Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Tax audit report overlooked: tax office may still amend a final notice

Colo­gne Fis­cal Court: Over­loo­king a tax audit report can ren­der a final decis­i­on sub­ject to review even at a later date. 
Tax audit report overlooked: tax office may still amend a final notice

Tax audit report overlooked: tax office may still amend a final notice

A final tax assess­ment is, in prin­ci­ple, con­side­red to be final. The tax office may only amend it retro­s­pec­tively under very spe­ci­fic cir­cum­s­tances. The Colo­gne Finan­ce Court has now ruled that the fail­ure to take an audit report into account when making the assess­ment may con­sti­tu­te grounds for such an amendment.

What was the case about?

An asset-manage­ment GmbH & Co. KG had sub­mit­ted its tax returns to the tax office. At the same time, a tax audit had been car­ri­ed out at the com­pa­ny. The final audit report was for­ward­ed to the rele­vant assess­ment depart­ment at the tax office so that the fin­dings could be incor­po­ra­ted into the tax assess­ment notice.

Howe­ver, the tax office initi­al­ly asses­sed the com­pa­ny sole­ly on the basis of the tax returns sub­mit­ted, wit­hout taking into account the tax audit report that was alre­a­dy available. The assess­ment noti­ces issued in this way beca­me final becau­se no appeal was lodged against them.

It was only then that the tax office noti­ced the error and infor­med the clai­mant that the noti­ces would need to be amen­ded. As the legal basis, the office refer­red to Sec­tion 129 of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code (AO). This pro­vi­si­on per­mits the cor­rec­tion of cle­ri­cal errors, cal­cu­la­ti­on errors and simi­lar obvious inac­cu­ra­ci­es that occur­red during processing.

What is a manifest error?

The con­cept of ‘obvious inac­cu­ra­cy’ under sec­tion 129 of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code (AO) covers so-cal­led mecha­ni­cal errors made during pro­ces­sing. The­se may include typ­ing errors, trans­po­sed figu­res or sim­ply over­loo­king exis­ting docu­ments. The cru­cial point is that the error must not be based on a deli­be­ra­te legal decis­i­on or an assess­ment of the facts. Anyo­ne who makes a mista­ke in the tax assess­ment of a set of facts can­not rely on Sec­tion 129 of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code (AO). Howe­ver, anyo­ne who sim­ply over­looks some­thing can do so.

Court upholds the amendment

The clai­mant objec­ted to the cor­rec­tion, arguing that the con­di­ti­ons set out in sec­tion 129 of the Ger­man Fis­cal Code (AO) had not been met. Howe­ver, the Colo­gne Finan­ce Court did not agree with this view. It was not appa­rent from the case file that the case offi­cer had deli­bera­te­ly dis­re­gard­ed the tax audit report. Ever­y­thing indi­ca­ted that he had sim­ply over­loo­ked the docu­ments. This was a cle­ri­cal error, not an error of law. The amend­ment to the final assess­ment noti­ces was the­r­e­fo­re per­mis­si­ble. The jud­ge­ment was deli­ver­ed on 24 Febru­ary 2026 under case num­ber 11 K 379/22.

What does this mean for taxpayers?

The ruling shows that the fina­li­ty of a tax assess­ment does not offer abso­lu­te cer­tain­ty. If the tax office makes a cle­ri­cal error whilst pro­ces­sing the case, the assess­ment can still be amen­ded years later. For busi­nesses that have under­go­ne a tax audit, this means that even if the ori­gi­nal noti­ce was issued wit­hout taking the audit fin­dings into account and has alre­a­dy beco­me final, the tax office may still imple­ment the fin­dings retrospectively.

The com­men­ta­ry by the Hau­fe expert points to a cer­tain asym­me­try: it is not always the case that the tax court and the tax aut­ho­ri­ties app­ly the cor­rec­tion pro­vi­si­ons with the same degree of leni­en­cy when errors are made by tax­pay­ers. Anyo­ne in a simi­lar situa­ti­on should have the exact cir­cum­s­tances review­ed by a soli­ci­tor or tax adviser.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this