Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Mannheim Labour Court: Not every dispute between colleagues constitutes bullying

Mannheim Labour Court: Not every dispute between colleagues constitutes bullying

Anyo­ne who feels mistrea­ted by a col­le­ague at work is quick to think of bul­ly­ing. Howe­ver, in a recent ruling, the Mann­heim Labour Court has cla­ri­fied whe­re the legal line is drawn and what con­sti­tu­tes mere inter­per­so­nal tensions.

The case: Administrative assistant takes legal action over her colleague’s dismissal

An admi­nis­tra­ti­ve offi­cer in the human resour­ces depart­ment of a uni­ver­si­ty found the working atmo­sphe­re so stressful due to the beha­viour of a col­le­ague that she took sick lea­ve in March 2024. Upon her return in May 2024, she repor­ted ongo­ing health pro­blems and a fee­ling of being excluded from the team. Media­ti­on, sug­gested by her line mana­ger, fai­led becau­se the col­le­ague accu­sed of the beha­viour refu­sed to take part. A work­place inte­gra­ti­on pro­gram­me also fai­led to pro­du­ce a solution.

The employee even­tual­ly took legal action, deman­ding that her employ­er take disci­pli­na­ry action against her col­le­ague – spe­ci­fi­cal­ly, dis­mis­sal, trans­fer or, at the very least, a writ­ten war­ning. She also clai­med com­pen­sa­ti­on under the Gene­ral Equal Tre­at­ment Act (AGG), as she felt she had been dis­cri­mi­na­ted against.

Court finds no evidence of discrimination or bullying

The Mann­heim Labour Court dis­missed the cla­im in its enti­re­ty. The jud­ges empha­sis­ed that con­flicts bet­ween col­le­agues are part of ever­y­day working life and are not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly legal­ly rele­vant. The decisi­ve fac­tor is whe­ther the beha­viour is sys­te­ma­ti­cal­ly aimed at vio­la­ting a person’s digni­ty or at crea­ting a hosti­le working envi­ron­ment through inti­mi­da­ti­on, hosti­li­ty or humiliation.

In this spe­ci­fic case, the court did not con­sider this thres­hold to have been excee­ded. A par­ti­cu­lar­ly tel­ling exam­p­le: the clai­mant regard­ed it as bul­ly­ing that her col­le­ague had not than­ked her for her bir­th­day wis­hes. The jud­ges expres­sed their asto­nish­ment that such an inci­dent should ser­ve as grounds for dis­mis­sal. In this regard, they noted that employees have no right to be lik­ed or view­ed favour­a­b­ly by their col­le­agues. The­re is sim­ply no obli­ga­ti­on for col­le­agues to main­tain a fri­end­ly relationship.

What does this mean in legal terms, specifically?

Accor­ding to case law, work­place bul­ly­ing within the mea­ning of employ­ment law is only dee­med to exist if all of the fol­lo­wing con­di­ti­ons are met:

  • The beha­viour is sys­te­ma­tic and recurrent.
  • It is inten­ded to, or results in, an inf­rin­ge­ment of a person’s dignity.
  • An envi­ron­ment is crea­ted that is cha­rac­te­ri­sed by inti­mi­da­ti­on, hosti­li­ty or humiliation.

In the absence of this, the employ­er is under no obli­ga­ti­on under Sec­tion 12(3) of the AGG to take acti­ve mea­su­res against the accu­sed employee. Nor does this give rise to any entit­le­ment to compensation.

What does this ruling mean for employees and employers?

For employees, the ruling shows that sub­jec­ti­ve fee­lings alo­ne are not suf­fi­ci­ent to estab­lish legal claims. Unp­lea­sant situa­tions or a poor working atmo­sphe­re are stressful, but do not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly con­sti­tu­te bul­ly­ing in the legal sen­se. Anyo­ne who belie­ves they are actual­ly being sys­te­ma­ti­cal­ly haras­sed should careful­ly docu­ment spe­ci­fic incidents.

Employ­ers, for their part, see this as con­fir­ma­ti­on that not every com­plaint about col­le­agues neces­s­a­ri­ly has to lead to disci­pli­na­ry action. Their duty of care obli­ges them to take con­flicts serious­ly and to offer solu­ti­ons, for exam­p­le through media­ti­on or work­place inte­gra­ti­on sup­port. Whe­ther fur­ther con­cre­te steps are neces­sa­ry depends on the indi­vi­du­al case.

In case of doubt, it is advi­sa­ble for both employees and employ­ers to seek advice on employ­ment law befo­re taking legal action.

Mann­heim Labour Court, jud­ge­ment of 11 June 2026, Case No. 5 Ca 139/25

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this