More and more people want to install air conditioning in their flats. But what happens if the owners’ association refuses to give its consent? In a recent ruling, the Federal Court of Justice has clarified that, under certain conditions, owners may have a legal right to such authorisation. The case number is V ZR 162/25; the judgement was handed down on 17 July 2026.
What was the argument about?
A couple who owned a flat in Berlin wanted to install a so-called split air-conditioning unit on their balcony. This would have required drilling a hole through the external façade. The owners’ meeting rejected the application. The owners subsequently brought an action for the replacement of the resolution, that is to say, they sought a court order requiring the rejected resolution to be replaced. The Local Court dismissed the claim, whilst the Regional Court ruled in favour of the owners. The Federal Court of Justice upheld this decision.
The legal classification
Under the Condominium Act, the installation of a split-system air-conditioning unit involving a breach in the façade constitutes a structural alteration to the common property. Such measures generally require a resolution by the owners’ meeting in accordance with Section 20(1) of the Condominium Act.
An individual owner may be entitled to permission for such a modification if the measure does not inconvenience the other owners beyond what is unavoidable in the course of harmonious coexistence. In the case of an air-conditioning unit that has been properly planned and installed, this is generally not the case, in the view of the Federal Court of Justice (BGH). Even a hole in the façade does not automatically lead to a significant disruption if carried out properly.
Potential noise nuisance is not an obstacle
The owners’ association had been particularly concerned about noise. However, the Federal Court of Justice made it clear that the mere fear of noise during operation does not, in principle, preclude a claim for authorisation. Authorisation may only be refused if it is already established that unacceptable noise will be generated. In this specific case, the device was approved for the German market and capable of complying with the requirements of the Technical Instructions on Noise (TA Lärm). Furthermore, the planned installation was several metres away from the nearest bedroom window.
What happens if there is noise after all?
The court emphasised that authorisation for installation and subsequent use are two separate matters. If the operation of the equipment does in fact cause disruptive noise, affected owners may assert defences under the Condominium Act and the Civil Code. In practice, this will usually result in time-limited restrictions on use, rather than a complete shutdown of the system. Furthermore, the owners’ association may incorporate corresponding provisions into the house rules.
What does this mean for flat owners?
Anyone wishing to install air conditioning in their flat should first submit a request to the owners’ meeting. If this is rejected, an action to set aside the resolution may, under certain circumstances, be successful. The decisive factor is whether the planned measure actually causes significant disruption to the other owners. In any event, the owners’ association may no longer reject a request for an air-conditioning system across the board. As each case depends on the specific circumstances, it is advisable to seek legal advice before taking legal action.
Source: Haufe: Law
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.