Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Kununu reviews: Employers can have them removed

Kununu reviews: Employers can have them removed

Anyo­ne who finds that their com­pa­ny has been given a poor rating on the Kun­unu review plat­form does not sim­ply have to accept this. In a recent case, the Han­sea­tic Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Ham­burg has cla­ri­fied that, under cer­tain con­di­ti­ons, employ­ers are entit­led to have anony­mous ent­ries remo­ved. Kun­unu with­drew its appeal fol­lo­wing a cor­re­spon­ding inte­rim order from the court, mea­ning that the out­co­me of the pro­cee­dings for a preli­mi­na­ry injunc­tion and the main pro­cee­dings befo­re the Ham­burg Regio­nal Court stands.

What was the subject of the dispute?

An employ­er had deman­ded that the plat­form remo­ve nega­ti­ve reviews. The crux of the pro­blem was that the reviews had been sub­mit­ted anony­mously, and the employ­er was unable to veri­fy whe­ther the aut­hors had actual­ly ever been employ­ed by them or had appli­ed for a job the­re. This is pre­cis­e­ly what is pos­si­ble on Kun­unu, as the plat­form allows posts wit­hout a requi­re­ment to use a real name. In theo­ry, the­r­e­fo­re, anyo­ne could pass jud­ge­ment on a com­pa­ny wit­hout ever having work­ed there.

What was the court’s ruling?

The Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Ham­burg cla­ri­fied that the prin­ci­ples of lia­bi­li­ty deve­lo­ped for online review por­tals app­ly. Accor­din­gly, it is gene­ral­ly suf­fi­ci­ent for the employ­er con­cer­ned to object that the review is not based on any actu­al cont­act bet­ween the aut­hor and the com­pa­ny. This objec­tion may be main­tai­ned until Kun­unu makes the review­er suf­fi­ci­ent­ly iden­ti­fia­ble to the employ­er to enable the lat­ter to veri­fy the exis­tence of a genui­ne employ­ment or job appli­ca­ti­on rela­ti­onship. As Kun­unu fai­led to ful­fil this obli­ga­ti­on, the employer’s appli­ca­ti­on was successful.

This line of argu­ment was upheld in the main pro­cee­dings befo­re the Ham­burg Regio­nal Court on 7 Febru­ary 2025. Kun­unu appar­ent­ly took the sub­se­quent refer­ral order issued by the Ham­burg Hig­her Regio­nal Court on 25 June 2026 as an oppor­tu­ni­ty to with­draw its appeal. The Hig­her Regio­nal Court’s order was sub­se­quent­ly issued on 13 July 2026 under file num­ber 7 U 8/25.

What does this mean for businesses?

Employ­ers who find them­sel­ves faced with anony­mous and defa­ma­to­ry reviews on Kun­unu now have a signi­fi­cant­ly stron­ger legal basis. Anyo­ne who objects to such a review and requests Kun­unu to pro­ve the authen­ti­ci­ty of the employ­ment rela­ti­onship may insist on its rem­oval if no evi­dence is pro­vi­ded. It is important to act swift­ly. Inte­rim injunc­tions – that is, urgent court orders – requi­re a sen­se of urgen­cy, which may cea­se to app­ly if one waits too long.

What applies to employees?

On the other hand, the ruling does not mean that Kun­unu would be obli­ged to dis­c­lo­se the real names of review­ers imme­dia­te­ly at an employer’s request. Accor­ding to the ruling of the Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Ham­burg, no such direct right exists. Nevert­hel­ess, it should be bor­ne in mind that the con­tent of a review, when com­bi­ned with other infor­ma­ti­on, often makes it pos­si­ble to iden­ti­fy the per­son who wro­te it.

Background: Kununu’s business model

The court also indi­ca­ted that the platform’s busi­ness model should be view­ed cri­ti­cal­ly. On the one hand, Kun­unu allows anony­mous, poten­ti­al­ly repu­ta­ti­on-dama­ging posts; at the same time, it sells paid pro­files to employ­ers to enhan­ce their repu­ta­ti­on. This inter­play was dis­cus­sed during the pro­cee­dings and is likely to have influen­ced the court’s assessment.

Affec­ted com­pa­nies should have the spe­ci­fic cir­cum­s­tances of their case review­ed by a soli­ci­tor, as the pro­s­pects of suc­cess depend on the con­tent, wor­ding and timing of their response.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this