Self-employed individuals who applied for bridging support during the coronavirus pandemic are coming under increasing pressure as the final settlements are processed. The reason is a eligibility criterion that was often not a key focus when the applications were submitted: the so-called ‘main source of income’ threshold. Anyone who fails to meet this threshold faces the prospect of having to repay the full amount of the funds received, plus interest.
What is the main source of income threshold?
Self-employed individuals and freelancers without employees were only permitted to apply for bridging support if they carried out their self-employed work as their main source of income. The approving authorities define this in concrete terms: at least 51 per cent of total income must derive from commercial or freelance activities, i.e. from the types of income specified in Section 15 or 18 of the Income Tax Act.
The relevant figure here is taxable income, not turnover. The comparative calculation takes into account all other sources of income: wages from employment, pension payments and rental income. According to the relevant FAQs, investment income is excluded. The reference period is generally the calendar year 2019, or alternatively January or February 2020.
Why is it only now that this is happening to so many people?
When submitting the application, a simple declaration stating that the applicant was in full-time employment was sufficient. The payment was made as an advance. The actual verification takes place only during the final settlement, when the approving authority compares the information provided with the 2019 income tax assessment.
Anyone who, alongside their self-employment, receives a small pension, lets out a flat or has been in paid employment from time to time may have fallen below the 51 per cent threshold without realising it. Even a poor financial year in 2019, with low or negative profits, can push the ratio below the threshold, even though self-employment was in fact the main focus of their life. The result: the provisional approval notice is revoked and the entire grant is reclaimed.
What do the courts rule?
The case law available to date supports the strict administrative practice. In July 2025, the Hamburg Administrative Court dismissed the claim of a tour operator whose self-employment income in 2019 was below 51 per cent, because he had also received a pension and rental income (judgement of 8 July 2025, Ref. 16 K 6134/24). The Würzburg Administrative Court also confirmed the application of the 51 per cent threshold (judgement of 17 April 2023, Ref. W 8 K 22.1233). A ruling by the highest court is still pending.
What options are there for defence?
Despite the complex legal situation, there are a number of approaches worth exploring:
- Alternative reference period:If the year 2019 was distorted by one-off factors, January or February 2020 may be used instead. This option should be exercised at an early stage, as courts do not always permit it to be exercised retrospectively during legal proceedings.
- Check tax classification:If an inflow was incorrectly attributed to 2019, a correction to the income tax assessment may affect the rate.
- Protection of legitimate expectations:Anyone who, at the time of submitting their application, had reasonable grounds to believe that they were in full-time employment may, in borderline cases, invoke the principle of protection of legitimate expectations. However, if the information provided was objectively incorrect, this defence will not generally be upheld under the rules of administrative procedure law.
Please note the deadlines
Anyone who receives a final assessment and recovery notice must ensure they meet the deadline for lodging an appeal. In several federal states, legal proceedings must be brought immediately, without first going through an objection procedure. Failure to meet this deadline precludes any further recourse.
Those affected should have their case reviewed as soon as possible by a solicitor specialising in administrative or tax law, as the legal and tax aspects are closely interlinked.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.