Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

AI in housing allocation: What landlords need to bear in mind under the AGG

AI in housing allocation: What landlords need to bear in mind under the AGG

Housing orga­ni­sa­ti­ons are incre­asing­ly tur­ning to digi­tal tools and algo­rith­ms to cope with the gro­wing flood of appli­ca­ti­ons. In sought-after loca­ti­ons, a sin­gle advert can quick­ly attract seve­ral hundred enqui­ries. Howe­ver, the use of auto­ma­ted sys­tems car­ri­es signi­fi­cant legal risks, par­ti­cu­lar­ly with regard to the Gene­ral Equal Tre­at­ment Act (AGG).

What is the AGG and why is it relevant to letting?

The AGG pro­hi­bits dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on on the grounds of cha­rac­te­ristics such as eth­nic ori­gin, gen­der, reli­gi­on, age or disa­bi­li­ty. Housing orga­ni­sa­ti­ons are bound by this when allo­ca­ting flats. Brea­ches can pro­ve cos­t­ly: courts fre­quent­ly award tho­se affec­ted dama­ges amoun­ting to two to three times the month­ly rent. And this appli­es not only to decis­i­ons made by a per­son, but also to errors made by an algorithm.

Algorithms do not discriminate on a case-by-case basis, but systematically

That is the real pro­blem. A human case worker can reflect on indi­vi­du­al cases, weigh up the cir­cum­s­tances and show empa­thy. A poor­ly trai­ned AI sys­tem, on the other hand, con­sis­t­ent­ly repeats lear­nt pat­terns wit­hout excep­ti­on. If his­to­ri­cal award data dis­ad­van­ta­ges cer­tain groups, the AI lear­ns pre­cis­e­ly that as the norm and con­ti­nues to do so. Address data can act as a hid­den indi­ca­tor of ori­gin, whilst lan­guage pat­terns can ser­ve as a pro­xy for eth­ni­ci­ty. Both are pro­hi­bi­ted under the AGG.

The Fede­ral Anti-Dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on Agen­cy repor­ted that it had dealt with around 500 cases rela­ting to the housing mar­ket in 2025, an increase of 25 per cent on the pre­vious year. The actu­al num­ber of unre­por­ted cases is likely to be signi­fi­cant­ly higher.

What landlords and housing associations need to bear in mind in practical terms

Caro­lin Klein, a soli­ci­tor at the law firm Heu­king, sets out five requi­re­ments for allo­ca­ting accom­mo­da­ti­on in accordance with the Gene­ral Equal Tre­at­ment Act (AGG) using digi­tal systems:

  • Trans­pa­ren­cy of the sel­ec­tion cri­te­ria:It must be pos­si­ble at all times to under­stand and explain who is asses­sed and on the basis of which criteria.
  • No indi­rect dis­cri­mi­na­ti­on:See­mingly neu­tral cha­rac­te­ristics, such as an address or speech pat­terns, must not be used as a sub­sti­tu­te for pro­tec­ted characteristics.
  • Accu­ra­te trai­ning data:Sys­tems based on dis­tor­ted his­to­ri­cal data per­pe­tua­te past inju­s­ti­ces and are legal­ly problematic.
  • Ran­dom sel­ec­tion whe­re can­di­da­tes have the same qua­li­fi­ca­ti­ons:If seve­ral can­di­da­tes are equal­ly sui­ta­ble, a draw must be held.
  • Respon­si­bi­li­ty remains with the com­pa­ny:Regu­lar spot checks and the ana­ly­sis of com­plaints are man­da­to­ry, regard­less of which soft­ware is used.

The EU AI Act requires human final decision-making

Ful­ly auto­ma­ted rejec­tions – for exam­p­le, based on a cre­dit score – are not per­mit­ted under the EU AI Act in the con­text of high-risk data pro­ces­sing. The final decis­i­on on a ten­an­cy agree­ment must be made by a human being. Housing orga­ni­sa­ti­ons that igno­re this risk brea­ching not only the AGG but also Euro­pean law.

What does this mean for private landlords and smaller companies?

Even tho­se who let only a few flats and do not use com­plex soft­ware are bound by the AGG. Reasons for rejec­tion should be docu­men­ted in a way that is trans­pa­rent. Anyo­ne using a ser­vice pro­vi­der or a let­ting plat­form is still per­so­nal­ly lia­ble for dis­cri­mi­na­to­ry let­ting decis­i­ons made through that chan­nel. Whe­re in doubt, it is advi­sa­ble to seek legal advice befo­re intro­du­cing new digi­tal processes.

Anyo­ne who wis­hes to check now whe­ther their recruit­ment pro­ces­ses com­ply with the AGG should not put it off. Undo­cu­men­ted pro­ce­du­res in par­ti­cu­lar – tho­se based on past expe­ri­ence or gut fee­ling – are vir­tual­ly impos­si­ble to defend in court.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this