Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Reskilling programmes in employment law: When voluntary further training becomes a condition of transfer

Res­kil­ling pro­gram­mes may sound like fur­ther trai­ning, but under employ­ment law they can con­sti­tu­te a trans­fer. What employees and employ­ers need to know. 
Reskilling programmes in employment law: When voluntary further training becomes a condition of transfer

Reskilling programmes in employment law: When voluntary further training becomes a condition of transfer

Arti­fi­ci­al intel­li­gence and auto­ma­ti­on are trans­forming not only the world of work, but also the poten­ti­al for con­flict bet­ween employ­ers and employees. Many com­pa­nies are tur­ning to so-cal­led res­kil­ling pro­gram­mes to retrain staff who­se pre­vious roles are being pha­sed out for new roles. What may appear at first glan­ce to be a fair solu­ti­on har­bours signi­fi­cant pit­falls under employ­ment law.

Upgrading or transfer? A crucial distinction

As long as employees recei­ve trai­ning along­side their exis­ting duties, wit­hout any signi­fi­cant chan­ge to their area of respon­si­bi­li­ty, this is legal­ly clas­si­fied as a skills deve­lo­p­ment pro­gram­me. The situa­ti­on is dif­fe­rent if an employee is assi­gned to a new area of work that lasts for more than one month or invol­ves signi­fi­cant­ly alte­red working con­di­ti­ons. In that case, it con­sti­tu­tes a trans­fer within the mea­ning of the Works Con­sti­tu­ti­on Act, in respect of which the works coun­cil has a right of co-determination.

In prac­ti­ce, res­kil­ling pro­gram­mes almost always invol­ve both aspects simul­ta­neous­ly. On the one hand, new skills are deve­lo­ped, such as tho­se rela­ting to AI or data ana­ly­sis. On the other hand, com­ple­ti­on of the trai­ning is often fol­lo­wed by a move to dif­fe­rent roles or even dif­fe­rent com­pa­nies. Even if the pro­gram­me is offi­ci­al­ly desi­gna­ted as fur­ther trai­ning, it remains sub­ject to co-deter­mi­na­ti­on as soon as it effec­tively acts as a means of redeployment.

Rejection of the scheme and the risk of dismissal on grounds of change

Befo­re making a red­un­dan­cy for ope­ra­tio­nal reasons, the employ­er must assess whe­ther less dra­stic mea­su­res are pos­si­ble, such as reasonable retrai­ning or con­tin­ued employ­ment in ano­ther vacant post. If an employee rejects a pro­per­ly struc­tu­red offer of retrai­ning for the pur­po­ses of pro­fes­sio­nal trans­for­ma­ti­on, a noti­ce of chan­ge of con­tract may be soci­al­ly jus­ti­fied. This is sub­ject to the con­di­ti­on that the pre­vious post has objec­tively cea­sed to exist, the new role is reasonable, and the trai­ning offers rea­li­stic pro­s­pects of suc­cess. Pro­gram­mes that lead to care­er dead ends or invol­ve signi­fi­cant los­ses of inco­me are often ruled unlawful by the courts on the grounds that they are soci­al­ly unjust.

The role of the works council

Under employ­ment law, a res­kil­ling aca­de­my is gene­ral­ly con­side­red to be part of a chan­ge in busi­ness ope­ra­ti­ons, par­ti­cu­lar­ly whe­re a signi­fi­cant num­ber of jobs are lost. This trig­gers the obli­ga­ti­on to nego­tia­te a recon­ci­lia­ti­on of inte­rests and to draw up a social plan. The works coun­cil can enforce important pro­tec­ti­ve pro­vi­si­ons under coll­ec­ti­ve bar­gai­ning law, for example:

  • Prio­ri­ti­sing retrai­ning over redundancy
  • Pro­tec­tion against dis­mis­sal whilst par­ti­ci­pa­ting in the programme
  • Trans­pa­rent sel­ec­tion cri­te­ria for participation
  • Opti­ons for retur­ning to one’s pre­vious field of work

Remuneration and pay grading must not be changed unilaterally

As long as no new employ­ment con­tract has been con­cluded or a noti­ce of amend­ment has been accept­ed, the pre­vious terms and con­di­ti­ons of employ­ment shall con­ti­nue to app­ly. Remu­ne­ra­ti­on may not be redu­ced during the trai­ning pha­se wit­hout mutu­al agree­ment. Trai­ning peri­ods orde­red by the employ­er or requi­red as part of a trans­for­ma­ti­on plan are, in prin­ci­ple, regard­ed as working time. Upon com­ple­ti­on of the pro­gram­me, the new role must be clas­si­fied in accordance with the exis­ting pay sca­le, sub­ject to the works council’s rights of co-determination.

What does this mean for employees and businesses?

Whe­ther a res­kil­ling pro­gram­me is genui­ne­ly vol­un­t­a­ry is not deter­mi­ned by its name, but by whe­ther the­re is a rea­li­stic pos­si­bi­li­ty of remai­ning in one’s cur­rent field of work. If this opti­on is effec­tively unavailable, the sup­po­sedly vol­un­t­a­ry trai­ning beco­mes a forced res­truc­tu­ring with far-rea­ching con­se­quen­ces under employ­ment law. Employees who are unsu­re how to respond to such an offer, as well as com­pa­nies wis­hing to estab­lish a legal­ly sound trans­for­ma­ti­on model, should seek legal advice at an ear­ly stage.

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this