Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Final COVID-19 settlement: Why the appeal process is the deciding factor

Karls­ru­he Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court: Fixed cos­ts sub­mit­ted as part of an appeal must be exami­ned. Any­thing sub­mit­ted after that is disregarded. 
Final COVID-19 settlement: Why the appeal process is the deciding factor

Final COVID-19 settlement: Why the appeal process is the deciding factor

Anyo­ne lodging an appeal against a reduc­tion in their coro­na­vi­rus bridging sup­port should be awa­re that the state­ment of grounds for the appeal is the last real oppor­tu­ni­ty to put for­ward new argu­ments and figu­res. Any­thing omit­ted from the appeal is high­ly likely to be dis­re­gard­ed in sub­se­quent legal pro­cee­dings. The Karls­ru­he Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court made this clear in a jud­ge­ment dated 7 July 2026 (Case No. 8 K 12012/25).

What had happened?

A limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH) in the plant engi­nee­ring sec­tor had appli­ed for and been gran­ted ‘Bridging Aid I’ of 50,000 euros for August 2020. Howe­ver, the busi­ness pre­mi­ses did not belong to the GmbH its­elf, but were joint­ly owned by the sole share­hol­der and his wife. The GmbH paid them month­ly rent of around 31,533 euros.

It was pre­cis­e­ly the­se ren­tal cos­ts that the rele­vant L‑Bank struck out enti­re­ly in its final decis­i­on. Its reaso­ning was that, accor­ding to the FAQs on Bridging Aid I, pay­ments within a group of com­pa­nies are not eli­gi­ble for fun­ding. Ins­tead of 50,000 euros, only around 32,930 euros remain­ed; the rest had to be repaid.

Amendments to an appeal were admissible

During the appeal pro­cee­dings, the GmbH not only sought to chall­enge the assump­ti­on of a group, but also, in the alter­na­ti­ve, clai­med fur­ther fixed cos­ts, spe­ci­fi­cal­ly pro­per­ty tax and inte­rest expen­ses. L‑Bank com­ple­te­ly dis­re­gard­ed this argu­ment and rejec­ted the appeal. It argued that no fur­ther chan­ges were pos­si­ble once the final assess­ment noti­ce had been issued.

The Karls­ru­he Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court took a dif­fe­rent view. Accor­ding to estab­lished case law, the rele­vant point in time for asses­sing a dis­cre­tio­na­ry decis­i­on is the date on which the noti­ce of decis­i­on on the appeal is issued, not that of the ori­gi­nal decis­i­on. This means that anyo­ne who spe­ci­fies new fixed cos­ts or amends details during the appeal pro­cee­dings com­pels the aut­ho­ri­ty to address the­se issues. If it fails to do so, this con­sti­tu­tes a so-cal­led fail­ure to exer­cise dis­cre­ti­on – that is, a pro­ce­du­ral error which may lead to the decis­i­on being set aside.

The court also made it clear that, in such cases, the aut­ho­ri­ty must its­elf request the third par­ty car­ry­ing out the audit – that is, the tax advi­ser – to sub­mit a cor­rec­ted final state­ment. The tech­ni­cal clo­sure of the por­tal does not reli­e­ve the aut­ho­ri­ty of this obligation.

Too late is too late: two proposals have failed

At the same time, the jud­ge­ment high­lights the down­si­de. Rent-rela­ted ser­vice char­ges amoun­ting to 383 euros had been inad­ver­t­ent­ly ente­red under the wrong fixed-cost hea­ding. This error only came to light during the oral hea­ring, i.e. after the appeal pro­cee­dings. The court did not allow the cor­rec­tion to be made. The dead­line had pas­sed, and the cla­im was the­r­e­fo­re defi­ni­tively lost.

A fur­ther inte­rest char­ge of 5.20 euros had been clai­med in the state­ment of defence for the wrong month. Here, too, the state­ment of cla­im was of no avail.

Criticism of the network assumption

The court its­elf accept­ed L‑Bank’s prac­ti­ce of auto­ma­ti­cal­ly infer­ring the exis­tence of a group of com­pa­nies from fami­ly ties bet­ween the land­lord and a share­hol­der in a limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny. This arran­ge­ment is legal­ly open to chall­enge. In a jud­ge­ment of 27 Febru­ary 2014 (Case C‑110/13), the Euro­pean Court of Jus­ti­ce cla­ri­fied that joint action requi­res actu­al coor­di­na­ti­on and can­not be infer­red sole­ly from fami­ly relationships.

The sepa­ra­ti­on of busi­ness assets and pro­per­ty is a com­mon and legal­ly reco­g­nis­ed arran­ge­ment in Ger­ma­ny. In prin­ci­ple, it has not­hing to do with the ques­ti­on of whe­ther COVID-19-rela­ted los­ses of tur­no­ver are eli­gi­ble for sup­port. Anyo­ne facing the rem­oval of their group sta­tus should check whe­ther the landlord’s buil­ding expen­ses can, as an alter­na­ti­ve, be trea­ted as fixed cos­ts in accordance with the Sup­ple­men­ta­ry Gui­de­lines issued by the Fede­ral Minis­try for Eco­no­mic Affairs on 19 July 2024.

What does that mean in practice?

The fol­lo­wing appli­es to all ongo­ing appeal pro­cee­dings con­cer­ning final COVID-19 sett­le­ment state­ments: the grounds for the appeal must be com­ple­te. Any fixed-cost items yet to be clai­med, any incor­rect allo­ca­ti­ons and any sub­stan­ti­ve cor­rec­tions must be spe­ci­fied the­re at the latest. It is stron­gly recom­men­ded that you seek legal or tax advice throug­hout the appeal pro­cess, as the sources of error lie in the details and the finan­cial impli­ca­ti­ons can be significant.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this