If damage is caused to a private flat as a result of a defect in the common property, the question arises: who bears the costs? On 4 December 2026, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) will consider precisely this scenario and could thus finally clarify a legal situation that has been the subject of controversy for years. Case number: V ZR 259/25.
What happened?
The claimant owns a ground-floor flat in a block of flats (WEG) and lets it out. In 2021, the return pump of the sewage lifting system failed. This pump forms part of what is known as the ‘common property’, i.e. the part of the building that is jointly owned by all owners and managed by the association. Following a heavy downpour, sewage contaminated with faecal matter entered the flat through the fault. The flat was temporarily uninhabitable.
The owner is now claiming compensation from the owners’ association for lost rental income, the tenants’ removal costs and their accommodation costs. In some cases, she is also asserting claims that the tenants have assigned to her.
What are the parties disputing in legal terms?
Both the Mönchengladbach Local Court and the Düsseldorf Regional Court dismissed the claim. The Regional Court argued that a claim for compensation under the Condominium Act, as amended in 2020, did not apply in this case. Under the previous legal framework, it was recognised that owners had to bear the costs of damage arising from the common property themselves. The reform of the Condominium Act had not altered this.
The claimant takes a different view. She relies on Section 14(3) of the WEG, which, since the reform, has been formulated as a so-called ‘compensation for sacrifice’ claim. This section provides that a flat owner who is required to tolerate an impact that exceeds what is reasonable may demand appropriate financial compensation. The claimant takes the view that this provision also covers involuntary damage such as water ingress caused by a defect. In the alternative, she invokes a corresponding application of the Section 906(2), second sentence, of the German Civil Code (BGB), which gives rise to a claim for compensation in comparable neighbourhood situations.
Why is this decision important?
The question concerns a situation that occurs time and again in blocks of flats: a burst pipe in a communal area, a fault in the heating system or, indeed, an overflowing drainage system causes damage to an individual owner’s flat. Until now, it was unclear whether the owners’ association is liable in such cases if no fault on the part of the property manager can be proven.
The Federal Court of Justice’s ruling is expected to be of considerable significance for all flat owners in Germany. Those affected can either expect greater protection or will continue to have to cover the costs of such damage themselves and will be reliant on private insurance.
What does this mean for property owners and landlords?
- Flats owners who let out their flats currently bear the risk of damage caused by defective communal property themselves.
- Whether the 2020 WEG reform has changed anything in this regard will only be clarified by the Federal Court of Justice on 4 December 2026.
- Pending a decision, it is advisable to review your own insurance cover and, if necessary, seek legal advice on how to deal with ongoing claims.
Any flat owner or landlord finding themselves in a similar situation should follow the Federal Court of Justice’s ruling closely. If in doubt, it is worth seeking advice from a solicitor specialising in tenancy law or the German Condominium Act (WEG).
Source: BGH press releases
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.