Anyone trading in options on the stock exchange may find themselves in a tax dilemma: profits from option premiums are taxed, whilst the economically related losses from share sales may not be offset against tax. The Baden-Württemberg Finance Court has now ruled that, in such a case, the state may be obliged to cap the tax burden on grounds of fairness if the affected parties’ income would otherwise fall below the subsistence level.
What had happened?
A married couple carried out so-called option writing transactions in 2006 and 2007. In doing so, the claimants sold share options and received premiums in return. When buyers exercised their options, the claimants had to purchase the relevant shares at a high price on the stock exchange in order to fulfil their delivery obligation. This led to substantial losses from the sale of shares: around 300,000 euros in 2006 and almost 850,000 euros in 2007.
For tax purposes, the premium income was taxed as other income under Section 22(3) of the Income Tax Act (EStG). Losses arising from the sale of shares, on the other hand, were treated as private disposal transactions under Section 23 of the Income Tax Act (EStG). Due to the statutory principle of separation, offsetting these two amounts against one another was prohibited. The tax office rejected an application for a different tax assessment on grounds of equity.
The subjective net principle as a limit on taxation
The Baden-Württemberg Finance Court took a different view, at least on one key point. Whilst it initially confirmed that the statutory prohibition on loss set-off is not, in itself, objectively unfair, The legislature had specifically intended this provision to prevent tax-saving schemes, and a generous measure based on equity would undermine this objective.
Nevertheless, the court ordered the tax office to reconsider its decision because the so-called ‘subjective net principle’ had been breached. This principle has constitutional status and stipulates that, each year, the taxpayer must be allowed to retain as much of their income as is necessary to cover their own and their family’s basic living expenses. Taxation that falls below this subsistence minimum is unconstitutional, even if it is based on a formally correct law.
In doing so, the court laid down a annual perspectiveas a basis. It is not sufficient to refer to subsequent years in which adjustments are made. Protection of the minimum subsistence level must be guaranteed for each individual tax year. For 2006, the total tax burden comprising income tax, the solidarity surcharge and church tax must therefore not exceed 293,865 euros; for 2007, it must not exceed 474,748 euros.
Tax office’s discretion reduced to zero
The legal implication is interesting: the court considered a so-called Reduction of discretion to zero. This means that the tax office no longer has any discretion in deciding whether to limit the tax liability. It must grant a partial remission. However, the tax office may choose which of the measures provided for by law under Section 163 of the Tax Code it will use to reduce the tax liability to the permissible level.
What does this mean for those affected?
The judgement shows that even tax assessment notices that comply with the law can be amended if they infringe upon the minimum subsistence level. Anyone carrying out complex capital market transactions and falling into tax loss traps should have their case reviewed to see whether an application for equitable relief is an option. The procedure is complex and requires a precise calculation of one’s actual economic capacity.
The judgement was handed down at second instance. The case number is 2 K 827/23, Baden-Württemberg Finance Court, judgement of 17 July 2025.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.