Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

BFH: Which tax court has jurisdiction when a jobcentre takes legal action to claim child benefit?

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) has cla­ri­fied that, in cases whe­re a job­cent­re brings a cla­im rela­ting to child bene­fit, the tax court at the beneficiary’s place of resi­dence has jurisdiction. 
BFH: Which tax court has jurisdiction when a jobcentre takes legal action to claim child benefit?

BFH: Which tax court has jurisdiction when a jobcentre takes legal action to claim child benefit?

When a job­cent­re or ano­ther social secu­ri­ty pro­vi­der takes legal action to cla­im child bene­fit on behalf of a per­son entit­led to bene­fits, a prac­ti­cal ques­ti­on ari­ses: which tax court has ter­ri­to­ri­al juris­dic­tion? The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) has addres­sed this issue in a recent ruling and clo­sed an important loopho­le in pro­ce­du­ral law.

What was the case about?

A mother who is a third-coun­try natio­nal – let us call her M – lives in Sax­o­ny and has been recei­ving bene­fits under SGB II sin­ce Novem­ber 2016 from a job cent­re based in ano­ther town. The com­pe­tent fami­ly bene­fits office, ZKGS, rejec­ted an appli­ca­ti­on for child bene­fit with effect from Janu­ary 2021. The job cent­re, which is aut­ho­ri­sed to assert the entit­le­ment on behalf of the child bene­fit reci­pi­ent in its own name pur­su­ant to Sec­tion 5(2) of SGB II, brought an action befo­re the Saxon Finan­ce Court.

The lat­ter con­side­red that it lacked juris­dic­tion and refer­red the case to the Tax Court of Sax­o­ny-Anhalt, in who­se juris­dic­tion the ZKGS Fami­ly Bene­fits Office is based. The Sax­o­ny-Anhalt Finan­ce Court, in turn, declared that it lacked juris­dic­tion. As two courts simul­ta­neous­ly con­side­red them­sel­ves to lack juris­dic­tion, the Sax­o­ny-Anhalt Finan­ce Court refer­red the mat­ter to the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) to deter­mi­ne which court had jurisdiction.

What do the legal provisions say?

In mat­ters rela­ting to child bene­fit, the fol­lo­wing gene­ral­ly appli­es: the tax court with juris­dic­tion is that within who­se dis­trict the clai­mant has their domic­i­le or habi­tu­al resi­dence (Sec­tion 38(2a), first sen­tence, of the Tax Court Rules (FGO)). Accor­ding to its wor­ding, this rule appli­es to natu­ral per­sons. Howe­ver, as a public aut­ho­ri­ty, a Job­cent­re does not have a place of resi­dence but rather an offi­ci­al regis­tered office. The pro­vi­si­on the­r­e­fo­re does not app­ly directly.

The Federal Fiscal Court closes the legal loophole by analogy

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) found that the­re is a so-cal­led unin­ten­ded legis­la­ti­ve gap in this case. When draf­ting the rule on juris­dic­tion, the legis­la­tu­re had in mind exclu­si­ve­ly the typi­cal sce­na­rio in which a natu­ral per­son brings a cla­im them­sel­ves. It sim­ply did not take into account the aty­pi­cal sce­na­rio in which a social secu­ri­ty pro­vi­der asserts the cla­im in its own name on behalf of the per­son entit­led to child benefit.

The solu­ti­on is as fol­lows: Sec­tion 38(2a), first sen­tence, of the Fis­cal Court Act (FGO) is to be appli­ed muta­tis mut­an­dis. This means that local juris­dic­tion is deter­mi­ned by the place of resi­dence of the per­son who­se entit­le­ment to child bene­fit is in dis­pu­te; in M’s case, the­r­e­fo­re, by their place of resi­dence in Sax­o­ny. From the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court’s (BFH) per­spec­ti­ve, the­re were seve­ral reasons in favour of this:

  • The per­son entit­led to child bene­fit must be joi­n­ed to the pro­cee­dings as a neces­sa­ry third par­ty and the­r­e­fo­re has her own pro­ce­du­ral rights, inclu­ding the right to attend the oral hearing.
  • A court clo­se to whe­re the par­ties live is in their best interests.
  • Orga­ni­sa­tio­nal res­truc­tu­ring of the fami­ly bene­fits offices – such as the cen­tra­li­sa­ti­on of cer­tain pro­ce­du­res at the ZKGS for the who­le of Ger­ma­ny – should not result in a sin­gle tax court being over­whel­med with cases from across the country.
  • The risk of con­flic­ting decis­i­ons is redu­ced when a court rules on both the cla­im brought by the entit­led par­ty and the cla­im brought by the jobcentre.

Result: Binding effect despite errors

Alt­hough the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) con­side­red the Saxon Fis­cal Court’s refer­ral to the Sax­o­ny-Anhalt Fis­cal Court to be fla­wed, the bin­ding effect of that refer­ral order remain­ed in force. This is becau­se a refer­ral order is, in prin­ci­ple, bin­ding on the recei­ving court unless it is mani­fest­ly arbi­tra­ry. That was not the case here. Con­se­quent­ly, the Sax­o­ny-Anhalt Finan­ce Court has jurisdiction.

For cli­ents who recei­ve social secu­ri­ty bene­fits and who­se child bene­fit claims are being pur­sued in court by the Job­cent­re, this ruling pro­vi­des clea­rer gui­dance for the future: the court in their place of resi­dence has juris­dic­tion. In case of doubt, it is advi­sa­ble to seek legal or tax advice at an ear­ly stage.

Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH), ruling of 17 July 2026, case num­ber III S 15/26

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this