Anyone living in a flat subject to the rent control scheme is entitled to request certain information from their landlord. This is, in itself, common knowledge. The Federal Court of Justice has now clarified that this right to information also applies if the landlord has breached their pre-contractual duty to provide information and is therefore not initially entitled to invoke any exceptions to the rent control scheme. The judgement is dated 1 July 2026 (Case No. VIII ZR 211/23).
What had happened?
A tenant had rented a flat in Berlin in April 2021. The rent cap has been in force in Berlin since June 2015. Before the tenancy agreement was signed, the landlord had not informed the tenant whether, and if so why, a higher rent might be permissible – for example, due to a previous rent protected under the rent control scheme or modernisation work that had been carried out. The tenant considered the agreed rent to be too high and, through a debt collection agency, requested information on, amongst other things, the previous rent, past rent increases and modernisation work carried out, as well as claiming a refund of overpaid rent.
The Regional Court dismissed the claim for information. Its reasoning was that, as the landlord had failed to fulfil her pre-contractual obligation, she could not, in any event, invoke any exceptions. The information would therefore be of no use to the tenant; there was no interest worthy of protection.
The Federal Court of Justice takes a different view
The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) overturned this ruling. In the court’s view, the decisive factor is that the ban on appeals does not apply to the landlord on a permanent basis. If the landlord subsequently provides the tenant with the information that was previously omitted, a two-year period begins to run. Once this period has expired, the landlord may invoke exceptional circumstances, such as prior tenancy or modernisation works, and, where appropriate, demand a rent that is more than ten per cent above the local comparative rent.
This is precisely why, in the view of the Federal Court of Justice, the tenant has a legitimate interest in obtaining this information. He wishes to know which facts might be relevant to future rent increases, so that he can assess his rights going forward.
Two separate obligations to provide information
The Federal Court of Justice emphasises that there are two separate obligations to provide information:
- Pre-contractual duty to provide information (Section 556g(1a), first sentence, of the German Civil Code (BGB)):If the landlord wishes to justify a higher rent on the basis of an exceptional circumstance, they must inform the tenant of this of their own accord before the tenancy agreement is concluded. If they fail to do so, they cannot initially invoke the previous rent or modernisation as grounds.
- Information on request (Section 556g(3) of the German Civil Code (BGB)):Irrespective of this, the tenant may at any time request information regarding all facts that are relevant to the validity of the agreed rent. This right remains in force even if the pre-contractual obligation has been breached.
Risk to the tenant: The notification triggers a time limit
The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) expressly points out that the request for information may also be disadvantageous to the tenant. This is because if the tenant requests the information and the landlord provides it, this may trigger the start of the two-year period after which the landlord can invoke a higher rent. It is up to each tenant to weigh up for themselves whether this is advisable. If they choose not to request the information, they also accept that they will remain in the dark about potential future risks of rent increases.
If a tenant decides to make a request for information, the court cannot deny them legal protection on the grounds that they lack the necessary need for legal protection. The Federal Court of Justice has now clarified this.
For tenants in areas subject to rent control, it is advisable to seek legal advice in case of doubt before submitting a formal request for information or asserting claims for reimbursement.
Source: Haufe: Property
This post and the accompanying image were created with the help of AI and have been editorially reviewed.