Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

BFH: No exemption from land transfer tax in the case of the distribution of an estate where there is no controlling company

BFH: Heirs who are not part of a cor­po­ra­te enti­ty can­not cla­im exemp­ti­on from land trans­fer tax under Sec­tion 6a of the Land Trans­fer Tax Act (GrEStG).
BFH: No exemption from land transfer tax in the case of the distribution of an estate where there is no controlling company

BFH: No exemption from land transfer tax in the case of the distribution of an estate where there is no controlling company

Anyo­ne who, as part of the sett­le­ment of an estate, con­tri­bu­tes shares in pro­per­ty-owning com­pa­nies to a new­ly for­med part­ner­ship some­ti­mes hopes to bene­fit from the tax exemp­ti­on under Sec­tion 6a of the Land Trans­fer Tax Act (GrEStG). The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court has now cla­ri­fied in a recent jud­ge­ment that this exemp­ti­on does not app­ly if the con­tri­bu­tor is mere­ly a group of natu­ral per­sons who have not for­med a company.

What is Section 6a of the GrEStG about?

Land trans­fer tax is not only paya­ble on a tra­di­tio­nal pro­per­ty purcha­se. It is also trig­ge­red when someone acqui­res at least 95 per cent of the shares in a com­pa­ny that owns a plot of land. The reaso­ning behind this is that anyo­ne hol­ding such a lar­ge pro­por­ti­on of shares is, for eco­no­mic pur­po­ses, equi­va­lent to a landowner.

Sec­tion 6a of the Real Estate Trans­fer Tax Act (GrEStG) pro­vi­des for a tax exemp­ti­on for cer­tain res­truc­tu­ring mea­su­res within a group of com­pa­nies. It appli­es whe­re a con­trol­ling com­pa­ny and at least one sub­si­dia­ry are invol­ved in the tran­sac­tion. The con­trol­ling com­pa­ny must hold at least a 95 per cent sta­ke in the sub­si­dia­ry for a peri­od of five years, both befo­re and after the transaction.

The case: Three heirs set up a GmbH & Co. KG

Fol­lo­wing the death of the test­a­tor, three heirs agreed to divi­de the estate. The estate included, among­st other things, share­hol­dings in two limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­nies (GmbHs), each of which owned land. In order to orga­ni­se the dis­tri­bu­ti­on of the estate, the three heirs joint­ly estab­lished a new GmbH & Co. KG and trans­fer­red the GmbH shares into this new­ly for­med company.

As a result of the trans­fer, the new GmbH & Co. KG held all the shares in the two GmbHs for the first time. The tax office sub­se­quent­ly asses­sed land trans­fer tax. The heirs argued that the exemp­ti­on under Sec­tion 6a of the Land Trans­fer Tax Act (GrEStG) must app­ly, as the trans­fer had been car­ri­ed out on the basis of the artic­les of association.

The Federal Fiscal Court’s ruling

In its jud­ge­ment of 8 April 2026, the Fede­ral Fis­cal Court upheld the tax assess­ment issued by the tax office (case num­ber II R 2/23). The exemp­ti­on under sec­tion 6a of the Real Estate Trans­fer Tax Act (GrEStG) did not app­ly becau­se the key con­di­ti­ons were not met.

  • The three heirs, as a group of natu­ral per­sons not orga­nis­ed as a legal enti­ty under com­pa­ny law, do not con­sti­tu­te a legal enti­ty within the mea­ning of civil law.
  • A mere group of indi­vi­du­als can­not the­r­e­fo­re be a con­trol­ling under­ta­king within the mea­ning of Sec­tion 6a of the Real Estate Trans­fer Tax Act (GrEStG).
  • Taken indi­vi­du­al­ly, none of the heirs held a sta­ke of at least 95 per cent in the com­pa­nies contributed.
  • The ori­gi­nal com­mu­ni­ty of heirs was also excluded becau­se it had been express­ly dis­sol­ved pri­or to the transfer.

The Fede­ral Fis­cal Court (BFH) empha­sis­ed that the scope of appli­ca­ti­on of Sec­tion 6a of the Real Estate Trans­fer Tax Act (GrEStG) is, in prin­ci­ple, broad and that sole trad­ers or natu­ral per­sons may also qua­li­fy as a con­trol­ling enter­pri­se. Howe­ver, the decisi­ve fac­tor is that the enti­ty in ques­ti­on must be a legal enti­ty reco­g­nis­ed under civil law which is enga­ged in eco­no­mic acti­vi­ty. An infor­mal group of seve­ral indi­vi­du­als does not meet this requirement.

What does this mean in practice?

The ruling high­lights the importance of careful plan­ning in inhe­ri­tance dis­pu­tes whe­re share­hol­dings in pro­per­ty-owning com­pa­nies are invol­ved. Land trans­fer tax may still be paya­ble even if no pro­per­ty chan­ges hands direct­ly. Anyo­ne plan­ning such struc­tures should have the tax impli­ca­ti­ons asses­sed at an ear­ly stage. In indi­vi­du­al cases, the choice of struc­tu­re can make a signi­fi­cant dif­fe­rence to the amount of tax paya­ble. Per­so­na­li­sed advice is stron­gly recom­men­ded in such circumstances.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This artic­le was crea­ted with the help of AI and has been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this