If EU citizens find themselves out of work after giving birth, they can still receive child benefit for a certain period. But how long does this apply for? The Düsseldorf Finance Court has now set a clear time limit: the so-called ‘retroactive employee status’ ends 12 months after the child’s birth.
What is it about?
A Polish national, who gave birth to her child in June 2023, applied for child benefit from the month of the birth. She had worked as a cleaner on a ‘minijob’ basis both before and after the birth, from March to August 2023. After her employment ended, she did not take up any new employment. The family benefits office rejected the child benefit application on the grounds that the woman had not provided sufficient evidence of her right to freedom of movement.
The right to freedom of movement is crucial for EU citizens in Germany: anyone who works here or is looking for work is entitled to certain social security benefits. However, anyone who is neither in employment nor can prove that they are looking for work may lose these entitlements.
What was the court’s ruling?
The Düsseldorf Finance Court ruled partly in favour of the claimant. For the period of her actual employment from March to August 2023, she met the eligibility criteria for child benefit as an employee. This part of the claim was not in dispute.
The question of what applies thereafter was more difficult. The court relied on a 2014 judgment of the European Court of Justice (ECJ, judgment of 19 June 2014, Case C‑507/12, known as the ‘Saint-Prix’ ruling). According to this, women who are temporarily unable to work due to pregnancy or childbirth do not immediately lose their status as employees. They retain this status for a reasonable period of time, during which they have the opportunity to return to work.
The ECJ left open the question of how long this period is. The Düsseldorf Finance Court has now based its decision on a provision in the Freedom of Movement Act: Section 4a(6)(3) of the Freedom of Movement Act (FreizügG/EU) stipulates that 12 months is the period during which the right to permanent residence remains unaffected. The court adopted this period as its benchmark. The continued status as an employee ceases 12 months after the birth.
As the claimant neither took up new employment within this period nor was able to provide evidence of a promising job search, nor did she submit confirmation from the employment agency of her unemployment status, she was no longer entitled to child benefit after August 2023.
What does that mean in practice?
For EU citizens who wish to claim child benefit in Germany following the birth of a child, whilst not currently in employment, clear evidence is essential. Anyone who is no longer in work must prove that they are actively seeking employment, are registered with the Jobcentre, or have sufficient personal funds. If this evidence is missing, there is a risk that the application will be rejected.
Important: The matter has not yet been definitively resolved. The Düsseldorf Finance Court has granted leave to appeal; the case is now pending before the Federal Finance Court under reference number III R 29/25. Further appeals on similar issues are also already pending there, including, in particular, one concerning the significance of pregnancy (Ref. III R 27/24). Those affected should keep an eye on any current tax assessment notices and, where necessary, leave them open.
The judgement of the Düsseldorf Finance Court is dated 31 July 2025, case number 15 K 2413/24 Kg.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.