If, following the death of the taxpayer, an heir claims that a tax assessment notice was never received by the taxpayer, the mere fact that the notice cannot be found amongst the estate’s assets is not sufficient to rebut the statutory presumption of receipt. The Federal Fiscal Court has clarified this in a recent judgement, thereby overturning a contrary decision by the Münster Fiscal Court.
What had happened?
In 2016, a woman granted a tax consultancy firm a comprehensive power of attorney, which expressly included the authority to receive tax assessment notices. However, the woman’s home address was entered as the delivery address on the cover sheet of the tax return that was submitted. The tax office sent the income tax assessment for 2016 to this address in October 2017.
When the woman died in February 2020, her daughter, as her heir, took over the estate. Whilst clearing out the flat, she found organised tax documents, but no tax assessment notice for the year 2016. The daughter subsequently lodged an appeal against the tax assessment, disputing that her mother had ever received it. The tax office dismissed the appeal as inadmissible because the time limit for lodging an appeal had long since expired.
What does the presumption of disclosure mean?
Under Section 122(2)(1) of the Tax Code, a tax assessment notice sent by post is deemed to have been received on the third day after it was posted. This legal presumption may be rebutted, but this requires specific evidence that casts doubt on the actual delivery process itself.
The following applies: if the addressee themselves denies receipt, this is generally sufficient to give rise to doubt. After all, they are expressing their own perception based on their personal experience. The situation is different if a third party or an heir denies receipt. Anyone who has never been the recipient themselves cannot comment on the question of receipt based on their own knowledge.
The Federal Fiscal Court’s ruling
The Federal Fiscal Court quashed the judgment of the Münster Fiscal Court, which had upheld the claim. The Münster Fiscal Court had held that the tidiness of the deceased’s home and the absence of a notification letter indicated that the notice had not been received. This assessment did not convince the Federal Fiscal Court.
The mere absence of a document does not indicate whether it ever arrived. It may have been destroyed, filed elsewhere or simply misplaced. Furthermore, the estate also contained a notice for the year 2018 that had only been sent after the woman’s death. This showed that other people had evidently also had access to the documents. It could not, therefore, be said that the estate was organised in a truly comprehensive manner.
Furthermore, although the tax consultancy firm had been granted power of attorney to receive correspondence, it had itself stated the taxpayer’s home address as the delivery address on the tax return form. This effectively overrode the power of attorney arrangement in this case, and the notification sent directly to the taxpayer was lawful.
What does this mean for heirs and taxpayers?
The judgement shows that heirs do not enjoy a privileged position in tax matters when it comes to the question of whether a notice has been validly served. Anyone wishing to challenge the service of the notice as a legal successor must provide specific facts that allow conclusions to be drawn about the actual service process. The mere absence of a document is not sufficient for this purpose.
In practice, the following applies: any heir who discovers that deadlines have passed or that decisions are missing should seek expert advice at an early stage. The options for lodging an appeal retrospectively or applying for reinstatement to the previous status are very limited.
Federal Fiscal Court (BFH), judgement of 11 June 2026, case number VI R 16/24
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.