When parents share custody of their child following a separation, the question often arises as to which of the two is entitled to receive child benefit. On 9 July 2026, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) handed down an important ruling on this matter, which is particularly significant for families with cross-border childcare arrangements (Case No. III R 8/25).
The case: The son lives mainly abroad with his mother
A father received child benefit for his son. The parents had initially shared custody of the child on an alternating basis, but in early 2020 the mother moved to a country within the European Economic Area (EEA) and took their son with her. He has been attending school there since January 2021. In the year in question, 2022, the son spent 257 days with his mother and 108 days with his father, who spent the holidays with him. The father paid maintenance, covered the cost of flights and private tuition fees, and passed the child benefit on to the mother.
The Family Benefits Office revoked the child benefit award in favour of the father with effect from April 2022, as it considered the mother to be the primary claimant. The Finance Court initially ruled in the father’s favour. However, the Federal Fiscal Court overturned this ruling and referred the case back.
Ruling: The centre of one’s life is the decisive factor, not financial benefits
Under the Income Tax Act (Section 64(2) EStG), where there are several eligible recipients, child benefit is generally paid to the person who has taken the child into their household. If children spend time in both households and their stays with the other parent go beyond mere visits or holiday stays, the decisive factor is the child’s centre of life.
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) made it clear in this regard that financial contributions from a parent – such as maintenance payments, airfares or tuition fees – are irrelevant to the question of whether the child is living in the parent’s household. The law links the priority of entitlement either to actual custody or, only secondarily, to the amount of maintenance paid. If cash maintenance payments were taken into account under the first criterion, this would undermine the order of priority laid down by law.
The actual circumstances are decisive
- Where does the child spend most of their time?
- Where is the centre of his life?
- Factors such as joint custody, a child having their own bedroom, or the child being free to choose where they live may influence the assessment.
In this specific case, the fact that the child spent a significantly longer period of time with the mother clearly indicated that she should be given priority. As the father was unable to cite any other special circumstances that would counterbalance this factor, the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) deemed it established that the child had taken up residence solely with the mother.
Unresolved issue: the mother’s entitlement to child benefit from abroad
The proceedings are not yet concluded. In the second instance, the Finance Court must determine whether the mother is entitled to German child benefit at all, given that she lives abroad, and whether foreign family benefits reduce or exclude her entitlement to German child benefit. European coordination rules play a role here.
For families in a shared custody arrangement, particularly where one parent lives abroad, this ruling shows that the child’s actual period of residence and the place where they actually have their main centre of life are decisive for entitlement to child benefit. A parent who contributes significantly financially is not automatically entitled to child benefit. In similar situations, it is advisable to seek tax advice to clarify one’s own position.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.