In its judgement of 16 April 2026, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) ruled that a temporary employment agency may not deduct input VAT from invoices if a flat-rate fee is not, in reality, based on a genuine exchange of services. The case reference is V R 1/25, published on 13 August 2026.
What was the case about?
A temporary employment agency (the claimant) supplied staff to a public limited company (AG) to work in its staff canteens. Under a supplementary agreement to the temporary employment contract, the supplied staff were permitted to use the AG’s canteens on the same preferential terms as the AG’s own employees.
For this canteen access, the client company invoiced the temporary employment agency a flat-rate fee per employee and per day of assignment, shown with VAT itemised separately. Insofar as the temporary employment agency claimed the input VAT on this in its VAT return, this initially seemed logical. What was unusual about this arrangement, however, was that the temporary employment agency immediately charged exactly the same amount back to the AG, included within the total remuneration for the provision of staff.
During several tax audits covering the years 2010 to 2017, the tax office refused to allow input tax deduction. The Tax Court initially upheld the claim. However, the Federal Fiscal Court overturned this judgement and ruled in favour of the tax office.
The Federal Fiscal Court’s reasoning
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) made it clear that an input tax deduction requires that a service has actually been provided. It is not sufficient simply to have an invoice showing VAT. The tax must also actually be legally payable in respect of a service provided.
In this specific case, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) held that there was no genuine exchange of services between the parent company and the temporary employment agency. The reason: when all the contracts were considered from an overall economic perspective, the parent company was intended to bear the canteen costs alone. Although the lump sum was initially charged to the temporary employment agency, it was then immediately re-charged back in the same amount. The temporary employment agency merely acted as an intermediary in the parent company’s internal cost allocation process.
A benefit provided by the claimant to its own employees was also ruled out because the AG granted the discounted canteen facilities directly and independently to the employees on secondment.
Further consequence: incorrect tax statement
As the invoices issued by the public limited company to the temporary employment agency did not correspond to any actual service provided, the same applies, conversely, to the credit note invoices issued by the temporary employment agency to the public limited company. The temporary employment agency showed VAT as payable on these invoices, even though no service had been provided. The consequence is that it is nevertheless liable for this VAT under the provisions governing the unauthorised showing of tax (Section 14c(2) of the Value Added Tax Act), but cannot simultaneously deduct it as input tax.
What does this mean in practice?
The judgement highlights how dangerous contractual arrangements can be where costs are formally passed on but, in economic terms, no genuine flow of services takes place. Particularly in the case of temporary agency work contracts with supplementary agreements, it is worth carrying out a detailed VAT review of the overall structure. Companies that use similar arrangements should have their contracts and the tax treatment carefully reviewed.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.