When parents live apart and their child spends time in both households, the question often arises: who is entitled to child benefit? In its judgement of 9 July 2026 (Case No. III R 8/25), the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) established important principles on this matter and, in doing so, corrected a widely held assumption: the parent who pays more money does not automatically take precedence.
The situation: father in Germany, mother abroad
A father received child benefit for his son. In early 2020, the mother moved to a country within the European Economic Area (EEA); the son moved with her and attended school there. He spent his holidays with his father in Germany. In 2022, the son spent 108 days with his father and 257 days with his mother. The father paid maintenance, covered the cost of flights and private tuition fees, and passed the child benefit on to the mother.
The Family Benefits Office revoked the child benefit award in favour of the father with effect from April 2022. It considered the mother to be the primary claimant because the son lived predominantly with her. The Finance Court initially ruled in the father’s favour. However, the Federal Fiscal Court overturned this ruling and referred the case back.
It is one’s focus in life that matters, not financial payments
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) clarifies that, where there are several persons entitled to child benefit, priority is determined by what is known as ‘household placement’ – that is, by the household in which the child is actually living. The decisive factor here is where the child has their Focus on foodhas and where it spends most of its time.
The specific factual circumstances are decisive. Relevant factors may include:
- Length of stay with each parent
- Joint custody
- A separate bedroom for the child at each parent’s home
- The child’s ability to choose their place of residence freely
However, the extent of financial support – such as maintenance payments, airfares paid on behalf of the child or other financial contributions – must expressly not be taken into account. The law provides for cash maintenance payments as a criterion only where there is no custody arrangement at all. It would be contradictory to use them additionally when determining whether a child has been taken into the household.
Special circumstances in shared custody arrangements
If children spend a significant amount of time in both parents’ households – that is, not merely for visits or holidays – the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) refers to this as ‘approximately equal residence’. In this case, the parents must agree amongst themselves who is to claim child benefit. If they cannot reach an agreement, the child’s main place of residence will be the deciding factor.
In the present case, the son spent significantly more time with his mother in 2022. As there were no apparent special circumstances to offset this imbalance, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) regarded the mother as having the primary right of custody.
Unresolved issues regarding EEA-related foreign transactions
The proceedings are not yet concluded. In the second instance, the Finance Court must still determine whether the mother is entitled to German child benefit at all. As she has moved her place of residence abroad, the key issue is whether, under European coordination law, a deemed place of residence in Germany can be established. It must also be examined whether foreign family benefits preclude the entitlement to German child benefit in whole or in part.
For parents in similar situations, particularly those living across national borders or sharing custody, it is advisable to have a tax adviser carry out a detailed assessment of the individual case.
Source: BFH press releases
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.