Anyone who has to defend themselves in criminal proceedings often wonders whether the legal fees incurred are tax-deductible. A recent ruling by the Lower Saxony Finance Court provides a surprisingly clear answer to this question, at least in cases where the final sentence consists solely of a custodial sentence.
The facts of the case: Commercial director in court
A commercial director of a group of companies was involved in a scheme to evade value-added tax using bogus invoices and undeclared labour. The Regional Court sentenced him to a total of two years’ imprisonment, suspended, for ten counts of tax evasion. No fine was imposed, and the proceeds of the offence were not confiscated.
The man incurred costs of 50,000 euros for his criminal defence. His employer transferred this amount directly to the criminal defence lawyer on the basis of a loan agreement. In his income tax return for 2021, the claimant claimed these costs as retrospective income-related expenses arising from his employment.
The tax office refused to allow the deduction
The tax office refused to allow the deduction for several reasons. It doubted that the claimant had actually incurred the costs for business purposes, as there was no evidence of the loan having been repaid. Furthermore, the authority considered that there was a private motive involved in the form of so-called kickback payments which the claimant had received. Finally, the tax office invoked the prohibition on tax deductions under Section 12(4) of the Income Tax Act, which, since 2019, has also been extended to cover expenses relating to corresponding sanctions.
The Tax Court ruled otherwise
In its judgement of 14 July 2026 (case number 13 K 108/25), the Lower Saxony Finance Court ruled in favour of the claimant. It first recognised that the costs of the criminal defence were work-related, as the allegations arose directly from the claimant’s professional activities. The payment by the employer via a loan agreement merely constituted a so-called ‘abbreviated payment method’ and did not prevent the deduction. Whether the loan was actually repaid at a later date was irrelevant for the tax year in question.
The crucial point, however, was the issue of the prohibition on deduction. The court made it clear that the prohibition on deduction under Section 12(4) of the Income Tax Act, in its extended form, relates to expenses associated with a fine or any other of the sanctions specified therein. In the present case, however, only a custodial sentence was imposed, which is not listed in that provision.
The court rejected a proposal to extend the ban to the entire criminal proceedings. It pointed out that, if this were the case, defence costs incurred following an acquittal would consequently also be non-deductible, which would contravene the tax law principle of taxation according to economic capacity.
Appeal pending before the Federal Fiscal Court
The proceedings are therefore not yet concluded. The Finance Court has expressly permitted an appeal to the Federal Finance Court, and such an appeal has been lodged. The case is pending before the Federal Finance Court under reference number VI R 10/26. It remains to be seen how the highest tax judges will assess the scope of the prohibition on deductions in the case of custodial sentences.
Anyone who finds themselves in a similar situation and wishes to claim criminal defence costs as a tax deduction should consult a tax adviser or a specialist law firm to check whether the conditions are met in their specific case.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.