Anyone who feels mistreated by a colleague at work is quick to think of bullying. However, in a recent ruling, the Mannheim Labour Court has clarified where the legal line is drawn and what constitutes mere interpersonal tensions.
The case: Administrative assistant takes legal action over her colleague’s dismissal
An administrative officer in the human resources department of a university found the working atmosphere so stressful due to the behaviour of a colleague that she took sick leave in March 2024. Upon her return in May 2024, she reported ongoing health problems and a feeling of being excluded from the team. Mediation, suggested by her line manager, failed because the colleague accused of the behaviour refused to take part. A workplace integration programme also failed to produce a solution.
The employee eventually took legal action, demanding that her employer take disciplinary action against her colleague – specifically, dismissal, transfer or, at the very least, a written warning. She also claimed compensation under the General Equal Treatment Act (AGG), as she felt she had been discriminated against.
Court finds no evidence of discrimination or bullying
The Mannheim Labour Court dismissed the claim in its entirety. The judges emphasised that conflicts between colleagues are part of everyday working life and are not automatically legally relevant. The decisive factor is whether the behaviour is systematically aimed at violating a person’s dignity or at creating a hostile working environment through intimidation, hostility or humiliation.
In this specific case, the court did not consider this threshold to have been exceeded. A particularly telling example: the claimant regarded it as bullying that her colleague had not thanked her for her birthday wishes. The judges expressed their astonishment that such an incident should serve as grounds for dismissal. In this regard, they noted that employees have no right to be liked or viewed favourably by their colleagues. There is simply no obligation for colleagues to maintain a friendly relationship.
What does this mean in legal terms, specifically?
According to case law, workplace bullying within the meaning of employment law is only deemed to exist if all of the following conditions are met:
- The behaviour is systematic and recurrent.
- It is intended to, or results in, an infringement of a person’s dignity.
- An environment is created that is characterised by intimidation, hostility or humiliation.
In the absence of this, the employer is under no obligation under Section 12(3) of the AGG to take active measures against the accused employee. Nor does this give rise to any entitlement to compensation.
What does this ruling mean for employees and employers?
For employees, the ruling shows that subjective feelings alone are not sufficient to establish legal claims. Unpleasant situations or a poor working atmosphere are stressful, but do not automatically constitute bullying in the legal sense. Anyone who believes they are actually being systematically harassed should carefully document specific incidents.
Employers, for their part, see this as confirmation that not every complaint about colleagues necessarily has to lead to disciplinary action. Their duty of care obliges them to take conflicts seriously and to offer solutions, for example through mediation or workplace integration support. Whether further concrete steps are necessary depends on the individual case.
In case of doubt, it is advisable for both employees and employers to seek advice on employment law before taking legal action.
Mannheim Labour Court, judgement of 11 June 2026, Case No. 5 Ca 139/25
Source: Haufe: Human Resources
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.