A DHL employee publicly criticised his employer for transporting arms on behalf of Rheinmetall. The company’s response was to dismiss him without notice for an alleged breach of trade secrets. However, the Leipzig Labour Court ruled that the dismissal was unlawful. The client relationship had long been public knowledge; the employee had not made any false claims and was therefore rightfully entitled to keep his job.
This case illustrates just how complex the issue of freedom of expression is in the context of employment, for both parties.
Fundamental protection under the Basic Law
Article 5 of the Basic Law protects freedom of expression. This protection also applies in the context of employment. The Federal Labour Court clarified as early as 2005 that employees are, in principle, free to express their opinions, regardless of whether the statement is rational or emotional (BAG, judgement of 24 November 2005, ref. 2 AZR 584/04). Incidentally, employers also benefit from this protection: not every critical remark made by a manager to staff automatically constitutes an infringement of personal rights or workplace bullying.
Where do employees’ rights end?
Freedom of expression is not a free pass for every kind of statement. There are clear limits:
- False statements of factare excluded from the scope of freedom of expression from the outset.
- Insults, abusive criticism and formal insultstowards superiors or colleagues are not protected under Article 5 of the Basic Law.
- Public criticism, which damages the company’s reputation or spreads rumours about the employer’s solvency, may have consequences under employment law.
- Comments on social mediaare considered public, even if only a limited group of people can see the posts. There is always a risk of uncontrolled dissemination.
Internal criticism versus public statements
Whether an expression of opinion is permissible depends, amongst other things, on whether it is made internally or publicly. Objective criticism within the workplace is generally permitted. Anyone who exposes malpractice of public interest may, under certain circumstances, also invoke the Whistleblowing Protection Act. Companies with 50 or more employees are obliged to set up an internal reporting channel for such reports.
Specific features in certain areas
Public sector employees are subject to specific duties of loyalty, depending on their role and responsibilities. However, in 2009, the Federal Labour Court (BAG) ruled that public-sector employees who do not perform sovereign functions are, in principle, subject to the same standards as employees in the private sector (BAG, judgement of 10 September 2009, ref. 2 AZR 257/08).
In so-called ‘ideologically oriented organisations’ – such as trade unions, churches or political institutions – stricter requirements apply. Anyone working in such organisations must also take care, even outside working hours, not to act in a manner that contravenes the organisation’s fundamental principles (Federal Labour Court, judgement of 23 October 2008, ref. 2 AZR 483/07).
In addition, works council members are subject to a statutory prohibition on party political activity under Section 75(2), third sentence, of the Works Constitution Act (BetrVG) where there is a specific link to a political party.
What does this mean in practice?
Employers may respond to inappropriate comments by issuing a written warning or, in serious cases, by dismissing the employee. However, it is always essential to carefully weigh up the circumstances of each individual case. Any employee who is unsure whether a planned statement might have consequences under employment law, or any employer wishing to respond to an expression of opinion, should seek legal advice before taking any hasty action.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.