Artificial intelligence and automation are transforming not only the world of work, but also the potential for conflict between employers and employees. Many companies are turning to so-called reskilling programmes to retrain staff whose previous roles are being phased out for new roles. What may appear at first glance to be a fair solution harbours significant pitfalls under employment law.
Upgrading or transfer? A crucial distinction
As long as employees receive training alongside their existing duties, without any significant change to their area of responsibility, this is legally classified as a skills development programme. The situation is different if an employee is assigned to a new area of work that lasts for more than one month or involves significantly altered working conditions. In that case, it constitutes a transfer within the meaning of the Works Constitution Act, in respect of which the works council has a right of co-determination.
In practice, reskilling programmes almost always involve both aspects simultaneously. On the one hand, new skills are developed, such as those relating to AI or data analysis. On the other hand, completion of the training is often followed by a move to different roles or even different companies. Even if the programme is officially designated as further training, it remains subject to co-determination as soon as it effectively acts as a means of redeployment.
Rejection of the scheme and the risk of dismissal on grounds of change
Before making a redundancy for operational reasons, the employer must assess whether less drastic measures are possible, such as reasonable retraining or continued employment in another vacant post. If an employee rejects a properly structured offer of retraining for the purposes of professional transformation, a notice of change of contract may be socially justified. This is subject to the condition that the previous post has objectively ceased to exist, the new role is reasonable, and the training offers realistic prospects of success. Programmes that lead to career dead ends or involve significant losses of income are often ruled unlawful by the courts on the grounds that they are socially unjust.
The role of the works council
Under employment law, a reskilling academy is generally considered to be part of a change in business operations, particularly where a significant number of jobs are lost. This triggers the obligation to negotiate a reconciliation of interests and to draw up a social plan. The works council can enforce important protective provisions under collective bargaining law, for example:
- Prioritising retraining over redundancy
- Protection against dismissal whilst participating in the programme
- Transparent selection criteria for participation
- Options for returning to one’s previous field of work
Remuneration and pay grading must not be changed unilaterally
As long as no new employment contract has been concluded or a notice of amendment has been accepted, the previous terms and conditions of employment shall continue to apply. Remuneration may not be reduced during the training phase without mutual agreement. Training periods ordered by the employer or required as part of a transformation plan are, in principle, regarded as working time. Upon completion of the programme, the new role must be classified in accordance with the existing pay scale, subject to the works council’s rights of co-determination.
What does this mean for employees and businesses?
Whether a reskilling programme is genuinely voluntary is not determined by its name, but by whether there is a realistic possibility of remaining in one’s current field of work. If this option is effectively unavailable, the supposedly voluntary training becomes a forced restructuring with far-reaching consequences under employment law. Employees who are unsure how to respond to such an offer, as well as companies wishing to establish a legally sound transformation model, should seek legal advice at an early stage.
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.