On 9 July 2026, the Federal Fiscal Court published four new judgements. The rulings concern issues of practical significance for employees with links to foreign countries, property owners and families in cross-border situations.
No entitlement to a refund in the case of income tax wrongly withheld
The ruling with arguably the most far-reaching consequences concerns employees from whom the employer has deducted income tax, even though this was not actually permitted under a double taxation agreement or due to their limited tax liability. Until now, these employees have been able to claim back the excess income tax paid directly from the tax office. That is now no longer the case.
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) has expressly departed from its previous case law. In such circumstances, employees will no longer have a direct claim for a refund against the tax office (judgement of 9 April 2026, case number VI R 12/24).
Important: Anyone who has claimed such a right to a refund from the tax office by the date the judgement is published – that is, 9 July 2026 – is protected by the principle of legitimate expectations. The old principles continue to apply in these cases. Anyone who has not yet submitted a claim should seek tax advice at the earliest opportunity.
Cross-border commuters to Switzerland: case-by-case assessment of days not spent in Switzerland
For employees who live in Germany and work in Switzerland, or vice versa, the double taxation agreement between Germany and Switzerland sets out specific tax rules. One of the key factors here is the number of days a person has spent away from their place of residence for work-related reasons.
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) makes it clear that whether a return journey was unreasonable cannot be determined solely on the basis of the distance between the place of residence and the place of work. The decisive factor is the specific circumstances of the individual case, in particular work-related factors. Flat-rate mileage rules are not sufficient (judgement of 9 April 2026, reference number VI R 31/24).
Land Transfer Tax: No concessions for informal groups of people
Section 6a of the Land Transfer Tax Act provides for a tax relief where land is transferred within a group of companies. One of the conditions is that there must be a controlling company.
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) has now clarified that a mere group of natural persons without a legal entity under company law cannot constitute such a controlling company. Anyone wishing to claim the tax relief must have a recognised legal form, such as a limited liability company (GmbH), a partnership or a community of heirs (judgement of 8 April 2026, case number II R 2/23).
Child benefit after Brexit: Grandfathering of existing entitlements
The latest ruling concerns child benefit cases relating to the United Kingdom. Following Brexit, certain family benefits are protected under grandfathering provisions if the entitlement already existed at the end of the transition period.
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) has ruled that this protection also applies even if only the family members are in a cross-border situation and not the person from whom the entitlement is derived. This may be relevant for families with a British-German background (judgement of 18 March 2026, case number III R 10/25).
Anyone who might be affected by one of these decisions should have their own situation reviewed by a tax adviser or solicitor.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.