Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

Federal Court of Justice: Tenants always have the right to information regarding the rent cap

Federal Court of Justice: Tenants always have the right to information regarding the rent cap

Anyo­ne living in a flat sub­ject to the rent con­trol sche­me is entit­led to request cer­tain infor­ma­ti­on from their land­lord. This is, in its­elf, com­mon know­ledge. The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce has now cla­ri­fied that this right to infor­ma­ti­on also appli­es if the land­lord has brea­ched their pre-con­trac­tu­al duty to pro­vi­de infor­ma­ti­on and is the­r­e­fo­re not initi­al­ly entit­led to invo­ke any excep­ti­ons to the rent con­trol sche­me. The jud­ge­ment is dated 1 July 2026 (Case No. VIII ZR 211/23).

What had happened?

A ten­ant had ren­ted a flat in Ber­lin in April 2021. The rent cap has been in force in Ber­lin sin­ce June 2015. Befo­re the ten­an­cy agree­ment was signed, the land­lord had not infor­med the ten­ant whe­ther, and if so why, a hig­her rent might be per­mis­si­ble – for exam­p­le, due to a pre­vious rent pro­tec­ted under the rent con­trol sche­me or moder­ni­sa­ti­on work that had been car­ri­ed out. The ten­ant con­side­red the agreed rent to be too high and, through a debt coll­ec­tion agen­cy, reques­ted infor­ma­ti­on on, among­st other things, the pre­vious rent, past rent increa­ses and moder­ni­sa­ti­on work car­ri­ed out, as well as clai­ming a refund of over­paid rent.

The Regio­nal Court dis­missed the cla­im for infor­ma­ti­on. Its reaso­ning was that, as the land­lord had fai­led to ful­fil her pre-con­trac­tu­al obli­ga­ti­on, she could not, in any event, invo­ke any excep­ti­ons. The infor­ma­ti­on would the­r­e­fo­re be of no use to the ten­ant; the­re was no inte­rest wort­hy of protection.

The Federal Court of Justice takes a different view

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) over­tur­ned this ruling. In the court’s view, the decisi­ve fac­tor is that the ban on appeals does not app­ly to the land­lord on a per­ma­nent basis. If the land­lord sub­se­quent­ly pro­vi­des the ten­ant with the infor­ma­ti­on that was pre­vious­ly omit­ted, a two-year peri­od beg­ins to run. Once this peri­od has expi­red, the land­lord may invo­ke excep­tio­nal cir­cum­s­tances, such as pri­or ten­an­cy or moder­ni­sa­ti­on works, and, whe­re appro­pria­te, demand a rent that is more than ten per cent abo­ve the local com­pa­ra­ti­ve rent.

This is pre­cis­e­ly why, in the view of the Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce, the ten­ant has a legi­ti­ma­te inte­rest in obtai­ning this infor­ma­ti­on. He wis­hes to know which facts might be rele­vant to future rent increa­ses, so that he can assess his rights going forward.

Two separate obligations to provide information

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce empha­si­s­es that the­re are two sepa­ra­te obli­ga­ti­ons to pro­vi­de information:

  • Pre-con­trac­tu­al duty to pro­vi­de infor­ma­ti­on (Sec­tion 556g(1a), first sen­tence, of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB)):If the land­lord wis­hes to jus­ti­fy a hig­her rent on the basis of an excep­tio­nal cir­cum­s­tance, they must inform the ten­ant of this of their own accord befo­re the ten­an­cy agree­ment is con­cluded. If they fail to do so, they can­not initi­al­ly invo­ke the pre­vious rent or moder­ni­sa­ti­on as grounds.
  • Infor­ma­ti­on on request (Sec­tion 556g(3) of the Ger­man Civil Code (BGB)):Irre­spec­ti­ve of this, the ten­ant may at any time request infor­ma­ti­on regar­ding all facts that are rele­vant to the vali­di­ty of the agreed rent. This right remains in force even if the pre-con­trac­tu­al obli­ga­ti­on has been breached.

Risk to the tenant: The notification triggers a time limit

The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce (BGH) express­ly points out that the request for infor­ma­ti­on may also be dis­ad­van­ta­ge­ous to the ten­ant. This is becau­se if the ten­ant requests the infor­ma­ti­on and the land­lord pro­vi­des it, this may trig­ger the start of the two-year peri­od after which the land­lord can invo­ke a hig­her rent. It is up to each ten­ant to weigh up for them­sel­ves whe­ther this is advi­sa­ble. If they choo­se not to request the infor­ma­ti­on, they also accept that they will remain in the dark about poten­ti­al future risks of rent increases.

If a ten­ant deci­des to make a request for infor­ma­ti­on, the court can­not deny them legal pro­tec­tion on the grounds that they lack the neces­sa­ry need for legal pro­tec­tion. The Fede­ral Court of Jus­ti­ce has now cla­ri­fied this.

For ten­ants in are­as sub­ject to rent con­trol, it is advi­sa­ble to seek legal advice in case of doubt befo­re sub­mit­ting a for­mal request for infor­ma­ti­on or asser­ting claims for reimbursement.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this