In its judgement of 26 August 2026 (Case No. 2 K 29/26.KO), the Koblenz Administrative Court dismissed the claim brought by a dentist from Rhineland-Palatinate. She had contested the demand for the full repayment of 15,000 euros in coronavirus emergency aid. The outcome may seem surprising at first glance, but on closer inspection it can be explained by the claimant’s own figures.
What had happened?
In April 2020, the dentist had applied for emergency aid for her practice and received the maximum amount of 15,000 euros. The decision was subject to a subsequent review. In November 2023, the authority requested the actual figures for the relevant three-month period. The claimant reported income of around 121,300 euros and expenditure of around 86,900 euros. This resulted in a cash surplus of more than 34,000 euros, meaning there was no cash flow shortfall. In January 2025, the authority set the emergency aid at zero and demanded the full 15,000 euros be repaid.
Why was the claim unsuccessful?
The dentist’s own statements worked against her. According to administrative practice in Rhineland-Palatinate, a cash surplus precludes any funding. The claimant attempted to include staff costs, such as income tax and social security contributions, in the calculation in order to fabricate a financial shortfall. The court rejected this. The funding authority had already made it clear in its FAQs as early as July 2022 that staff costs would not be taken into account. Anyone who brings a claim against such a documented and consistently applied administrative practice has little prospect of success before the administrative courts.
Nor was the court persuaded by the argument that dentists bill on a quarterly basis and that, as a result, payments from the previous quarter are included in the period under consideration in a way that distorts the picture. What is decisive is the actual cash flow over the three-month period, regardless of the billing period for which a payment was originally intended.
Unresolved issue: Automated notifications
One point that the court deliberately chose not to rule on is of particular interest. The claimant argued that the final decision had been drawn up in a fully automated manner and without any genuine assessment of the individual case. This would be problematic under Section 35a of the Administrative Procedure Act (VwVfG), as fully automated decisions require a statutory basis and must not involve any exercise of discretion. However, emergency aid is a discretionary benefit.
The Koblenz Administrative Court sidestepped the issue. It pointed out that the notice of appeal had been signed by two officials named by name and had addressed the claimant’s specific objections. This, it argued, constituted a human review which remedied any potential error in the original decision. Whether this holds up in law, and whether an appeal decision can in any case remedy a breach of Section 35a of the Administrative Procedure Act (VwVfG), remains an open question. In federal states without an appeals procedure, the courts will have to answer this question directly.
What does this mean for those affected?
The ruling does not constitute a general signal to abandon ongoing proceedings. However, it clearly shows where the boundaries lie:
- Anyone who, by their own admission, reports a liquidity surplus stands virtually no chance, even if they cite staff costs as a reason.
- The precise administrative procedure for calculating costs should be checked at an early stage by inspecting the files.
- The question of the appropriate time frame has not yet been definitively resolved and may be decisive in certain circumstances.
- The issue of automation remains a potential point of challenge if no opposition proceedings have taken place or if the opposition decision is clearly composed of boilerplate text.
The judgement is not yet final. The claimant may apply to the Higher Administrative Court of Rhineland-Palatinate for leave to appeal within one month of service of the judgement. Anyone who has received a demand for repayment should keep an eye on the deadlines and seek legal advice.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.