In June 2025, an asylum case officer at the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees (BAMF) hung a so-called ‘Pride Month’ flag in his office. The ‘Pride Month’ flag is a stylised version of the German flag, used as a counter-symbol to the rainbow flag of Pride Month. According to the 2024 Report on the Protection of the Constitution, the campaign behind it is largely driven by right-wing and far-right groups. The state of Hesse subsequently dismissed the employee in accordance with standard procedure. However, the Giessen Labour Court declared the dismissal invalid.
Why hanging it up constituted a breach of duty
The office served not only as a workplace but also as a hearing room for asylum proceedings. Asylum seekers, interpreters and legal advisers were regularly present there. The court ruled that displaying the flag constituted a serious breach of ancillary obligations under the employment contract. Public sector employees, particularly those in a sovereign capacity such as asylum decision-making, are subject to the state’s requirement of neutrality. A particularly sensitive issue is that some asylum seekers are persecuted on the grounds of their sexual identity and might interpret the flag as a sign that they will not receive a fair hearing.
Why the dismissal failed all the same
The key factor was the principle of proportionality. According to the established case law of the Federal Labour Court, dismissal on grounds of conduct requires that there be a negative prognosis for the future – in other words, that the employee is likely to repeat their misconduct. This is precisely what the Giessen Labour Court ruled against.
The employee had removed the flag immediately upon being expressly asked to do so, without objection. He expressly distanced himself from far-right and anti-LGBTQ+ views and, on his own initiative, signed up for anti-discrimination training, which his employer, however, refused to allow him to attend. The court regarded this as a clear sign of remorse and a willingness to cooperate.
The behaviour of the line managers had an impact
The court also did not fail to assess the conduct of the authority itself. Although the team leader noticed the flag, she did not expressly demand that it be taken down. The head of department was aware of this and initially took no action either. It was only a senior civil servant who arranged for it to be removed. Around six and a half weeks elapsed between the incident and the suspension. The court found that anyone who, in the face of an allegedly so serious breach of duty, stands by idly for weeks on end and allows the employee to continue processing asylum applications cannot subsequently credibly claim that the relationship of trust has been irreparably destroyed.
No evidence of anti-constitutional views
The court was also not convinced by the state’s argument that the employee did not adhere to the free and democratic basic order. The Pride Month flag is not a prohibited symbol. The employee had not previously attracted attention for making anti-constitutional remarks, and his reports had passed internal quality assurance checks without any objections.
What the ruling means for employers
The judgement highlights a point that is often underestimated in practice: even in the case of serious breaches of duty, a written warning must, as a general rule, be issued before dismissal can take place. Exceptions apply only if a repeat offence is to be expected despite the written warning, or if the breach of duty is so serious that continuing the employment relationship is clearly unreasonable. In the court’s view, neither of these circumstances applied in this case.
Employers should also bear in mind that their own hesitation following an incident may be interpreted as a counter-argument if they later wish to base a dismissal on the seriousness of that same breach of duty. Anyone wishing to act in a legally sound manner in comparable situations should seek advice on employment law at an early stage.
Giessen Labour Court, judgement of 22 April 2026, Case No. 6 Ca 220/25
Source: Haufe: Law
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.