The Federal Ministry of Finance is working on a draft bill intended to fundamentally change the taxation of certain cryptocurrencies. Specifically, the aim is to ensure that so-called exchange-traded cryptocurrencies, such as Bitcoin or Ether, acquired after 31 December 2026, will in future no longer be taxed as miscellaneous income but as income from capital assets. What may sound at first glance like a technical reclassification has far-reaching consequences in practice.
The end of tax exemption after one year
Currently, a one-year holding period applies to cryptocurrencies. Anyone who holds Bitcoin or Ether for longer than twelve months can sell them tax-free. This rule will no longer apply to new holdings acquired on or after 1 January 2027. Instead, capital gains tax of 25 per cent would be levied on profits, regardless of how long the tokens were held. For existing holdings – that is, all tokens acquired before that date – the current rules will continue to apply.
Existing holdings and new holdings in the same wallet
This is precisely where one of the biggest challenges lies. Anyone who regularly buys cryptocurrencies over a period of years may end up with a wallet containing identical tokens that are treated under completely different tax rules. Whether a sale is tax-free or subject to capital gains tax then depends on the exact date of acquisition. The order in which tokens are deemed to have been sold plays a crucial role in this regard.
A concrete example: anyone who invests in Ether every month from 2024 to 2030 and sells half of their holdings in 2031 must be able to trace exactly which tokens were purchased and when. Documenting the purchase history will therefore become even more important than before.
Staking returns and recurring income
The tax treatment of staking – that is, the provision of tokens for network processing in return for a reward – is also set to change. From 1 January 2027, staking income is to be treated as income from capital assets. Anyone who receives tokens as part of their salary could face double taxation if the draft legislation is implemented as it stands: once when the tokens are received as wages, and again upon disposal, should the acquisition cost be set at zero euros.
Restrictions on loss set-off
Anyone who incurs losses on crypto assets has, until now, been able to carry these back to the previous year or carry them forward indefinitely. If such assets were classified as capital assets, only carry-forward would be permitted in future. Carry-back would no longer be permitted. Given the sometimes enormous price fluctuations in cryptocurrencies, this is no small matter.
Withholding tax on investment income from 2028 and missing data
From 2028, domestic providers will be required to withhold and pay capital gains tax directly, including in the case of swaps between different cryptocurrencies. If the provider lacks the purchase details, half of the sale proceeds would be treated as profit on a flat-rate basis. This could lead to tax deductions even though no profit was actually made or the sale is even tax-exempt. Investors should therefore keep a complete record of their transaction history.
What does this mean for crypto investors?
The draft bill has not yet been passed and is still subject to change. Nevertheless, it is worth analysing your own crypto holdings now. Anyone with a large number of existing holdings should consider whether and when it might be advisable to sell before the cut-off date. At the same time, all purchase details, prices and transactions should be carefully recorded. In individual cases, it is advisable to seek tax advice, as the transitional situation is complex and tax errors can quickly prove costly.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.