Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Child benefit for separated parents: Who takes precedence if the child lives in both households?

Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH): When it comes to child bene­fit, what mat­ters is whe­re the child’s main cent­re of life is, not who pays more main­ten­an­ce. Ref. III R 8/25.
Child benefit for separated parents: Who takes precedence if the child lives in both households?

Child benefit for separated parents: Who takes precedence if the child lives in both households?

When par­ents live apart and their child spends time in both house­holds, the ques­ti­on often ari­ses: who is entit­led to child bene­fit? In its jud­ge­ment of 9 July 2026 (Case No. III R 8/25), the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) estab­lished important prin­ci­ples on this mat­ter and, in doing so, cor­rec­ted a wide­ly held assump­ti­on: the parent who pays more money does not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly take precedence.

The situation: father in Germany, mother abroad

A father recei­ved child bene­fit for his son. In ear­ly 2020, the mother moved to a coun­try within the Euro­pean Eco­no­mic Area (EEA); the son moved with her and atten­ded school the­re. He spent his holi­days with his father in Ger­ma­ny. In 2022, the son spent 108 days with his father and 257 days with his mother. The father paid main­ten­an­ce, cover­ed the cost of flights and pri­va­te tui­ti­on fees, and pas­sed the child bene­fit on to the mother.

The Fami­ly Bene­fits Office revo­ked the child bene­fit award in favour of the father with effect from April 2022. It con­side­red the mother to be the pri­ma­ry clai­mant becau­se the son lived pre­do­mi­nant­ly with her. The Finan­ce Court initi­al­ly ruled in the father’s favour. Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court over­tur­ned this ruling and refer­red the case back.

It is one’s focus in life that matters, not financial payments

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) cla­ri­fies that, whe­re the­re are seve­ral per­sons entit­led to child bene­fit, prio­ri­ty is deter­mi­ned by what is known as ‘house­hold pla­ce­ment’ – that is, by the house­hold in which the child is actual­ly living. The decisi­ve fac­tor here is whe­re the child has their Focus on foodhas and whe­re it spends most of its time.

The spe­ci­fic fac­tu­al cir­cum­s­tances are decisi­ve. Rele­vant fac­tors may include:

  • Length of stay with each parent
  • Joint cus­t­ody
  • A sepa­ra­te bed­room for the child at each parent’s home
  • The child’s abili­ty to choo­se their place of resi­dence freely

Howe­ver, the ext­ent of finan­cial sup­port – such as main­ten­an­ce pay­ments, air­fa­res paid on behalf of the child or other finan­cial con­tri­bu­ti­ons – must express­ly not be taken into account. The law pro­vi­des for cash main­ten­an­ce pay­ments as a cri­ter­ion only whe­re the­re is no cus­t­ody arran­ge­ment at all. It would be con­tra­dic­to­ry to use them addi­tio­nal­ly when deter­mi­ning whe­ther a child has been taken into the household.

Special circumstances in shared custody arrangements

If child­ren spend a signi­fi­cant amount of time in both par­ents’ house­holds – that is, not mere­ly for visits or holi­days – the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) refers to this as ‘appro­xi­m­ate­ly equal resi­dence’. In this case, the par­ents must agree among­st them­sel­ves who is to cla­im child bene­fit. If they can­not reach an agree­ment, the child’s main place of resi­dence will be the deci­ding factor.

In the pre­sent case, the son spent signi­fi­cant­ly more time with his mother in 2022. As the­re were no appa­rent spe­cial cir­cum­s­tances to off­set this imba­lan­ce, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) regard­ed the mother as having the pri­ma­ry right of custody.

Unresolved issues regarding EEA-related foreign transactions

The pro­cee­dings are not yet con­cluded. In the second ins­tance, the Finan­ce Court must still deter­mi­ne whe­ther the mother is entit­led to Ger­man child bene­fit at all. As she has moved her place of resi­dence abroad, the key issue is whe­ther, under Euro­pean coor­di­na­ti­on law, a dee­med place of resi­dence in Ger­ma­ny can be estab­lished. It must also be exami­ned whe­ther for­eign fami­ly bene­fits pre­clude the entit­le­ment to Ger­man child bene­fit in who­le or in part.

For par­ents in simi­lar situa­tions, par­ti­cu­lar­ly tho­se living across natio­nal bor­ders or sha­ring cus­t­ody, it is advi­sa­ble to have a tax advi­ser car­ry out a detail­ed assess­ment of the indi­vi­du­al case.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this