Anyone who has received a final decision under the Corona Restart Aid scheme and has been asked to repay the funds can breathe a sigh of relief: In its judgement of 9 July 2026 (Case No. 9 K 9788/24), the Düsseldorf Administrative Court has set aside such a final decision and ordered the authority to issue a new decision. The ruling is of considerable practical significance for all those affected by final statements relating to coronavirus aid.
The case: A self-employed individual is to repay 7,500 euros
In October 2021, a workplace health management consultant had applied for the ‘Restart Grant’ for the first half of 2021 and was awarded 7,500 euros. Years later, as part of the final settlement, the district government demanded the return of the entire sum. Reason given: the applicant had not carried out her self-employed work as her so-called ‘main source of income’. Her 2019 income tax assessment showed that her freelance earnings accounted for only around 39 per cent of her total income, and were therefore below the relevant 51 per cent threshold.
However, the woman in question had pointed out that she had only set up her own business in 2018 and was still receiving a start-up grant in 2019. Her business only really got off the ground in the fourth quarter of 2019.
The authorities should have investigated the matter more thoroughly
The court did not set aside the final decision on the grounds that the claim for repayment was inadmissible in principle. The decisive factor was a different point: In reaching its decision, the authority had only taken the whole of 2019 into account and had failed to examine whether the applicant had in fact carried out her self-employed work as her main source of income in January or February 2020. Yet, according to the funding guidelines, this would precisely have been possible as an alternative reference period.
The court emphasises that if an applicant provides specific evidence that might suggest a different assessment, the authority is obliged to investigate this on its own initiative. It must not simply base its decision on the first available data set whilst ignoring obvious alternatives. This principle of what is known as ‘ex officio investigation’ also applies where subsidy recipients are, in principle, subject to heightened obligations to cooperate.
An important related question: When is a decision deemed to have been served?
The court also had to rule on a procedural issue. The final decision had been made available via an online portal. The authority assumed that this meant it was automatically deemed to have been served. However, the applicant had only become aware of it much later because she was initially unable to log into her user account.
The court ruled that such a presumption of automatic notification requires the user’s express consent. Anyone who has merely stated that they wish to receive notices by email has not thereby consented to having to actively log in to a portal and download documents themselves. The time limit for bringing a claim therefore only began to run from the moment the user actually became aware of the notice. The claim was therefore lodged in good time.
What does this mean for those affected?
The ruling conveys two practical messages. Firstly, anyone who has received a final decision ordering repayment and believes that the authority has failed to take exonerating circumstances into account should have this specifically reviewed. Secondly, anyone who is unsure whether a time limit for bringing a claim has actually expired because a notice was made available via a digital portal should seek legal advice. The question of whether the notice was validly served can determine the success or failure of an appeal.
The judgement is not yet final. If you have any questions regarding your own final tax assessment, it is advisable to seek advice from a tax adviser or solicitor on a case-by-case basis.
Source: Haufe: Tax
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.