Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Temporary relief: When the 51 per cent threshold triggers repayment

Final state­ments for coro­na­vi­rus sup­port pay­ments: Self-employ­ed indi­vi­du­als working on their own risk having to repay funds due to the 51 per cent main source of inco­me threshold. 
Temporary relief: When the 51 per cent threshold triggers repayment

Temporary relief: When the 51 per cent threshold triggers repayment

Self-employ­ed indi­vi­du­als who appli­ed for bridging sup­port during the coro­na­vi­rus pan­de­mic are coming under incre­asing pres­su­re as the final sett­le­ments are pro­ces­sed. The reason is a eli­gi­bi­li­ty cri­ter­ion that was often not a key focus when the appli­ca­ti­ons were sub­mit­ted: the so-cal­led ‘main source of inco­me’ thres­hold. Anyo­ne who fails to meet this thres­hold faces the pro­s­pect of having to repay the full amount of the funds recei­ved, plus interest.

What is the main source of income threshold?

Self-employ­ed indi­vi­du­als and free­lan­cers wit­hout employees were only per­mit­ted to app­ly for bridging sup­port if they car­ri­ed out their self-employ­ed work as their main source of inco­me. The appro­ving aut­ho­ri­ties defi­ne this in con­cre­te terms: at least 51 per cent of total inco­me must deri­ve from com­mer­cial or free­lan­ce acti­vi­ties, i.e. from the types of inco­me spe­ci­fied in Sec­tion 15 or 18 of the Inco­me Tax Act.

The rele­vant figu­re here is taxa­ble inco­me, not tur­no­ver. The com­pa­ra­ti­ve cal­cu­la­ti­on takes into account all other sources of inco­me: wages from employ­ment, pen­si­on pay­ments and ren­tal inco­me. Accor­ding to the rele­vant FAQs, invest­ment inco­me is excluded. The refe­rence peri­od is gene­ral­ly the calen­dar year 2019, or alter­na­tively Janu­ary or Febru­ary 2020.

Why is it only now that this is happening to so many people?

When sub­mit­ting the appli­ca­ti­on, a simp­le decla­ra­ti­on sta­ting that the appli­cant was in full-time employ­ment was suf­fi­ci­ent. The pay­ment was made as an advan­ce. The actu­al veri­fi­ca­ti­on takes place only during the final sett­le­ment, when the appro­ving aut­ho­ri­ty com­pa­res the infor­ma­ti­on pro­vi­ded with the 2019 inco­me tax assessment.

Anyo­ne who, along­side their self-employ­ment, recei­ves a small pen­si­on, lets out a flat or has been in paid employ­ment from time to time may have fal­len below the 51 per cent thres­hold wit­hout rea­li­sing it. Even a poor finan­cial year in 2019, with low or nega­ti­ve pro­fits, can push the ratio below the thres­hold, even though self-employ­ment was in fact the main focus of their life. The result: the pro­vi­sio­nal appr­oval noti­ce is revo­ked and the enti­re grant is reclaimed.

What do the courts rule?

The case law available to date sup­ports the strict admi­nis­tra­ti­ve prac­ti­ce. In July 2025, the Ham­burg Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court dis­missed the cla­im of a tour ope­ra­tor who­se self-employ­ment inco­me in 2019 was below 51 per cent, becau­se he had also recei­ved a pen­si­on and ren­tal inco­me (jud­ge­ment of 8 July 2025, Ref. 16 K 6134/24). The Würz­burg Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court also con­firm­ed the appli­ca­ti­on of the 51 per cent thres­hold (jud­ge­ment of 17 April 2023, Ref. W 8 K 22.1233). A ruling by the hig­hest court is still pending.

What options are there for defence?

Despi­te the com­plex legal situa­ti­on, the­re are a num­ber of approa­ches worth exploring:

  • Alter­na­ti­ve refe­rence peri­od:If the year 2019 was dis­tor­ted by one-off fac­tors, Janu­ary or Febru­ary 2020 may be used ins­tead. This opti­on should be exer­cis­ed at an ear­ly stage, as courts do not always per­mit it to be exer­cis­ed retro­s­pec­tively during legal proceedings.
  • Check tax clas­si­fi­ca­ti­on:If an inflow was incor­rect­ly attri­bu­ted to 2019, a cor­rec­tion to the inco­me tax assess­ment may affect the rate.
  • Pro­tec­tion of legi­ti­ma­te expec­ta­ti­ons:Anyo­ne who, at the time of sub­mit­ting their appli­ca­ti­on, had reasonable grounds to belie­ve that they were in full-time employ­ment may, in bor­der­line cases, invo­ke the prin­ci­ple of pro­tec­tion of legi­ti­ma­te expec­ta­ti­ons. Howe­ver, if the infor­ma­ti­on pro­vi­ded was objec­tively incor­rect, this defence will not gene­ral­ly be upheld under the rules of admi­nis­tra­ti­ve pro­ce­du­re law.

Please note the deadlines

Anyo­ne who recei­ves a final assess­ment and reco­very noti­ce must ensu­re they meet the dead­line for lodging an appeal. In seve­ral fede­ral sta­tes, legal pro­cee­dings must be brought imme­dia­te­ly, wit­hout first going through an objec­tion pro­ce­du­re. Fail­ure to meet this dead­line pre­cludes any fur­ther recourse.

Tho­se affec­ted should have their case review­ed as soon as pos­si­ble by a soli­ci­tor spe­cia­li­sing in admi­nis­tra­ti­ve or tax law, as the legal and tax aspects are clo­se­ly interlinked.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this