Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Coronavirus emergency aid: Recovery of funds lawful despite slump in turnover

Coronavirus emergency aid: Recovery of funds lawful despite slump in turnover

In its jud­ge­ment of 26 August 2026 (Case No. 2 K 29/26.KO), the Koblenz Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court dis­missed the cla­im brought by a den­tist from Rhi­ne­land-Pala­ti­na­te. She had con­tes­ted the demand for the full repay­ment of 15,000 euros in coro­na­vi­rus emer­gen­cy aid. The out­co­me may seem sur­pri­sing at first glan­ce, but on clo­ser inspec­tion it can be explai­ned by the claimant’s own figures.

What had happened?

In April 2020, the den­tist had appli­ed for emer­gen­cy aid for her prac­ti­ce and recei­ved the maxi­mum amount of 15,000 euros. The decis­i­on was sub­ject to a sub­se­quent review. In Novem­ber 2023, the aut­ho­ri­ty reques­ted the actu­al figu­res for the rele­vant three-month peri­od. The clai­mant repor­ted inco­me of around 121,300 euros and expen­dit­u­re of around 86,900 euros. This resul­ted in a cash sur­plus of more than 34,000 euros, mea­ning the­re was no cash flow short­fall. In Janu­ary 2025, the aut­ho­ri­ty set the emer­gen­cy aid at zero and deman­ded the full 15,000 euros be repaid.

Why was the claim unsuccessful?

The dentist’s own state­ments work­ed against her. Accor­ding to admi­nis­tra­ti­ve prac­ti­ce in Rhi­ne­land-Pala­ti­na­te, a cash sur­plus pre­cludes any fun­ding. The clai­mant attempt­ed to include staff cos­ts, such as inco­me tax and social secu­ri­ty con­tri­bu­ti­ons, in the cal­cu­la­ti­on in order to fabri­ca­te a finan­cial short­fall. The court rejec­ted this. The fun­ding aut­ho­ri­ty had alre­a­dy made it clear in its FAQs as ear­ly as July 2022 that staff cos­ts would not be taken into account. Anyo­ne who brings a cla­im against such a docu­men­ted and con­sis­t­ent­ly appli­ed admi­nis­tra­ti­ve prac­ti­ce has litt­le pro­s­pect of suc­cess befo­re the admi­nis­tra­ti­ve courts.

Nor was the court per­sua­ded by the argu­ment that den­tists bill on a quar­ter­ly basis and that, as a result, pay­ments from the pre­vious quar­ter are included in the peri­od under con­side­ra­ti­on in a way that distorts the pic­tu­re. What is decisi­ve is the actu­al cash flow over the three-month peri­od, regard­less of the bil­ling peri­od for which a pay­ment was ori­gi­nal­ly intended.

Unresolved issue: Automated notifications

One point that the court deli­bera­te­ly cho­se not to rule on is of par­ti­cu­lar inte­rest. The clai­mant argued that the final decis­i­on had been drawn up in a ful­ly auto­ma­ted man­ner and wit­hout any genui­ne assess­ment of the indi­vi­du­al case. This would be pro­ble­ma­tic under Sec­tion 35a of the Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Pro­ce­du­re Act (VwVfG), as ful­ly auto­ma­ted decis­i­ons requi­re a sta­tu­to­ry basis and must not invol­ve any exer­cise of dis­cre­ti­on. Howe­ver, emer­gen­cy aid is a dis­cre­tio­na­ry benefit.

The Koblenz Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court sidestep­ped the issue. It poin­ted out that the noti­ce of appeal had been signed by two offi­ci­als named by name and had addres­sed the claimant’s spe­ci­fic objec­tions. This, it argued, con­sti­tu­ted a human review which reme­di­ed any poten­ti­al error in the ori­gi­nal decis­i­on. Whe­ther this holds up in law, and whe­ther an appeal decis­i­on can in any case reme­dy a breach of Sec­tion 35a of the Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Pro­ce­du­re Act (VwVfG), remains an open ques­ti­on. In fede­ral sta­tes wit­hout an appeals pro­ce­du­re, the courts will have to ans­wer this ques­ti­on directly.

What does this mean for those affected?

The ruling does not con­sti­tu­te a gene­ral signal to aban­don ongo­ing pro­cee­dings. Howe­ver, it cle­ar­ly shows whe­re the boun­da­ries lie:

  • Anyo­ne who, by their own admis­si­on, reports a liqui­di­ty sur­plus stands vir­tual­ly no chan­ce, even if they cite staff cos­ts as a reason.
  • The pre­cise admi­nis­tra­ti­ve pro­ce­du­re for cal­cu­la­ting cos­ts should be che­cked at an ear­ly stage by inspec­ting the files.
  • The ques­ti­on of the appro­pria­te time frame has not yet been defi­ni­tively resol­ved and may be decisi­ve in cer­tain circumstances.
  • The issue of auto­ma­ti­on remains a poten­ti­al point of chall­enge if no oppo­si­ti­on pro­cee­dings have taken place or if the oppo­si­ti­on decis­i­on is cle­ar­ly com­po­sed of boi­ler­p­la­te text.

The jud­ge­ment is not yet final. The clai­mant may app­ly to the Hig­her Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court of Rhi­ne­land-Pala­ti­na­te for lea­ve to appeal within one month of ser­vice of the jud­ge­ment. Anyo­ne who has recei­ved a demand for repay­ment should keep an eye on the dead­lines and seek legal advice.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this