Anyone who, as part of the settlement of an estate, contributes shares in property-owning companies to a newly formed partnership sometimes hopes to benefit from the tax exemption under Section 6a of the Land Transfer Tax Act (GrEStG). The Federal Fiscal Court has now clarified in a recent judgement that this exemption does not apply if the contributor is merely a group of natural persons who have not formed a company.
What is Section 6a of the GrEStG about?
Land transfer tax is not only payable on a traditional property purchase. It is also triggered when someone acquires at least 95 per cent of the shares in a company that owns a plot of land. The reasoning behind this is that anyone holding such a large proportion of shares is, for economic purposes, equivalent to a landowner.
Section 6a of the Real Estate Transfer Tax Act (GrEStG) provides for a tax exemption for certain restructuring measures within a group of companies. It applies where a controlling company and at least one subsidiary are involved in the transaction. The controlling company must hold at least a 95 per cent stake in the subsidiary for a period of five years, both before and after the transaction.
The case: Three heirs set up a GmbH & Co. KG
Following the death of the testator, three heirs agreed to divide the estate. The estate included, amongst other things, shareholdings in two limited liability companies (GmbHs), each of which owned land. In order to organise the distribution of the estate, the three heirs jointly established a new GmbH & Co. KG and transferred the GmbH shares into this newly formed company.
As a result of the transfer, the new GmbH & Co. KG held all the shares in the two GmbHs for the first time. The tax office subsequently assessed land transfer tax. The heirs argued that the exemption under Section 6a of the Land Transfer Tax Act (GrEStG) must apply, as the transfer had been carried out on the basis of the articles of association.
The Federal Fiscal Court’s ruling
In its judgement of 8 April 2026, the Federal Fiscal Court upheld the tax assessment issued by the tax office (case number II R 2/23). The exemption under section 6a of the Real Estate Transfer Tax Act (GrEStG) did not apply because the key conditions were not met.
- The three heirs, as a group of natural persons not organised as a legal entity under company law, do not constitute a legal entity within the meaning of civil law.
- A mere group of individuals cannot therefore be a controlling undertaking within the meaning of Section 6a of the Real Estate Transfer Tax Act (GrEStG).
- Taken individually, none of the heirs held a stake of at least 95 per cent in the companies contributed.
- The original community of heirs was also excluded because it had been expressly dissolved prior to the transfer.
The Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) emphasised that the scope of application of Section 6a of the Real Estate Transfer Tax Act (GrEStG) is, in principle, broad and that sole traders or natural persons may also qualify as a controlling enterprise. However, the decisive factor is that the entity in question must be a legal entity recognised under civil law which is engaged in economic activity. An informal group of several individuals does not meet this requirement.
What does this mean in practice?
The ruling highlights the importance of careful planning in inheritance disputes where shareholdings in property-owning companies are involved. Land transfer tax may still be payable even if no property changes hands directly. Anyone planning such structures should have the tax implications assessed at an early stage. In individual cases, the choice of structure can make a significant difference to the amount of tax payable. Personalised advice is strongly recommended in such circumstances.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This article was created with the help of AI and has been editorially reviewed.