Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Criminal defence costs as income-related expenses: What applies in the case of a custodial sentence?

Criminal defence costs as income-related expenses: What applies in the case of a custodial sentence?

Anyo­ne who has to defend them­sel­ves in cri­mi­nal pro­cee­dings often won­ders whe­ther the legal fees incur­red are tax-deduc­ti­ble. A recent ruling by the Lower Sax­o­ny Finan­ce Court pro­vi­des a sur­pri­sin­gly clear ans­wer to this ques­ti­on, at least in cases whe­re the final sen­tence con­sists sole­ly of a cus­to­di­al sentence.

The facts of the case: Commercial director in court

A com­mer­cial direc­tor of a group of com­pa­nies was invol­ved in a sche­me to eva­de value-added tax using bogus invoices and unde­clared labour. The Regio­nal Court sen­ten­ced him to a total of two years’ impri­son­ment, sus­pen­ded, for ten counts of tax eva­si­on. No fine was impo­sed, and the pro­ceeds of the offence were not confiscated.

The man incur­red cos­ts of 50,000 euros for his cri­mi­nal defence. His employ­er trans­fer­red this amount direct­ly to the cri­mi­nal defence lawy­er on the basis of a loan agree­ment. In his inco­me tax return for 2021, the clai­mant clai­med the­se cos­ts as retro­s­pec­ti­ve inco­me-rela­ted expen­ses ari­sing from his employment.

The tax office refused to allow the deduction

The tax office refu­sed to allow the deduc­tion for seve­ral reasons. It doub­ted that the clai­mant had actual­ly incur­red the cos­ts for busi­ness pur­po­ses, as the­re was no evi­dence of the loan having been repaid. Fur­ther­mo­re, the aut­ho­ri­ty con­side­red that the­re was a pri­va­te moti­ve invol­ved in the form of so-cal­led kick­back pay­ments which the clai­mant had recei­ved. Final­ly, the tax office invo­ked the pro­hi­bi­ti­on on tax deduc­tions under Sec­tion 12(4) of the Inco­me Tax Act, which, sin­ce 2019, has also been exten­ded to cover expen­ses rela­ting to cor­re­spon­ding sanctions.

The Tax Court ruled otherwise

In its jud­ge­ment of 14 July 2026 (case num­ber 13 K 108/25), the Lower Sax­o­ny Finan­ce Court ruled in favour of the clai­mant. It first reco­g­nis­ed that the cos­ts of the cri­mi­nal defence were work-rela­ted, as the alle­ga­ti­ons aro­se direct­ly from the claimant’s pro­fes­sio­nal acti­vi­ties. The pay­ment by the employ­er via a loan agree­ment mere­ly con­sti­tu­ted a so-cal­led ‘abbre­via­ted pay­ment method’ and did not pre­vent the deduc­tion. Whe­ther the loan was actual­ly repaid at a later date was irrele­vant for the tax year in question.

The cru­cial point, howe­ver, was the issue of the pro­hi­bi­ti­on on deduc­tion. The court made it clear that the pro­hi­bi­ti­on on deduc­tion under Sec­tion 12(4) of the Inco­me Tax Act, in its exten­ded form, rela­tes to expen­ses asso­cia­ted with a fine or any other of the sanc­tions spe­ci­fied the­r­ein. In the pre­sent case, howe­ver, only a cus­to­di­al sen­tence was impo­sed, which is not lis­ted in that provision.

The court rejec­ted a pro­po­sal to extend the ban to the enti­re cri­mi­nal pro­cee­dings. It poin­ted out that, if this were the case, defence cos­ts incur­red fol­lo­wing an acquit­tal would con­se­quent­ly also be non-deduc­ti­ble, which would con­tra­ve­ne the tax law prin­ci­ple of taxa­ti­on accor­ding to eco­no­mic capacity.

Appeal pending before the Federal Fiscal Court

The pro­cee­dings are the­r­e­fo­re not yet con­cluded. The Finan­ce Court has express­ly per­mit­ted an appeal to the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court, and such an appeal has been lodged. The case is pen­ding befo­re the Fede­ral Finan­ce Court under refe­rence num­ber VI R 10/26. It remains to be seen how the hig­hest tax jud­ges will assess the scope of the pro­hi­bi­ti­on on deduc­tions in the case of cus­to­di­al sentences.

Anyo­ne who finds them­sel­ves in a simi­lar situa­ti­on and wis­hes to cla­im cri­mi­nal defence cos­ts as a tax deduc­tion should con­sult a tax advi­ser or a spe­cia­list law firm to check whe­ther the con­di­ti­ons are met in their spe­ci­fic case.

Source: Hau­fe: Tax

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this