Works council members generally serve in an honorary capacity and receive no additional remuneration for their work on the council. This may sound simple at first, but in practice it is anything but straightforward. This is because, although the role itself is unpaid, works council members are entitled to continued payment of their regular wages whilst they are on leave to carry out their works council duties. This so-called ‘loss of earnings’ principle regularly gives rise to uncertainty and legal disputes in many companies.
The legal framework
The legal basis is set out in the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG). Under Section 37(1) of the BetrVG, serving on the works council is an unpaid voluntary position. At the same time, Section 37(2) of the BetrVG stipulates that works council members must not suffer any financial disadvantage during the period of their time off work. The employer must therefore always calculate their pay as if the works council member had worked normally during that period.
In practical terms, this means that if any overtime had been worked during the period of leave, or if the member had received an allowance, this must also be taken into account when calculating remuneration. Figuratively speaking, the employer must keep a sort of ‘shadow payslip’ for each works council member on leave, showing what they would have earned had they not been carrying out their works council duties.
Legislative changes in 2024 will provide greater clarity
One of the factors underlying the uncertainties of recent years was a judgement of the Federal Court of Justice dated 10 January 2023 (Case No. 6 StR 133/22). In that ruling, the Federal Court of Justice held that members of the executive board may be guilty of breach of trust if they grant excessive remuneration to works council members. The case originated from proceedings against VW managers. As a result, many companies took the precautionary step of reducing the remuneration of their works council members, which in turn led to a wave of legal action.
To remove these uncertainties, Sections 37 and 78 of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG) were amended in 2024. Since then, the law has stipulated that:
- The date on which an employee first takes up their post is decisive for determining comparable employees.
- The employer and the works council may set out a procedure for determining this reference group in a works agreement.
- Remuneration higher than the statutory minimum is permissible if there are objective grounds for it and the decision was taken without any error of discretion.
Recent BAG ruling on acquired qualifications
In its judgement of 13 August 2025 (Case No. 7 AZR 174/24), the Federal Labour Court has addressed another important issue: employers must, as a general rule, take into account any qualifications acquired by a works council member during their term of office when assessing their notional career progression. However, this does not apply to skills that relate exclusively to the works council role itself, such as negotiation skills acquired during works council negotiations.
What does this mean for businesses?
Employers who employ works council members or are required to pay remuneration to newly seconded works council members should carefully document and regularly review the development of such remuneration. Remuneration that is either too high or too low can have legal consequences. Whilst the legislative changes of 2024 have brought greater legal certainty, practical questions remain unresolved. In case of doubt, it is advisable to seek advice on employment law to avoid costly mistakes.
Source: Haufe: Law
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.