Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Child benefit for non-EU nationals: employee status ends 12 months after the birth

Fol­lo­wing the birth of a child, an EU citizen’s sta­tus as an employee cea­ses after 12 months at the latest. The Düs­sel­dorf Finan­ce Court has set a clear time limit for child bene­fit entitlements. 
Child benefit for non-EU nationals: employee status ends 12 months after the birth

Child benefit for non-EU nationals: employee status ends 12 months after the birth

If EU citi­zens find them­sel­ves out of work after giving birth, they can still recei­ve child bene­fit for a cer­tain peri­od. But how long does this app­ly for? The Düs­sel­dorf Finan­ce Court has now set a clear time limit: the so-cal­led ‘retroac­ti­ve employee sta­tus’ ends 12 months after the child’s birth.

What is it about?

A Polish natio­nal, who gave birth to her child in June 2023, appli­ed for child bene­fit from the month of the birth. She had work­ed as a clea­ner on a ‘mini­job’ basis both befo­re and after the birth, from March to August 2023. After her employ­ment ended, she did not take up any new employ­ment. The fami­ly bene­fits office rejec­ted the child bene­fit appli­ca­ti­on on the grounds that the woman had not pro­vi­ded suf­fi­ci­ent evi­dence of her right to free­dom of movement.

The right to free­dom of move­ment is cru­cial for EU citi­zens in Ger­ma­ny: anyo­ne who works here or is loo­king for work is entit­led to cer­tain social secu­ri­ty bene­fits. Howe­ver, anyo­ne who is neither in employ­ment nor can pro­ve that they are loo­king for work may lose the­se entitlements.

What was the court’s ruling?

The Düs­sel­dorf Finan­ce Court ruled part­ly in favour of the clai­mant. For the peri­od of her actu­al employ­ment from March to August 2023, she met the eli­gi­bi­li­ty cri­te­ria for child bene­fit as an employee. This part of the cla­im was not in dispute.

The ques­ti­on of what appli­es the­re­af­ter was more dif­fi­cult. The court reli­ed on a 2014 judgment of the Euro­pean Court of Jus­ti­ce (ECJ, judgment of 19 June 2014, Case C‑507/12, known as the ‘Saint-Prix’ ruling). Accor­ding to this, women who are tem­po­r­a­ri­ly unable to work due to pregnan­cy or child­birth do not imme­dia­te­ly lose their sta­tus as employees. They retain this sta­tus for a reasonable peri­od of time, during which they have the oppor­tu­ni­ty to return to work.

The ECJ left open the ques­ti­on of how long this peri­od is. The Düs­sel­dorf Finan­ce Court has now based its decis­i­on on a pro­vi­si­on in the Free­dom of Move­ment Act: Sec­tion 4a(6)(3) of the Free­dom of Move­ment Act (FreizügG/EU) sti­pu­la­tes that 12 months is the peri­od during which the right to per­ma­nent resi­dence remains unaf­fec­ted. The court adopted this peri­od as its bench­mark. The con­tin­ued sta­tus as an employee cea­ses 12 months after the birth.

As the clai­mant neither took up new employ­ment within this peri­od nor was able to pro­vi­de evi­dence of a pro­mi­sing job search, nor did she sub­mit con­fir­ma­ti­on from the employ­ment agen­cy of her unem­ploy­ment sta­tus, she was no lon­ger entit­led to child bene­fit after August 2023.

What does that mean in practice?

For EU citi­zens who wish to cla­im child bene­fit in Ger­ma­ny fol­lo­wing the birth of a child, whilst not curr­ent­ly in employ­ment, clear evi­dence is essen­ti­al. Anyo­ne who is no lon­ger in work must pro­ve that they are actively see­king employ­ment, are regis­tered with the Job­cent­re, or have suf­fi­ci­ent per­so­nal funds. If this evi­dence is miss­ing, the­re is a risk that the appli­ca­ti­on will be rejected.

Important: The mat­ter has not yet been defi­ni­tively resol­ved. The Düs­sel­dorf Finan­ce Court has gran­ted lea­ve to appeal; the case is now pen­ding befo­re the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court under refe­rence num­ber III R 29/25. Fur­ther appeals on simi­lar issues are also alre­a­dy pen­ding the­re, inclu­ding, in par­ti­cu­lar, one con­cer­ning the signi­fi­can­ce of pregnan­cy (Ref. III R 27/24). Tho­se affec­ted should keep an eye on any cur­rent tax assess­ment noti­ces and, whe­re neces­sa­ry, lea­ve them open.

The jud­ge­ment of the Düs­sel­dorf Finan­ce Court is dated 31 July 2025, case num­ber 15 K 2413/24 Kg.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this