A recent ruling by the European Court of Justice is causing a stir in the world of taxation. However, the German Government has made it clear that, for the time being, the ruling has no impact on German land transfer tax.
What did the ECJ rule?
In its judgment of 4 June 2026 (Case C‑837/24), the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled that the Portuguese land transfer tax in a so-called ‘share deal’ was contrary to European law. In the specific case, a company was formed through contributions in kind, which included, amongst other things, property. The Portuguese tax authorities subsequently levied property transfer tax on this. The ECJ regarded this as a breach of the European Capital Accumulation Directive (Directive 2008/7/EC). This Directive prohibits EU Member States from levying indirect taxes on capital contributions or restructuring operations involving limited companies.
Why isn’t Germany scoring (yet)?
In its response to a minor parliamentary question in the Bundestag (Bundestag printed paper dated 12 August 2026, 21/7608), the Federal Government emphasised that the judgement has no direct implications for German property acquisition tax law. The key point is that the Portuguese tax differs structurally from the German one.
Furthermore, in a decision not to accept the case dated 25 June 2026, the Federal Constitutional Court reaffirmed the Federal Fiscal Court’s previous position. The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) had previously always refused to refer the question of the compatibility of German land transfer tax law with EU law to the European Court of Justice (ECJ), and sees no incompatibility. The Federal Constitutional Court (BVerfG) has now confirmed that this approach is in accordance with the Constitution.
Questions remain unanswered
Despite the current lull, the Federal Ministry of Finance is closely monitoring developments in case law. Two cases could reignite the debate in the future:
- A case concerning taxation under Section 1(3)(4) of the Real Estate Transfer Tax Act is pending before the Federal Fiscal Court (Ref. II R 8/23). Once again, the case centres on the question of whether the Capital Accumulation Directive is applicable to certain situations under German real estate transfer tax law.
- A constitutional complaint is also pending before the Federal Constitutional Court against the Federal Fiscal Court’s judgement of 25 September 2024 (Ref. II R 36/21, BVerfG Ref. 1 BvR 574/25). Here, too, the long-term compliance of Section 1(3) of the Real Estate Transfer Tax Act with EU law is under scrutiny.
What does this mean for businesses and investors?
For companies that acquire or transfer property via company shares – that is, through so-called share deals – German property transfer tax law remains applicable as at present. Current case law confirms existing practice. At the same time, the landscape of pending legal proceedings indicates that the fundamental issue has not yet been definitively resolved.
Anyone planning share deals or involved in restructuring processes in which property plays a role should keep an eye on future developments. It is advisable to seek tax advice on a case-by-case basis in order to identify potential risks at an early stage.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.