Anyone who finds that their company has been given a poor rating on the Kununu review platform does not simply have to accept this. In a recent case, the Hanseatic Higher Regional Court of Hamburg has clarified that, under certain conditions, employers are entitled to have anonymous entries removed. Kununu withdrew its appeal following a corresponding interim order from the court, meaning that the outcome of the proceedings for a preliminary injunction and the main proceedings before the Hamburg Regional Court stands.
What was the subject of the dispute?
An employer had demanded that the platform remove negative reviews. The crux of the problem was that the reviews had been submitted anonymously, and the employer was unable to verify whether the authors had actually ever been employed by them or had applied for a job there. This is precisely what is possible on Kununu, as the platform allows posts without a requirement to use a real name. In theory, therefore, anyone could pass judgement on a company without ever having worked there.
What was the court’s ruling?
The Higher Regional Court of Hamburg clarified that the principles of liability developed for online review portals apply. Accordingly, it is generally sufficient for the employer concerned to object that the review is not based on any actual contact between the author and the company. This objection may be maintained until Kununu makes the reviewer sufficiently identifiable to the employer to enable the latter to verify the existence of a genuine employment or job application relationship. As Kununu failed to fulfil this obligation, the employer’s application was successful.
This line of argument was upheld in the main proceedings before the Hamburg Regional Court on 7 February 2025. Kununu apparently took the subsequent referral order issued by the Hamburg Higher Regional Court on 25 June 2026 as an opportunity to withdraw its appeal. The Higher Regional Court’s order was subsequently issued on 13 July 2026 under file number 7 U 8/25.
What does this mean for businesses?
Employers who find themselves faced with anonymous and defamatory reviews on Kununu now have a significantly stronger legal basis. Anyone who objects to such a review and requests Kununu to prove the authenticity of the employment relationship may insist on its removal if no evidence is provided. It is important to act swiftly. Interim injunctions – that is, urgent court orders – require a sense of urgency, which may cease to apply if one waits too long.
What applies to employees?
On the other hand, the ruling does not mean that Kununu would be obliged to disclose the real names of reviewers immediately at an employer’s request. According to the ruling of the Higher Regional Court of Hamburg, no such direct right exists. Nevertheless, it should be borne in mind that the content of a review, when combined with other information, often makes it possible to identify the person who wrote it.
Background: Kununu’s business model
The court also indicated that the platform’s business model should be viewed critically. On the one hand, Kununu allows anonymous, potentially reputation-damaging posts; at the same time, it sells paid profiles to employers to enhance their reputation. This interplay was discussed during the proceedings and is likely to have influenced the court’s assessment.
Affected companies should have the specific circumstances of their case reviewed by a solicitor, as the prospects of success depend on the content, wording and timing of their response.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.