Anyone who gets divorced and, as part of the separation, transfers property to their ex-partner may be falling into a tax trap. In its judgement of 18 June 2026, the Münster Finance Court ruled that such a transfer may be taxable as a private disposal transaction under section 23(1)(1) of the Income Tax Act (EStG) (Case No. 8 K 901/23 E).
What had happened?
A married couple had jointly purchased a block of flats and two flats, each owning a 50 per cent share. Following their separation, both parties reached a settlement before a family court judge in July 2018. Under the terms of the settlement, the husband transferred his co-ownership shares in all three properties to his wife. In return, both parties mutually waived any claims to equalisation of accrued gains, pension rights equalisation and maintenance. The divorce became final in October 2018, and the notarised transfer of the properties took place in December 2018.
Initially, the claimant had declared the transfer himself as a private sale in his tax return. Following an external tax audit, which revealed significantly higher profits, he changed his legal position. He argued that, at the time of the settlement, no claim for equalisation of accrued gains had yet arisen, as the divorce had not yet become final. Without such a monetary claim, the transfer of the property could not constitute consideration in return for payment.
The court took a different view
The Münster Finance Court did not accept this line of argument. In the judges’ view, it is irrelevant whether the statutory claim for equalisation of accrued gains had already formally arisen. What is decisive is the overall economic context of the transaction. The waiver of future monetary claims arising from the divorce constitutes consideration and thus makes the transfer of the property a transaction for valuable consideration.
Furthermore, the court drew a clear distinction between two different types of contract. A genuine Prenuptial agreementUnder Section 1408 of the German Civil Code (BGB), this applies only where the spouses, irrespective of any specific intention to divorce, agree on a general matrimonial property regime and replace the statutory equalisation system with a contractual one. This was not the case here. The settlement was expressly concluded with a view to the impending divorce and would have become void without it. It was therefore a Divorce Settlement Agreement, not a prenuptial agreement.
When is a transfer tax-free?
The judgement makes it clear under what conditions a tax-free transfer would have been possible. Had the spouses agreed, whilst the existing matrimonial property regime was still in force, in a genuine marriage contract that a future equalisation of accrued gains was to take the form of a transfer of a specific plot of land, no tax liability would have arisen under section 23 of the Income Tax Act. An agreement reached only during the ongoing divorce proceedings is not sufficient for this purpose, even if it is formally concluded before the divorce becomes final.
Practical implications for those affected
- Property transfers in the course of a divorce can result in substantial back payments of income tax if the properties were acquired within the ten-year capital gains tax period.
- Only a prenuptial agreement concluded in good time, containing specific provisions on the transfer of assets, can avoid tax liability.
- An agreement reached before the conciliation judge or in divorce proceedings is not sufficient for this purpose.
The Münster Fiscal Court has granted leave to appeal to the Federal Fiscal Court, meaning that a ruling by the highest court is still pending. Anyone finding themselves in a similar situation should seek tax advice at an early stage, before entering into any agreements with their spouse.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.