Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Equity relief for option transactions: the subsistence level protects against an excessive tax burden

Baden-Würt­tem­berg Finan­ce Court: Whe­re the­re is a pro­hi­bi­ti­on on off­set­ting los­ses, a dif­fe­rent tax assess­ment may be requi­red to safe­guard the mini­mum sub­sis­tence level. 
Equity relief for option transactions: the subsistence level protects against an excessive tax burden

Equity relief for option transactions: the subsistence level protects against an excessive tax burden

Anyo­ne tra­ding in opti­ons on the stock exch­an­ge may find them­sel­ves in a tax dilem­ma: pro­fits from opti­on pre­mi­ums are taxed, whilst the eco­no­mic­al­ly rela­ted los­ses from share sales may not be off­set against tax. The Baden-Würt­tem­berg Finan­ce Court has now ruled that, in such a case, the sta­te may be obli­ged to cap the tax bur­den on grounds of fair­ness if the affec­ted par­ties’ inco­me would other­wi­se fall below the sub­sis­tence level.

What had happened?

A mar­ried cou­ple car­ri­ed out so-cal­led opti­on wri­ting tran­sac­tions in 2006 and 2007. In doing so, the clai­mants sold share opti­ons and recei­ved pre­mi­ums in return. When buy­ers exer­cis­ed their opti­ons, the clai­mants had to purcha­se the rele­vant shares at a high pri­ce on the stock exch­an­ge in order to ful­fil their deli­very obli­ga­ti­on. This led to sub­stan­ti­al los­ses from the sale of shares: around 300,000 euros in 2006 and almost 850,000 euros in 2007.

For tax pur­po­ses, the pre­mi­um inco­me was taxed as other inco­me under Sec­tion 22(3) of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG). Los­ses ari­sing from the sale of shares, on the other hand, were trea­ted as pri­va­te dis­po­sal tran­sac­tions under Sec­tion 23 of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG). Due to the sta­tu­to­ry prin­ci­ple of sepa­ra­ti­on, off­set­ting the­se two amounts against one ano­ther was pro­hi­bi­ted. The tax office rejec­ted an appli­ca­ti­on for a dif­fe­rent tax assess­ment on grounds of equity.

The subjective net principle as a limit on taxation

The Baden-Würt­tem­berg Finan­ce Court took a dif­fe­rent view, at least on one key point. Whilst it initi­al­ly con­firm­ed that the sta­tu­to­ry pro­hi­bi­ti­on on loss set-off is not, in its­elf, objec­tively unfair, The legis­la­tu­re had spe­ci­fi­cal­ly inten­ded this pro­vi­si­on to pre­vent tax-saving sche­mes, and a gene­rous mea­su­re based on equi­ty would under­mi­ne this objective.

Nevert­hel­ess, the court orde­red the tax office to recon­sider its decis­i­on becau­se the so-cal­led ‘sub­jec­ti­ve net prin­ci­ple’ had been brea­ched. This prin­ci­ple has con­sti­tu­tio­nal sta­tus and sti­pu­la­tes that, each year, the tax­pay­er must be allo­wed to retain as much of their inco­me as is neces­sa­ry to cover their own and their family’s basic living expen­ses. Taxa­ti­on that falls below this sub­sis­tence mini­mum is uncon­sti­tu­tio­nal, even if it is based on a for­mal­ly cor­rect law.

In doing so, the court laid down a annu­al per­spec­ti­veas a basis. It is not suf­fi­ci­ent to refer to sub­se­quent years in which adjus­t­ments are made. Pro­tec­tion of the mini­mum sub­sis­tence level must be gua­ran­teed for each indi­vi­du­al tax year. For 2006, the total tax bur­den com­pri­sing inco­me tax, the soli­da­ri­ty surchar­ge and church tax must the­r­e­fo­re not exceed 293,865 euros; for 2007, it must not exceed 474,748 euros.

Tax office’s discretion reduced to zero

The legal impli­ca­ti­on is inte­res­t­ing: the court con­side­red a so-cal­led Reduc­tion of dis­cre­ti­on to zero. This means that the tax office no lon­ger has any dis­cre­ti­on in deci­ding whe­ther to limit the tax lia­bi­li­ty. It must grant a par­ti­al remis­si­on. Howe­ver, the tax office may choo­se which of the mea­su­res pro­vi­ded for by law under Sec­tion 163 of the Tax Code it will use to redu­ce the tax lia­bi­li­ty to the per­mis­si­ble level.

What does this mean for those affected?

The jud­ge­ment shows that even tax assess­ment noti­ces that com­ply with the law can be amen­ded if they inf­rin­ge upon the mini­mum sub­sis­tence level. Anyo­ne car­ry­ing out com­plex capi­tal mar­ket tran­sac­tions and fal­ling into tax loss traps should have their case review­ed to see whe­ther an appli­ca­ti­on for equi­ta­ble reli­ef is an opti­on. The pro­ce­du­re is com­plex and requi­res a pre­cise cal­cu­la­ti­on of one’s actu­al eco­no­mic capacity.

The jud­ge­ment was han­ded down at second ins­tance. The case num­ber is 2 K 827/23, Baden-Würt­tem­berg Finan­ce Court, jud­ge­ment of 17 July 2025.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this