Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Property transfers as part of a divorce settlement: a tax pitfall for married couples

Property transfers as part of a divorce settlement: a tax pitfall for married couples

Anyo­ne who gets divorced and, as part of the sepa­ra­ti­on, trans­fers pro­per­ty to their ex-part­ner may be fal­ling into a tax trap. In its jud­ge­ment of 18 June 2026, the Müns­ter Finan­ce Court ruled that such a trans­fer may be taxa­ble as a pri­va­te dis­po­sal tran­sac­tion under sec­tion 23(1)(1) of the Inco­me Tax Act (EStG) (Case No. 8 K 901/23 E).

What had happened?

A mar­ried cou­ple had joint­ly purcha­sed a block of flats and two flats, each owning a 50 per cent share. Fol­lo­wing their sepa­ra­ti­on, both par­ties rea­ched a sett­le­ment befo­re a fami­ly court judge in July 2018. Under the terms of the sett­le­ment, the hus­band trans­fer­red his co-owner­ship shares in all three pro­per­ties to his wife. In return, both par­ties mutual­ly wai­ved any claims to equa­li­sa­ti­on of accrued gains, pen­si­on rights equa­li­sa­ti­on and main­ten­an­ce. The divorce beca­me final in Octo­ber 2018, and the nota­ri­sed trans­fer of the pro­per­ties took place in Decem­ber 2018.

Initi­al­ly, the clai­mant had declared the trans­fer hims­elf as a pri­va­te sale in his tax return. Fol­lo­wing an exter­nal tax audit, which reve­a­led signi­fi­cant­ly hig­her pro­fits, he chan­ged his legal posi­ti­on. He argued that, at the time of the sett­le­ment, no cla­im for equa­li­sa­ti­on of accrued gains had yet ari­sen, as the divorce had not yet beco­me final. Wit­hout such a mone­ta­ry cla­im, the trans­fer of the pro­per­ty could not con­sti­tu­te con­side­ra­ti­on in return for payment.

The court took a different view

The Müns­ter Finan­ce Court did not accept this line of argu­ment. In the jud­ges’ view, it is irrele­vant whe­ther the sta­tu­to­ry cla­im for equa­li­sa­ti­on of accrued gains had alre­a­dy for­mal­ly ari­sen. What is decisi­ve is the over­all eco­no­mic con­text of the tran­sac­tion. The wai­ver of future mone­ta­ry claims ari­sing from the divorce con­sti­tu­tes con­side­ra­ti­on and thus makes the trans­fer of the pro­per­ty a tran­sac­tion for valuable consideration.

Fur­ther­mo­re, the court drew a clear distinc­tion bet­ween two dif­fe­rent types of con­tract. A genui­ne Pren­up­ti­al agree­mentUnder Sec­tion 1408 of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB), this appli­es only whe­re the spou­ses, irre­spec­ti­ve of any spe­ci­fic inten­ti­on to divorce, agree on a gene­ral matri­mo­ni­al pro­per­ty regime and replace the sta­tu­to­ry equa­li­sa­ti­on sys­tem with a con­trac­tu­al one. This was not the case here. The sett­le­ment was express­ly con­cluded with a view to the impen­ding divorce and would have beco­me void wit­hout it. It was the­r­e­fo­re a Divorce Sett­le­ment Agree­ment, not a pren­up­ti­al agreement.

When is a transfer tax-free?

The jud­ge­ment makes it clear under what con­di­ti­ons a tax-free trans­fer would have been pos­si­ble. Had the spou­ses agreed, whilst the exis­ting matri­mo­ni­al pro­per­ty regime was still in force, in a genui­ne mar­ria­ge con­tract that a future equa­li­sa­ti­on of accrued gains was to take the form of a trans­fer of a spe­ci­fic plot of land, no tax lia­bi­li­ty would have ari­sen under sec­tion 23 of the Inco­me Tax Act. An agree­ment rea­ched only during the ongo­ing divorce pro­cee­dings is not suf­fi­ci­ent for this pur­po­se, even if it is for­mal­ly con­cluded befo­re the divorce beco­mes final.

Practical implications for those affected

  • Pro­per­ty trans­fers in the cour­se of a divorce can result in sub­stan­ti­al back pay­ments of inco­me tax if the pro­per­ties were acqui­red within the ten-year capi­tal gains tax period.
  • Only a pren­up­ti­al agree­ment con­cluded in good time, con­tai­ning spe­ci­fic pro­vi­si­ons on the trans­fer of assets, can avo­id tax liability.
  • An agree­ment rea­ched befo­re the con­ci­lia­ti­on judge or in divorce pro­cee­dings is not suf­fi­ci­ent for this purpose.

The Müns­ter Fis­cal Court has gran­ted lea­ve to appeal to the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court, mea­ning that a ruling by the hig­hest court is still pen­ding. Anyo­ne fin­ding them­sel­ves in a simi­lar situa­ti­on should seek tax advice at an ear­ly stage, befo­re ente­ring into any agree­ments with their spouse.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this