra­ting its 20th anni­ver­sa­ry this year. It came into force on 18 August 2006 and has sin­ce had a fun­da­men­tal impact on employ­ment law and HR prac­ti­ce in Ger­ma­ny. It is worth taking a look back, as the Act con­ti­nues to have very prac­ti­cal impli­ca­ti­ons for both employ­ers and employees.

What the AGG covers and who it protects

The AGG pro­hi­bits dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on on cer­tain grounds: race and eth­nic ori­gin, gen­der, reli­gi­on or belief, disa­bi­li­ty, age and sexu­al iden­ti­ty. As a gene­ral rule, the­se cha­rac­te­ristics must not play a role in the work­place, whe­ther in recruit­ment, pro­mo­ti­on, dis­mis­sal or remuneration.

It is important to distin­gu­ish bet­ween two fun­da­men­tal­ly dif­fe­rent types of ine­qua­li­ty. On the one hand, the­re is unju­s­ti­fied une­qual tre­at­ment: simi­lar cases are trea­ted dif­fer­ent­ly, even though the­re is no objec­ti­ve reason for this. On the other hand, the­re are situa­tions in which for­mal­ly equal tre­at­ment leads to unfair out­co­mes becau­se cer­tain groups are, in prac­ti­ce, pla­ced under a grea­ter bur­den. The AGG addres­ses both scenarios.

Harassment in the workplace: a separate category under the law

Sexu­al harass­ment and other forms of harass­ment in the work­place are also regu­la­ted under the AGG. An important prin­ci­ple appli­es here: the wrongful natu­re of harass­ment lies in the act its­elf, not mere­ly in com­pa­ri­son with the tre­at­ment of other employees. An employ­er who insults an employee on the grounds of their age is not acting unlawful­ly sim­ply becau­se they tre­at older employees less favour­a­b­ly than youn­ger ones, but becau­se the insult, in its­elf, vio­la­tes the digni­ty of the per­son con­cer­ned. This distinc­tion has legal con­se­quen­ces, for exam­p­le when it comes to deter­mi­ning whe­ther a cla­im for com­pen­sa­ti­on is likely to succeed.

Recent developments: pay transparency and regional legislation

Anti-dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on legis­la­ti­on is con­stant­ly evol­ving. The EU Pay Trans­pa­ren­cy Direc­ti­ve, which is inten­ded to obli­ge com­pa­nies to dis­c­lo­se and jus­ti­fy pay gaps bet­ween men and women, was ori­gi­nal­ly due to be trans­po­sed into Ger­man law by June 2026. This dead­line has pas­sed wit­hout an agree­ment having been rea­ched. Employ­ers should moni­tor deve­lo­p­ments clo­se­ly, as imple­men­ta­ti­on could result in signi­fi­cant docu­men­ta­ti­on and report­ing obli­ga­ti­ons for them.

At the same time, indi­vi­du­al fede­ral sta­tes are working on their own anti-dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on laws. Ber­lin and Rhi­ne­land-Pala­ti­na­te alre­a­dy have such legis­la­ti­on in place. North Rhi­ne-West­pha­lia is on the ver­ge of pas­sing a sta­te law that would go signi­fi­cant­ly bey­ond the scope of pro­tec­tion pro­vi­ded by the Fede­ral Anti-Dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on Act (AGG). It is inten­ded to cover not only the reco­g­nis­ed grounds of dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on, but also any form of unju­s­ti­fied une­qual tre­at­ment by public aut­ho­ri­ties. For pri­va­te employ­ers, the fede­ral AGG remains the gover­ning framework.

What does this mean for businesses?

Employ­ers must ensu­re that their job adver­ti­se­ments, recruit­ment pro­ce­du­res and inter­nal decis­i­ons do not take into account any grounds for dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on under the AGG. Exis­ting remu­ne­ra­ti­on sche­mes should be review­ed regu­lar­ly to check whe­ther they indi­rect­ly dis­ad­van­ta­ge cer­tain groups. Trai­ning on the pre­ven­ti­on of harass­ment is also advi­sa­ble for lia­bi­li­ty reasons.

The AGG pro­vi­des for claims for com­pen­sa­ti­on by tho­se affec­ted in the event of brea­ches. In dis­pu­tes, the bur­den of pro­of is also eased: anyo­ne who pres­ents cre­di­ble evi­dence sug­gest­ing dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on forces the employ­er to rebut this pre­sump­ti­on. This makes labour law dis­pu­tes in this area par­ti­cu­lar­ly sen­si­ti­ve. Whe­re in doubt, it is advi­sa­ble to seek legal advice at an ear­ly stage.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this