Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

An heir cannot refute the validity of a tax assessment notice solely on the grounds that it could not be found

An heir cannot refute the validity of a tax assessment notice solely on the grounds that it could not be found

If, fol­lo­wing the death of the tax­pay­er, an heir claims that a tax assess­ment noti­ce was never recei­ved by the tax­pay­er, the mere fact that the noti­ce can­not be found among­st the estate’s assets is not suf­fi­ci­ent to rebut the sta­tu­to­ry pre­sump­ti­on of receipt. The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has cla­ri­fied this in a recent jud­ge­ment, ther­eby over­tur­ning a con­tra­ry decis­i­on by the Müns­ter Fis­cal Court.

What had happened?

In 2016, a woman gran­ted a tax con­sul­tancy firm a com­pre­hen­si­ve power of att­or­ney, which express­ly included the aut­ho­ri­ty to recei­ve tax assess­ment noti­ces. Howe­ver, the woman’s home address was ente­red as the deli­very address on the cover sheet of the tax return that was sub­mit­ted. The tax office sent the inco­me tax assess­ment for 2016 to this address in Octo­ber 2017.

When the woman died in Febru­ary 2020, her daugh­ter, as her heir, took over the estate. Whilst clea­ring out the flat, she found orga­nis­ed tax docu­ments, but no tax assess­ment noti­ce for the year 2016. The daugh­ter sub­se­quent­ly lodged an appeal against the tax assess­ment, dis­pu­ting that her mother had ever recei­ved it. The tax office dis­missed the appeal as inad­mis­si­ble becau­se the time limit for lodging an appeal had long sin­ce expired.

What does the presumption of disclosure mean?

Under Sec­tion 122(2)(1) of the Tax Code, a tax assess­ment noti­ce sent by post is dee­med to have been recei­ved on the third day after it was pos­ted. This legal pre­sump­ti­on may be rebut­ted, but this requi­res spe­ci­fic evi­dence that casts doubt on the actu­al deli­very pro­cess itself.

The fol­lo­wing appli­es: if the addres­see them­sel­ves denies receipt, this is gene­ral­ly suf­fi­ci­ent to give rise to doubt. After all, they are expres­sing their own per­cep­ti­on based on their per­so­nal expe­ri­ence. The situa­ti­on is dif­fe­rent if a third par­ty or an heir denies receipt. Anyo­ne who has never been the reci­pi­ent them­sel­ves can­not com­ment on the ques­ti­on of receipt based on their own knowledge.

The Federal Fiscal Court’s ruling

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court quas­hed the judgment of the Müns­ter Fis­cal Court, which had upheld the cla­im. The Müns­ter Fis­cal Court had held that the tidi­ness of the deceased’s home and the absence of a noti­fi­ca­ti­on let­ter indi­ca­ted that the noti­ce had not been recei­ved. This assess­ment did not con­vin­ce the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court.

The mere absence of a docu­ment does not indi­ca­te whe­ther it ever arri­ved. It may have been des­troy­ed, filed else­whe­re or sim­ply mis­pla­ced. Fur­ther­mo­re, the estate also con­tai­ned a noti­ce for the year 2018 that had only been sent after the woman’s death. This show­ed that other peo­p­le had evi­dent­ly also had access to the docu­ments. It could not, the­r­e­fo­re, be said that the estate was orga­nis­ed in a tru­ly com­pre­hen­si­ve manner.

Fur­ther­mo­re, alt­hough the tax con­sul­tancy firm had been gran­ted power of att­or­ney to recei­ve cor­re­spon­dence, it had its­elf sta­ted the taxpayer’s home address as the deli­very address on the tax return form. This effec­tively over­ro­de the power of att­or­ney arran­ge­ment in this case, and the noti­fi­ca­ti­on sent direct­ly to the tax­pay­er was lawful.

What does this mean for heirs and taxpayers?

The jud­ge­ment shows that heirs do not enjoy a pri­vi­le­ged posi­ti­on in tax mat­ters when it comes to the ques­ti­on of whe­ther a noti­ce has been valid­ly ser­ved. Anyo­ne wis­hing to chall­enge the ser­vice of the noti­ce as a legal suc­ces­sor must pro­vi­de spe­ci­fic facts that allow con­clu­si­ons to be drawn about the actu­al ser­vice pro­cess. The mere absence of a docu­ment is not suf­fi­ci­ent for this purpose.

In prac­ti­ce, the fol­lo­wing appli­es: any heir who dis­co­vers that dead­lines have pas­sed or that decis­i­ons are miss­ing should seek expert advice at an ear­ly stage. The opti­ons for lodging an appeal retro­s­pec­tively or app­ly­ing for rein­state­ment to the pre­vious sta­tus are very limited.

Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH), jud­ge­ment of 11 June 2026, case num­ber VI R 16/24

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this