Anyone applying to the tax office for a binding ruling must pay a fee. But how many fees are payable if a project involves several stages and raises various tax issues? In a recent judgement, the Federal Fiscal Court has laid down important principles on this matter.
What is a binding statement?
A binding ruling under Section 89 of the German Fiscal Code (AO) is an official assurance from the tax office as to how it will assess, for tax purposes, a planned situation that has not yet come to pass. Taxpayers use this mechanism to obtain legal certainty before making major decisions. There is a charge for processing such requests: under Section 89(3), first sentence, of the AO, the tax office levies a fee for each application.
One project, one fee
In its judgement of 25 February 2026 (case number II R 38/23), the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) clarified that the issue of fees does not depend on the number of legal questions raised or the number of types of tax concerned. The decisive factor is whether the request for information is based on a single set of facts.
As an example, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) cites the restructuring of shareholdings, which takes place in several stages and is subsequently to be transferred to family members by way of anticipated succession. Even if this involves income tax, gift tax and other types of tax, and several individual measures are planned, it constitutes a single project. Consequently, only one fee may be charged in total.
No limitation period for the fee
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) has also ruled that fees for binding rulings are not subject to the limitation period for tax assessment. Whilst these are ancillary tax payments, the general limitation rules set out in Sections 169 et seq. of the German Fiscal Code (AO) apply only where the law expressly so provides. This is not the case here. The BFH also rejected an analogous application of the one-year limitation period for enforcement costs under Section 346(2) of the German Fiscal Code (AO), on the grounds that anyone who submits a request for information themselves is aware of the obligation to pay fees and does not require any special protection.
Fee payable even if the application is rejected or withdrawn
Anyone who withdraws their application for a binding ruling, or whose application is rejected by the tax office, must still pay the fee. The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) justifies this on the grounds that even a negative response provides clarity for the applicant: they now know how the tax office assesses their plans for tax purposes and can adjust their planning accordingly. Furthermore, the fee is intended to cover the administrative costs incurred, regardless of the outcome.
What does this mean for clients?
Anyone planning a complex project that involves several types of tax or several consecutive steps does not necessarily have to pay multiple times. If all the measures are economically and factually linked, the entire project is regarded as a single matter. This can significantly reduce the cost of a binding ruling. At the same time, it is important to note that withdrawing the application does not prevent the fee from being charged. When planning to apply for a binding ruling, it is therefore advisable to present the project in a comprehensive and coherent manner from the outset. Tax advisers or solicitors can help to draft the application in such a way as to clearly demonstrate the unified nature of the project.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.