Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Tie-breaking clause makes GmbH managing directors employees

Tie-breaking clause makes GmbH managing directors employees

A 50 per cent share­hol­ding is often regard­ed as a gua­ran­tee of entre­pre­neu­ri­al inde­pen­dence. Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Social Court has cla­ri­fied in a recent jud­ge­ment that this assump­ti­on can be mis­lea­ding. What mat­ters is not the size of the share­hol­ding, but the actu­al legal power to pre­vent unwan­ted decisions.

What had happened?

Two mana­ging direc­tors, who were also share­hol­ders, each held 50 per cent of the shares in a limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH). The artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on included a so-cal­led cas­ting vote clau­se: in the event of a tied vote, a neu­tral third par­ty was to make the decis­i­on. The pen­si­on insu­rance aut­ho­ri­ty inves­ti­ga­ted the cir­cum­s­tances and clas­si­fied both mana­ging direc­tors as employees. This resul­ted in a back pay­ment cla­im of around 127,000 euros. The GmbH chal­len­ged this decis­i­on, arguing that their 50 per cent share­hol­ding con­sti­tu­ted self-employ­ment. Fur­ther­mo­re, they con­ten­ded that the clau­se was inva­lid in any case.

The court does not consider that there is sufficient legal authority

The Fede­ral Social Court dis­missed the cla­im and upheld the decis­i­on of the Lower Sax­o­ny-Bre­men Regio­nal Social Court. The court’s key fin­ding was that, whilst a share­hol­der hol­ding 50 per cent of the shares can, in prin­ci­ple, block any reso­lu­ti­on requi­ring a simp­le majo­ri­ty, Howe­ver, if the­re is a cas­ting vote clau­se which allows a third par­ty to deci­de in the event of a dead­lock, this very abili­ty to block decis­i­ons is absent. Neither mana­ging direc­tor could relia­bly pre­vent decis­i­ons being taken against their will.

The Fede­ral Social Court (BSG) also empha­sis­ed that, for the pur­po­ses of assess­ment under social secu­ri­ty law, fore­seea­bi­li­ty is requi­red. The legal aut­ho­ri­ty must be cle­ar­ly reco­g­nisable and relia­ble. If, on the other hand, it depends on the out­co­me of legal pro­cee­dings or a sub­se­quent chall­enge, this is not suf­fi­ci­ent. Accor­ding to the court, a chall­enge pre­sup­po­ses that a decis­i­on has first been taken. It does not pre­vent such a decis­i­on from being taken.

The validity of the clause is not in question

The BSG did not accept the GmbH’s argu­ment that the cas­ting vote clau­se was inva­lid. The­re was no doubt as to the vali­di­ty of the pro­vi­si­on. And even if the clau­se had never actual­ly been appli­ed, this would make no dif­fe­rence: its mere exis­tence in the artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on is suf­fi­ci­ent to rule out the right to veto.

What does this mean in practice?

This ruling has signi­fi­cant prac­ti­cal impli­ca­ti­ons for share­hol­der-mana­ging direc­tors and their limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­nies (GmbHs). Many artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on con­tain simi­lar pro­vi­si­ons for resol­ving con­flicts in the event of a tie, wit­hout the par­ties invol­ved being awa­re of the con­se­quen­ces under social secu­ri­ty law.

  • A 50 per cent share­hol­ding does not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly pre­clude the employ­ment from being clas­si­fied as depen­dent employment.
  • Tie-brea­king clau­ses may mean that you are requi­red to pay social secu­ri­ty con­tri­bu­ti­ons even though you are a co-shareholder.
  • Addi­tio­nal con­tri­bu­ti­ons may amount to sub­stan­ti­al sums and may be clai­med retrospectively.
  • Artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on should be review­ed for such clau­ses befo­re a tax audit takes place.

Anyo­ne acting as a mana­ging direc­tor who is also a share­hol­der, or run­ning a limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny (GmbH) with seve­ral share­hol­ders, should have the artic­les of asso­cia­ti­on and their social secu­ri­ty sta­tus careful­ly review­ed. If in doubt, it is advi­sa­ble to seek legal advice.

Fede­ral Social Court (BSG), judgment of 23 July 2026, Case No. B 12 BA 10/24 R

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this