Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) clarifies: Is the owners’ association liable to pay if common property causes damage to a flat?

The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) clarifies: Is the owners’ association liable to pay if common property causes damage to a flat?

If dama­ge is cau­sed to a pri­va­te flat as a result of a defect in the com­mon pro­per­ty, the ques­ti­on ari­ses: who bears the cos­ts? On 4 Decem­ber 2026, the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) will con­sider pre­cis­e­ly this sce­na­rio and could thus final­ly cla­ri­fy a legal situa­ti­on that has been the sub­ject of con­tro­ver­sy for years. Case num­ber: V ZR 259/25.

What happened?

The clai­mant owns a ground-flo­or flat in a block of flats (WEG) and lets it out. In 2021, the return pump of the sewa­ge lif­ting sys­tem fai­led. This pump forms part of what is known as the ‘com­mon pro­per­ty’, i.e. the part of the buil­ding that is joint­ly owned by all owners and mana­ged by the asso­cia­ti­on. Fol­lo­wing a hea­vy down­pour, sewa­ge con­ta­mi­na­ted with faecal mat­ter ente­red the flat through the fault. The flat was tem­po­r­a­ri­ly uninhabitable.

The owner is now clai­ming com­pen­sa­ti­on from the owners’ asso­cia­ti­on for lost ren­tal inco­me, the ten­ants’ rem­oval cos­ts and their accom­mo­da­ti­on cos­ts. In some cases, she is also asser­ting claims that the ten­ants have assi­gned to her.

What are the parties disputing in legal terms?

Both the Mön­chen­glad­bach Local Court and the Düs­sel­dorf Regio­nal Court dis­missed the cla­im. The Regio­nal Court argued that a cla­im for com­pen­sa­ti­on under the Con­do­mi­ni­um Act, as amen­ded in 2020, did not app­ly in this case. Under the pre­vious legal frame­work, it was reco­g­nis­ed that owners had to bear the cos­ts of dama­ge ari­sing from the com­mon pro­per­ty them­sel­ves. The reform of the Con­do­mi­ni­um Act had not alte­red this.

The clai­mant takes a dif­fe­rent view. She reli­es on Sec­tion 14(3) of the WEG, which, sin­ce the reform, has been for­mu­la­ted as a so-cal­led ‘com­pen­sa­ti­on for sacri­fice’ cla­im. This sec­tion pro­vi­des that a flat owner who is requi­red to tole­ra­te an impact that exceeds what is reasonable may demand appro­pria­te finan­cial com­pen­sa­ti­on. The clai­mant takes the view that this pro­vi­si­on also covers invol­un­t­a­ry dama­ge such as water ingress cau­sed by a defect. In the alter­na­ti­ve, she invo­kes a cor­re­spon­ding appli­ca­ti­on of the Sec­tion 906(2), second sen­tence, of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB), which gives rise to a cla­im for com­pen­sa­ti­on in com­pa­ra­ble neigh­bour­hood situations.

Why is this decision important?

The ques­ti­on con­cerns a situa­ti­on that occurs time and again in blocks of flats: a burst pipe in a com­mu­nal area, a fault in the hea­ting sys­tem or, inde­ed, an over­flowing drai­na­ge sys­tem cau­ses dama­ge to an indi­vi­du­al owner’s flat. Until now, it was unclear whe­ther the owners’ asso­cia­ti­on is lia­ble in such cases if no fault on the part of the pro­per­ty mana­ger can be proven.

The Fede­ral Court of Justice’s ruling is expec­ted to be of con­sidera­ble signi­fi­can­ce for all flat owners in Ger­ma­ny. Tho­se affec­ted can eit­her expect grea­ter pro­tec­tion or will con­ti­nue to have to cover the cos­ts of such dama­ge them­sel­ves and will be reli­ant on pri­va­te insurance.

What does this mean for property owners and landlords?

  • Flats owners who let out their flats curr­ent­ly bear the risk of dama­ge cau­sed by defec­ti­ve com­mu­nal pro­per­ty themselves.
  • Whe­ther the 2020 WEG reform has chan­ged any­thing in this regard will only be cla­ri­fied by the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce on 4 Decem­ber 2026.
  • Pen­ding a decis­i­on, it is advi­sa­ble to review your own insu­rance cover and, if neces­sa­ry, seek legal advice on how to deal with ongo­ing claims.

Any flat owner or land­lord fin­ding them­sel­ves in a simi­lar situa­ti­on should fol­low the Fede­ral Court of Justice’s ruling clo­se­ly. If in doubt, it is worth see­king advice from a soli­ci­tor spe­cia­li­sing in ten­an­cy law or the Ger­man Con­do­mi­ni­um Act (WEG).

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this