Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Federal Court of Justice: Under the ‘local resident’ model, the time limit for the right of repurchase only begins to run once a request for an extension has been refused

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) cla­ri­fies: Under the ‘local resi­dent model’, the time limit for the right of repurcha­se only beg­ins to run once an appli­ca­ti­on for an exten­si­on has been refused. 
Federal Court of Justice: Under the ‘local resident’ model, the time limit for the right of repurchase only begins to run once a request for an extension has been refused

Federal Court of Justice: Under the ‘local resident’ model, the time limit for the right of repurchase only begins to run once a request for an extension has been refused

Anyo­ne who buys a plot of land from a local aut­ho­ri­ty at below mar­ket pri­ce gene­ral­ly enters into a buil­ding obli­ga­ti­on. In a recent jud­ge­ment of 17 July 2026 (Case No. V ZR 153/25), the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce has cla­ri­fied the gene­ral prin­ci­ples gover­ning what hap­pens if con­s­truc­tion does not take place and the purcha­ser requests more time.

What is a local labour model?

Under so-cal­led ‘local resi­dents’ sche­mes, local aut­ho­ri­ties sell buil­ding plots to local resi­dents at redu­ced pri­ces. In return, the buy­er under­ta­kes to build on the plot within a spe­ci­fied peri­od and to use it for their own pur­po­ses. If they fail to ful­fil this obli­ga­ti­on, the local aut­ho­ri­ty may buy back the plot, i.e. exer­cise its right of repurchase.

The case: Construction deadline has passed; the local authority wants the plot back

A Bava­ri­an local aut­ho­ri­ty had sold a plot of land in April 2019 at a pri­ce below mar­ket value. The buy­er under­took to build a detached house by April 2023. Should she fail to do so, the local aut­ho­ri­ty would have a right of repurcha­se for 15 years, which had to be exer­cis­ed by regis­tered post within six months of beco­ming awa­re of the breach.

Short­ly befo­re the con­s­truc­tion dead­line was due to expi­re, the purcha­ser reques­ted a five-year exten­si­on in Janu­ary 2023. The local aut­ho­ri­ty rejec­ted this in March 2023. In August 2023, she then exer­cis­ed her right of repurcha­se and deman­ded the retrans­fer of the plot in return for repay­ment of the purcha­se price.

The Regio­nal Court and the Hig­her Regio­nal Court dis­missed the local authority’s cla­im. Their reaso­ning was that the six-month peri­od had alre­a­dy begun upon receipt of the appli­ca­ti­on for an exten­si­on in Janu­ary 2023, and that the exer­cise of the right in August 2023 had the­r­e­fo­re taken place too late.

The Federal Court of Justice rules in favour of the local authority

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce took a dif­fe­rent view and made it clear that the time limit for exer­cis­ing the right of repurcha­se does not begin until the local aut­ho­ri­ty has rejec­ted the appli­ca­ti­on for an exten­si­on, i.e. on 9 March 2023 at the ear­liest. This is becau­se local aut­ho­ri­ties are bound by public law and must careful­ly con­sider whe­ther to grant such a request. They requi­re suf­fi­ci­ent time to make this dis­cre­tio­na­ry decis­i­on. It is only after the request has been rejec­ted that it is defi­ni­tively estab­lished that the con­s­truc­tion dead­line can­not be met.

As the local aut­ho­ri­ty exer­cis­ed its right of repurcha­se on 4 August 2023, this fell within the six-month peri­od. The right to re-trans­fer the­r­e­fo­re existed.

No right of withdrawal in addition to the right of repurchase

Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce did not per­mit a fur­ther with­dra­wal from the purcha­se con­tract. The obli­ga­ti­on to build under the ‘local resi­dent’ model is not an enforceable pri­ma­ry obli­ga­ti­on, but rather a so-cal­led ‘duty’. This means that, whilst the purcha­ser is not legal­ly obli­ged to build the house, she risks losing the plot of land if she fails to do so. If a right of repurcha­se has been agreed, the local aut­ho­ri­ty is rest­ric­ted to this and may not addi­tio­nal­ly with­draw from the contract.

What does this mean for buyers and local authorities?

For pri­va­te indi­vi­du­als purcha­sing a plot of land under a local resi­dents’ sche­me, this ruling sends an important mes­sa­ge: the obli­ga­ti­on to build must be taken serious­ly. A favoura­ble purcha­se pri­ce is con­di­tio­nal upon deve­lo­p­ment taking place in a time­ly man­ner. Anyo­ne who fails to meet the dead­line and appli­es for an exten­si­on runs the risk that the local aut­ho­ri­ty will exer­cise its right of repurcha­se as soon as it rejects the application.

For local aut­ho­ri­ties, the ruling pro­vi­des legal cer­tain­ty as to when the peri­od for exer­cis­ing this right beg­ins and how dis­cre­tio­na­ry decis­i­ons regar­ding an exten­si­on of this peri­od should be inter­pre­ted. Anyo­ne who, as a pro­per­ty buy­er, finds them­sel­ves in a simi­lar situa­ti­on, or who wis­hes to act on behalf of a local aut­ho­ri­ty, should seek legal advice on a case-by-case basis.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this