Ina Ree­se Tax & Legal Prac­ti­ce – Flens­burg | Harrislee

AI errors, directors’ liability: What managing directors need to know now

AI errors, directors’ liability: What managing directors need to know now

Arti­fi­ci­al intel­li­gence is taking on an incre­asing num­ber of tasks within com­pa­nies: it ana­ly­ses mar­kets, eva­lua­tes figu­res and pre­pa­res decis­i­ons. Howe­ver, if an AI-based ana­ly­sis is incor­rect and the com­pa­ny suf­fers a loss as a result, a very prac­ti­cal ques­ti­on ari­ses: who is liable?

The answer is clear: the Executive Board

No mat­ter how sophisti­ca­ted the AI sys­tem used may be, legal respon­si­bi­li­ty for busi­ness decis­i­ons remains with the gover­ning body. This appli­es equal­ly to the board of direc­tors of a public limi­t­ed com­pa­ny and to the mana­ging direc­tors of a limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­ny. AI can assist in the pre­pa­ra­ti­on of decis­i­ons, but it can­not deve­lop inde­pen­dent jud­ge­ment nor con­tri­bu­te com­pa­ny-spe­ci­fic experience.

Howe­ver, this is pre­cis­e­ly what is cru­cial when it comes to the so-cal­led ‘busi­ness jud­ge­ment rule’. This pro­vi­si­on under com­pa­ny law pro­tects board mem­bers from per­so­nal lia­bi­li­ty if they have taken a busi­ness decis­i­on in good faith, on the basis of ade­qua­te infor­ma­ti­on and in the inte­rests of the com­pa­ny. Howe­ver, anyo­ne who sim­ply accepts AI results wit­hout scru­ti­ni­s­ing them cri­ti­cal­ly and app­ly­ing their own jud­ge­ment can­not rely on this protection.

AI is no substitute for an expert opinion

Ano­ther mis­con­cep­ti­on is beco­ming wide­spread in prac­ti­ce: many mana­gers tre­at AI ana­ly­ses as if they were expert reports from an exter­nal spe­cia­list. This is legal­ly pro­ble­ma­tic. An expert opi­ni­on only exo­ne­ra­tes a gover­ning body if the expert is genui­ne­ly com­pe­tent, has not been given any result-ori­en­ted ins­truc­tions and was ful­ly awa­re of all rele­vant infor­ma­ti­on. As things stand, AI can­not meet the­se requi­re­ments. An erro­n­eous AI result the­r­e­fo­re does not have the same legal impli­ca­ti­ons in terms of lia­bi­li­ty as a human expert opinion.

What must be documented

Anyo­ne who incor­po­ra­tes AI into decis­i­on-making pro­ces­ses should careful­ly docu­ment its use. It must be pos­si­ble to ascer­tain, in retro­s­pect, on what infor­ma­ti­on a decis­i­on was based. The docu­men­ta­ti­on should include, in particular:

  • Name of the per­son who used the AI, and the date of use
  • Name and ver­si­on of the AI tool used
  • Inputs and prompts used, as well as uploa­ded documents
  • Che­cking the results for con­text, time­line­ss and sources
  • Com­pli­ance with inter­nal appr­oval processes

Prompts and results should be saved as PDF files whe­re­ver pos­si­ble, as many AI tools do not offer per­ma­nent storage.

The EU AI Act introduces additional obligations

The EU AI Act clas­si­fies cer­tain AI appli­ca­ti­ons as high-risk and requi­res, among­st other things, a risk manage­ment sys­tem that must be kept up to date, as well as strict docu­men­ta­ti­on requi­re­ments. Anyo­ne who igno­res the­se regu­la­to­ry requi­re­ments is in breach of the so-cal­led duty of lega­li­ty and ther­eby expo­ses them­sel­ves to an addi­tio­nal lia­bi­li­ty risk. AI is the­r­e­fo­re not just a tech­no­lo­gi­cal issue, but a genui­ne com­pli­ance issue.

What this means for managing directors of limited liability companies (GmbHs)

Alt­hough the dis­cus­sion often rela­tes to the exe­cu­ti­ve boards of public limi­t­ed com­pa­nies, the prin­ci­ples app­ly equal­ly to mana­ging direc­tors of limi­t­ed lia­bi­li­ty com­pa­nies (GmbHs). Anyo­ne who uses AI in day-to-day ope­ra­ti­ons – for exam­p­le, for finan­cial ana­ly­sis, HR decis­i­ons or stra­te­gic plan­ning – should intro­du­ce clear inter­nal rules, train staff and regu­lar­ly review the use of AI. The atti­tu­de that ‘the IT depart­ment or the legal depart­ment will sort it out’ is not enough. Respon­si­bi­li­ty can­not be delegated.

Com­pa­nies that are alre­a­dy making exten­si­ve use of AI, or are plan­ning to do so, should cla­ri­fy lia­bi­li­ty issues at an ear­ly stage. Legal advice can help them to deve­lop appro­pria­te pro­ces­ses and docu­men­ta­ti­on structures.

This post and the accom­pany­ing image were crea­ted with the help of AI and have been edi­to­ri­al­ly reviewed.

You might also be interested in this