When a jobcentre or another social security provider takes legal action to claim child benefit on behalf of a person entitled to benefits, a practical question arises: which tax court has territorial jurisdiction? The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) has addressed this issue in a recent ruling and closed an important loophole in procedural law.
What was the case about?
A mother who is a third-country national – let us call her M – lives in Saxony and has been receiving benefits under SGB II since November 2016 from a job centre based in another town. The competent family benefits office, ZKGS, rejected an application for child benefit with effect from January 2021. The job centre, which is authorised to assert the entitlement on behalf of the child benefit recipient in its own name pursuant to Section 5(2) of SGB II, brought an action before the Saxon Finance Court.
The latter considered that it lacked jurisdiction and referred the case to the Tax Court of Saxony-Anhalt, in whose jurisdiction the ZKGS Family Benefits Office is based. The Saxony-Anhalt Finance Court, in turn, declared that it lacked jurisdiction. As two courts simultaneously considered themselves to lack jurisdiction, the Saxony-Anhalt Finance Court referred the matter to the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) to determine which court had jurisdiction.
What do the legal provisions say?
In matters relating to child benefit, the following generally applies: the tax court with jurisdiction is that within whose district the claimant has their domicile or habitual residence (Section 38(2a), first sentence, of the Tax Court Rules (FGO)). According to its wording, this rule applies to natural persons. However, as a public authority, a Jobcentre does not have a place of residence but rather an official registered office. The provision therefore does not apply directly.
The Federal Fiscal Court closes the legal loophole by analogy
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) found that there is a so-called unintended legislative gap in this case. When drafting the rule on jurisdiction, the legislature had in mind exclusively the typical scenario in which a natural person brings a claim themselves. It simply did not take into account the atypical scenario in which a social security provider asserts the claim in its own name on behalf of the person entitled to child benefit.
The solution is as follows: Section 38(2a), first sentence, of the Fiscal Court Act (FGO) is to be applied mutatis mutandis. This means that local jurisdiction is determined by the place of residence of the person whose entitlement to child benefit is in dispute; in M’s case, therefore, by their place of residence in Saxony. From the Federal Fiscal Court’s (BFH) perspective, there were several reasons in favour of this:
- The person entitled to child benefit must be joined to the proceedings as a necessary third party and therefore has her own procedural rights, including the right to attend the oral hearing.
- A court close to where the parties live is in their best interests.
- Organisational restructuring of the family benefits offices – such as the centralisation of certain procedures at the ZKGS for the whole of Germany – should not result in a single tax court being overwhelmed with cases from across the country.
- The risk of conflicting decisions is reduced when a court rules on both the claim brought by the entitled party and the claim brought by the jobcentre.
Result: Binding effect despite errors
Although the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) considered the Saxon Fiscal Court’s referral to the Saxony-Anhalt Fiscal Court to be flawed, the binding effect of that referral order remained in force. This is because a referral order is, in principle, binding on the receiving court unless it is manifestly arbitrary. That was not the case here. Consequently, the Saxony-Anhalt Finance Court has jurisdiction.
For clients who receive social security benefits and whose child benefit claims are being pursued in court by the Jobcentre, this ruling provides clearer guidance for the future: the court in their place of residence has jurisdiction. In case of doubt, it is advisable to seek legal or tax advice at an early stage.
Federal Fiscal Court (BFH), ruling of 17 July 2026, case number III S 15/26
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.