The landlord rings the doorbell and wants to view his flat. But it’s not quite that simple. Tenants have the right to control access to the premises they are renting, and this protects them from unannounced or unjustified visits. The circumstances in which landlords may nevertheless demand access, and what needs to be taken into account in such cases, are primarily governed by case law.
No entry without a valid reason
The legal basis for a landlord’s right of inspection is set out in Section 809 of the German Civil Code (BGB). According to this provision, the landlord may demand access if he has a specific claim relating to the let property or wishes to ascertain whether he is entitled to such a claim. Furthermore, Article 13 of the Basic Law protects the inviolability of the home, which sets strict limits on contractual access clauses.
If the landlord enters the flat without the tenants’ consent – for example, whilst they are away, using a spare key – they are guilty of trespass under Section 123 of the German Criminal Code (StGB). This offence is punishable by a fine or up to one year’s imprisonment.
When a right of inspection applies
Valid reasons for viewing a flat include, amongst others:
- Planned sale of the flat, with viewings by prospective buyers
- Upcoming modernisation or maintenance work
- Notification of defects by the tenant and assessment of the damage
- Reasonable suspicion of use in breach of contract
- Reading measurements from measuring equipment
- Inspection of cosmetic repairs following a tenant’s departure
- Calculation for a rent increase
In a judgement dated 26 April 2023 (BGH, VIII ZR 420/21), the Federal Court of Justice confirmed that the tenant has a secondary contractual obligation to grant access where there is a specific, objective reason for doing so. In doing so, a fair balance must be struck between the conflicting interests of both parties.
Notification and deadlines
Landlords must give reasonable notice of a viewing. There is no statutory minimum notice period. In practice, for appointments that can be planned in advance, approximately two weeks’ notice is considered reasonable. The viewing should take place on a working day at a reasonable time of day; weekdays up to 7 pm are generally accepted. Saturdays count as working days. Where possible, several viewings should be scheduled together to minimise the inconvenience to the tenant.
In the event of imminent danger, such as a burst water pipe, the obligation to give notice does not apply.
No right to carry out routine inspections without cause
The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has expressly ruled out a right to periodic inspection without a specific reason. Although the Munich Local Court did permit an inspection after more than five years in one specific case (Munich Local Court, judgement of 8 January 2016, 461 C 19626/15), this issue has not yet been conclusively decided by the highest court.
What tenants can do
Tenants are entitled to refuse a viewing if the landlord turns up without notice and without a valid reason, if the viewing is scheduled at an unreasonable time, or if viewings take place with unreasonable frequency, such as several times a week. Where there is a valid reason, however, tenants must cooperate in arranging a viewing and must not permanently refuse access.
Disputes over the right to view a property affect both landlords and tenants. Anyone who is unsure how to proceed in specific situations should seek legal advice.
Source: Haufe: Property
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.