Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Coronavirus support: Düsseldorf Administrative Court strengthens rights regarding final settlements

Coronavirus support: Düsseldorf Administrative Court strengthens rights regarding final settlements

Anyo­ne who has recei­ved a final decis­i­on under the Coro­na Restart Aid sche­me and has been asked to repay the funds can brea­the a sigh of reli­ef: In its jud­ge­ment of 9 July 2026 (Case No. 9 K 9788/24), the Düs­sel­dorf Admi­nis­tra­ti­ve Court has set asi­de such a final decis­i­on and orde­red the aut­ho­ri­ty to issue a new decis­i­on. The ruling is of con­sidera­ble prac­ti­cal signi­fi­can­ce for all tho­se affec­ted by final state­ments rela­ting to coro­na­vi­rus aid.

The case: A self-employed individual is to repay 7,500 euros

In Octo­ber 2021, a work­place health manage­ment con­sul­tant had appli­ed for the ‘Restart Grant’ for the first half of 2021 and was award­ed 7,500 euros. Years later, as part of the final sett­le­ment, the dis­trict govern­ment deman­ded the return of the enti­re sum. Reason given: the appli­cant had not car­ri­ed out her self-employ­ed work as her so-cal­led ‘main source of inco­me’. Her 2019 inco­me tax assess­ment show­ed that her free­lan­ce ear­nings accoun­ted for only around 39 per cent of her total inco­me, and were the­r­e­fo­re below the rele­vant 51 per cent threshold.

Howe­ver, the woman in ques­ti­on had poin­ted out that she had only set up her own busi­ness in 2018 and was still recei­ving a start-up grant in 2019. Her busi­ness only real­ly got off the ground in the fourth quar­ter of 2019.

The authorities should have investigated the matter more thoroughly

The court did not set asi­de the final decis­i­on on the grounds that the cla­im for repay­ment was inad­mis­si­ble in prin­ci­ple. The decisi­ve fac­tor was a dif­fe­rent point: In rea­ching its decis­i­on, the aut­ho­ri­ty had only taken the who­le of 2019 into account and had fai­led to exami­ne whe­ther the appli­cant had in fact car­ri­ed out her self-employ­ed work as her main source of inco­me in Janu­ary or Febru­ary 2020. Yet, accor­ding to the fun­ding gui­de­lines, this would pre­cis­e­ly have been pos­si­ble as an alter­na­ti­ve refe­rence period.

The court empha­si­s­es that if an appli­cant pro­vi­des spe­ci­fic evi­dence that might sug­gest a dif­fe­rent assess­ment, the aut­ho­ri­ty is obli­ged to inves­ti­ga­te this on its own initia­ti­ve. It must not sim­ply base its decis­i­on on the first available data set whilst igno­ring obvious alter­na­ti­ves. This prin­ci­ple of what is known as ‘ex offi­cio inves­ti­ga­ti­on’ also appli­es whe­re sub­s­idy reci­pi­ents are, in prin­ci­ple, sub­ject to heigh­ten­ed obli­ga­ti­ons to cooperate.

An important related question: When is a decision deemed to have been served?

The court also had to rule on a pro­ce­du­ral issue. The final decis­i­on had been made available via an online por­tal. The aut­ho­ri­ty assu­med that this meant it was auto­ma­ti­cal­ly dee­med to have been ser­ved. Howe­ver, the appli­cant had only beco­me awa­re of it much later becau­se she was initi­al­ly unable to log into her user account.

The court ruled that such a pre­sump­ti­on of auto­ma­tic noti­fi­ca­ti­on requi­res the user’s express con­sent. Anyo­ne who has mere­ly sta­ted that they wish to recei­ve noti­ces by email has not ther­eby con­sen­ted to having to actively log in to a por­tal and down­load docu­ments them­sel­ves. The time limit for brin­ging a cla­im the­r­e­fo­re only began to run from the moment the user actual­ly beca­me awa­re of the noti­ce. The cla­im was the­r­e­fo­re lodged in good time.

What does this mean for those affected?

The ruling con­veys two prac­ti­cal mes­sa­ges. First­ly, anyo­ne who has recei­ved a final decis­i­on orde­ring repay­ment and belie­ves that the aut­ho­ri­ty has fai­led to take exo­ne­ra­ting cir­cum­s­tances into account should have this spe­ci­fi­cal­ly review­ed. Second­ly, anyo­ne who is unsu­re whe­ther a time limit for brin­ging a cla­im has actual­ly expi­red becau­se a noti­ce was made available via a digi­tal por­tal should seek legal advice. The ques­ti­on of whe­ther the noti­ce was valid­ly ser­ved can deter­mi­ne the suc­cess or fail­ure of an appeal.

The jud­ge­ment is not yet final. If you have any ques­ti­ons regar­ding your own final tax assess­ment, it is advi­sa­ble to seek advice from a tax advi­ser or soli­ci­tor on a case-by-case basis.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this