Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Federal Court of Justice: Property managers may not charge a commission for re-letting

Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH): A pro­per­ty mana­ger may not char­ge a bro­kera­ge com­mis­si­on if they also mana­ge the same flat. Any sums alre­a­dy paid may be reclaimed. 
Federal Court of Justice: Property managers may not charge a commission for re-letting

Federal Court of Justice: Property managers may not charge a commission for re-letting

Anyo­ne who mana­ges a flat whilst also acting as an estate agent may not char­ge a com­mis­si­on for doing so. This was ruled by the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce in its jud­ge­ment of 21 May 2026, ther­eby put­ting a clear stop to a wide­spread prac­ti­ce in the pro­per­ty sec­tor (BGH, ref. I ZR 224/25).

What had happened?

A pro­per­ty owner had ent­rus­ted a com­mer­cial pro­per­ty mana­ger with the manage­ment of 129 resi­den­ti­al units and 134 gara­ges. The pro­per­ty mana­ger was con­trac­tual­ly aut­ho­ri­sed to car­ry out all day-to-day manage­ment tasks, inclu­ding the con­clu­si­on of new ten­an­cy agree­ments on behalf of the owner. For day-to-day manage­ment, he recei­ved a month­ly flat-rate fee per unit. In addi­ti­on, the manage­ment con­tract pro­vi­ded for a com­mis­si­on of two months’ basic rent for each suc­cessful new letting.

During the term of the con­tract, the pro­per­ty mana­ger invoi­ced com­mis­si­ons total­ling around 16,800 euros. Fol­lo­wing the ter­mi­na­ti­on of the con­trac­tu­al rela­ti­onship, the owner deman­ded the return of this money. The case even­tual­ly rea­ched the Fede­ral Court of Justice.

The Federal Court of Justice’s ruling

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) upheld the ruling of the Hig­her Regio­nal Court of Düs­sel­dorf and found in favour of the owner. The decis­i­on is based on the Resi­den­ti­al Pro­per­ty Agen­cy Act (WoVer­mittG). Accor­ding to Sec­tion 2(2), first sen­tence, No. 2 of that Act, a let­ting agent may not char­ge a com­mis­si­on if they are also the pro­per­ty mana­ger of the flat in ques­ti­on. In the BGH’s view, this pro­hi­bi­ti­on appli­es not only to the ten­ant but also to the landlord.

In its reaso­ning, the court sta­ted that the wor­ding of the pro­vi­si­on did not con­tain any rest­ric­tion to agree­ments with ten­ants. The pro­tec­ti­ve pur­po­se of the law also sup­ports a broad inter­pre­ta­ti­on: if the land­lord pays the com­mis­si­on, he can pass this on to the ten­ant eco­no­mic­al­ly by char­ging a hig­her rent. The ten­ant would thus be indi­rect­ly bur­den­ed with cos­ts, even though they never com­mis­sio­ned the pro­per­ty mana­ger themselves.

The court also found no con­sti­tu­tio­nal con­cerns. The pro­per­ty manager’s free­dom to choo­se a pro­fes­si­on, as enshri­ned in Artic­le 12 of the Basic Law, is not dis­pro­por­tio­na­te­ly rest­ric­ted by the sta­tu­to­ry ban on com­mis­si­on. In intro­du­cing this pro­vi­si­on, the legis­la­tu­re deli­bera­te­ly sought to address abu­ses in a tight housing market.

What does that mean in practice?

The ruling has far-rea­ching impli­ca­ti­ons for pro­per­ty mana­gers and owners ali­ke. Many exis­ting pro­per­ty manage­ment con­tracts con­tain com­mis­si­on clau­ses of this kind, which are now inva­lid fol­lo­wing this ruling. This has two consequences:

  • Loo­king ahead:Com­mis­si­ons alre­a­dy agreed upon for new ten­an­ci­es can no lon­ger be legal­ly enforced.
  • As for the past:Com­mis­si­ons that have alre­a­dy been paid may, under cer­tain cir­cum­s­tances, be reclai­med, pro­vi­ded that the limi­ta­ti­on peri­od has not yet expired.

Owners who have made such pay­ments in the past should check whe­ther they are entit­led to a refund. Pro­per­ty mana­gers, for their part, should review their con­tract tem­pla­tes and check cur­rent con­tracts for rele­vant clauses.

Any owner or pro­per­ty mana­ger who is unsu­re how to deal with exis­ting con­tracts or pay­ments alre­a­dy made should seek legal advice at the ear­liest opportunity.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this