Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Child benefit in shared custody arrangements: Federal Fiscal Court emphasises the importance of the child’s main place of residence

Child benefit in shared custody arrangements: Federal Fiscal Court emphasises the importance of the child’s main place of residence

When par­ents share cus­t­ody of their child fol­lo­wing a sepa­ra­ti­on, the ques­ti­on often ari­ses as to which of the two is entit­led to recei­ve child bene­fit. On 9 July 2026, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) han­ded down an important ruling on this mat­ter, which is par­ti­cu­lar­ly signi­fi­cant for fami­lies with cross-bor­der child­ca­re arran­ge­ments (Case No. III R 8/25).

The case: The son lives mainly abroad with his mother

A father recei­ved child bene­fit for his son. The par­ents had initi­al­ly shared cus­t­ody of the child on an alter­na­ting basis, but in ear­ly 2020 the mother moved to a coun­try within the Euro­pean Eco­no­mic Area (EEA) and took their son with her. He has been atten­ding school the­re sin­ce Janu­ary 2021. In the year in ques­ti­on, 2022, the son spent 257 days with his mother and 108 days with his father, who spent the holi­days with him. The father paid main­ten­an­ce, cover­ed the cost of flights and pri­va­te tui­ti­on fees, and pas­sed the child bene­fit on to the mother.

The Fami­ly Bene­fits Office revo­ked the child bene­fit award in favour of the father with effect from April 2022, as it con­side­red the mother to be the pri­ma­ry clai­mant. The Finan­ce Court initi­al­ly ruled in the father’s favour. Howe­ver, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court over­tur­ned this ruling and refer­red the case back.

Ruling: The centre of one’s life is the decisive factor, not financial benefits

Under the Inco­me Tax Act (Sec­tion 64(2) EStG), whe­re the­re are seve­ral eli­gi­ble reci­pi­ents, child bene­fit is gene­ral­ly paid to the per­son who has taken the child into their house­hold. If child­ren spend time in both house­holds and their stays with the other parent go bey­ond mere visits or holi­day stays, the decisi­ve fac­tor is the child’s cent­re of life.

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) made it clear in this regard that finan­cial con­tri­bu­ti­ons from a parent – such as main­ten­an­ce pay­ments, air­fa­res or tui­ti­on fees – are irrele­vant to the ques­ti­on of whe­ther the child is living in the parent’s house­hold. The law links the prio­ri­ty of entit­le­ment eit­her to actu­al cus­t­ody or, only secon­da­ri­ly, to the amount of main­ten­an­ce paid. If cash main­ten­an­ce pay­ments were taken into account under the first cri­ter­ion, this would under­mi­ne the order of prio­ri­ty laid down by law.

The actual circumstances are decisive

  • Whe­re does the child spend most of their time?
  • Whe­re is the cent­re of his life?
  • Fac­tors such as joint cus­t­ody, a child having their own bed­room, or the child being free to choo­se whe­re they live may influence the assessment.

In this spe­ci­fic case, the fact that the child spent a signi­fi­cant­ly lon­ger peri­od of time with the mother cle­ar­ly indi­ca­ted that she should be given prio­ri­ty. As the father was unable to cite any other spe­cial cir­cum­s­tances that would coun­ter­ba­lan­ce this fac­tor, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) dee­med it estab­lished that the child had taken up resi­dence sole­ly with the mother.

Unresolved issue: the mother’s entitlement to child benefit from abroad

The pro­cee­dings are not yet con­cluded. In the second ins­tance, the Finan­ce Court must deter­mi­ne whe­ther the mother is entit­led to Ger­man child bene­fit at all, given that she lives abroad, and whe­ther for­eign fami­ly bene­fits redu­ce or exclude her entit­le­ment to Ger­man child bene­fit. Euro­pean coor­di­na­ti­on rules play a role here.

For fami­lies in a shared cus­t­ody arran­ge­ment, par­ti­cu­lar­ly whe­re one parent lives abroad, this ruling shows that the child’s actu­al peri­od of resi­dence and the place whe­re they actual­ly have their main cent­re of life are decisi­ve for entit­le­ment to child bene­fit. A parent who con­tri­bu­tes signi­fi­cant­ly finan­ci­al­ly is not auto­ma­ti­cal­ly entit­led to child bene­fit. In simi­lar situa­tions, it is advi­sa­ble to seek tax advice to cla­ri­fy one’s own position.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this